Mod of the Year 2007

Welcome to Mod DB and the 6th Annual Mod of the Year Awards - the definative event that showcases the best mods and indie games in the world and recognizes the teams behind them. The MOTY is a tribute to the creativity, dedication & hard work independent developers put into creating unique gaming experiences that enable us to "play something different".

Over the coming months we will showcase to you the best mods and games in the industry. You vote for those you believe are worthy of recognition. At the top of this program sits the ultimate prize, the mod of the year award won previously by Natural Selection, Red Orchestra, PoE2 and Garry's Mod. Thanks to our sponsors, this year we have a few surprizes up our sleaves not to mention a slew of prizes for the participating teams.

From Dec 1st to Jan 1st, industry professionals, developers, gamers and the general public cast their votes to decide which mods define the cutting edge of interactive entertainment and which mod teams attain gaming celebrity.

Follow the links to join us on an unforgettable journey as we present the 2007 Mod of the Year.

Navy MOTY 2007 SponsorAMD MOTY 2007 SponsorNVousPC MOTY 2007 SponsorAIO MOTY 2007 SponsorLogitech MOTY 2007 Sponsor
Report article RSS Feed Editor's Choice Winners Showcase

Editor's Choice is here! See what Mod DB editors have picked as their most notable of 2007.

Posted by stenchy on Feb 4th, 2008
Event Coverage

Editors Choice

Now that the Mod of the Year contest has finished and the winners have been revealed, it seems like the popular choices of the year were the realistic military shooters of the multiplayer variety. While most enjoy a good shooter that focuses on tactical realism, I can say with great certainty that I'm burned out on the genre for a while. I've logged many hours playing the top 5 of this year to see what all the winners had to offer and while they are all worthy, it was almost too much of a good thing.

Taking nominations from the staff and doing some digging myself, I've come up with a list of shining gems from our very own database. The list focuses on projects that have been pushed to the sidelines in a flood of constant media and news updates, yet merit some of their own time under the spotlight. Each of them embodies the overall spirit of modding in their effort to introduce new concepts and gaming experiences. You might also notice that this year there are no specific awards or ranking. ModDB has done away with the categorization this year to just focus on the gaming experience that each offering provides (or hopes to provide). Most of all, we tried to represent the many facets of the modding community with these choices, including the quality and variety available. Without further ado, here are the 2007 Editor's Choice winners:

Mind

(Unreleased: Doom 3, Singleplayer)
Mind is one man's journey through the minimalistic spaces in his own head as he tries to comprehend the dire situation he's placed in. At least, that what I gathered from the information provided:

"Your name is Jack and you're under arrest. They say you were on drugs. They say you killed your wife. All you know is the back of the police car smells like vomit. Maybe you are on drugs because now you're seeing things .... and suddenly ... you're very ... tired...."

In any case, Mind promises to be a puzzle oriented game with no firearms involved. The only weapons being your fists, flares and some telekinesis thrown in for good measure. The footage below shows the unique style and situations they are aiming for. The aesthetics of the level design concentrate the focus on a surreal environment where anything can happen. Mind is being put together on the ID Tech 4 Engine accompanied with an original soundtrack. So far, the release date is unannounced, but we look forward to Mind bringing us an intellectually challenging experience.

Temple Ruins The City


E.Y.E.

(Unreleased: Half Life 2, Singleplayer/Multiplayer)
Inspired from a custom RPG board game made from the creators in 1998, E.Y.E. is an evolution of a concept that the development team has been shaping for years. What does E.Y.E. stand for? I have no idea, but they are group of elite rebel warriors trained in "cyber and parapsychic arts" that fight against the oppressive multi-planetary government referred to as the 'Federation'.

Equal parts RPG and FPS, E.Y.E. will not only incorporate single player and multiplayer but tie the two together, presumably through some sort of character progression. Released footage is almost 6 months old, but shows an encouraging amount of polish with their own adept AI system included as well. One can only assume that a possible beta is on the horizon. This mod goes above and beyond the task of just creating another point-and-shoot clone. It aims to create a wholly unique experience on the Source platform.

Temple screenshot Temple Level Screenshot #1



Eternal Silence

(Half Life 2, Multiplayer)
Disrupt the blackness of space with dizzying space combat. Invade and conquer the opposing faction's capital ship before they can do the same to you. Eternal Silence brings a welcome change to the shooter genre by intertwining it with a healthy dose of space sim. It allows for two different game archetypes to co-exist within the same space and pulls it off with grace. While this mod has its dedicated group of small players, it surprises me that it isn't more popular considering its more than just your ground troop warfare variety. The Eternal Silence team themselves have been releasing a steady stream of updates and it sounds like they are in the final stages of a major update. In the meantime though, do yourself a favor (if you own Half-Life 2) and check this one out.

ES_Asteroid Space Combat 2 Sad Face!


C&C Generals: Shockwave

(C&C Generals Zero Hour, Singleplayer/Multiplayer)
Fans of the Command & Conquer series have always enjoyed variety within their games and Shockwave certainly delivers on that point. A plethora of new units and 3 brand new generals await you here. Shockwave hearkens back to the old days of modding when not everything had to be a total conversion and players were just happy with adding on to an existing experience. Unit and general diversity adds even more customization and options that allow you to further tailor your play style. Compete online or tackle the new challenge maps made with each of the new generals in mind. Custom made sound effects, music and particles also compliment the new additions to this mod. All of this makes C&C Generals: Shockwave a must have.

new R.A.D. tank for General Tao Scourge Missile launcher for Dr. Thrax


Paranoia

(Half Life 1, Singleplayer)
Paranoia manages to look, sound and play great. The kicker here is: it's doing it on the Half Life 1 engine. While the technical merits alone allow Paranoia to compete for attention amongst its current generation rivals, the team has also made good on the overall narrative and pacing within this single player offering. The story puts you in the role of a Russian officer in the secret service as you and your squad mates end up exploring an underground genetic laboratory. The build up to the climax is great, you actually feel like you're interacting with characters and everything is routine until things go awry. While I did encounter some minor problems with the AI, Paranoia is worth a download as it manages to comes close to putting together a complete package.

Patched v. 1.1 Bunkers, gate 7


Age of Chivalry

(Half Life 2, Multiplayer)
Take a step back into the past when combat was a lot more personal and the armor considerably more shiny (and heavier). Age of Chivalry forces you to holster the firearms so prevalent in most mods and dispatch of your foes medieval style - with swords, bows, maces, and daggers. The map rotation is preset to follow a campaign which links all of the maps together. Style points are given to the presentation in this mod. Crisp textures and good use of shaders make the characters and environments truly stand out. Everything from the dynamic lighting on viewmodels to the blood speckled weapons make hacking and slashing with your friends all the more enjoyable. Thanks to Age of Chivalry for taking multiplayer mayhem to the medieval ages.

1.0 Media 1.0 Media


Flipside

(Half Life 2, Singleplayer)
Flipside is all about guiding a mental institution escapee to freedom. The one twist, and likely reason for your incarceration, is the way the main character changes his perception of the environment. One minute you may be strolling through a meadow spotted with cheery bunnies and sun shining brightly, the next you're in a dark, dreary wasteland full of killer bees. The mod is short on length but challenging. Flipside is the result of an attempt to expand and challenge the conventional standards. Granted, the light/dark mirrored world game mechanic has been done before but not on the Source engine. The same can be said of the paper cutout visuals and the platforming. Flipside succeeds at creating a bold experience that stands out on the Source platform.

FLIPSIDE Screenshot 004 FLIPSIDE Screenshot 005


Europe in Ruins

(Company of Heroes, Multiplayer)
Company of Heroes won many awards for being the best of the RTS breed in 2006. While it was officially declared that Company of Heroes Online would only be delivered to China, (any word if it made it there yet?) fans took matters into their own hands and started Europe in Ruins. Europe in Ruins adds persistence to the army you control as you fight battles that decide an overall outcome. Veteran units that stay alive stay with your forces can be summoned in future battles. This places even more value on your units and strategies through discouraging hopelessly desperate rushes. While still early in development, Europe in Ruins now supports the expansion pack for Company of Heroes, Opposing Forces, and plans to include war-maps to track the progress of your side's campaign. For RTS nuts looking to add life to an already amazing game, Europe in Ruins should be a top choice.


The Hunted Chronicles

(Unreleased: Dark Places Engine, Singleplayer)
When looking at the sparse amount of information concerning The Hunted Chronicles, I was somewhat hesitant giving it the go ahead for an Editor's Choice. That was until I found a bounty of videos for THC on youtube (note: please update your mod profile THC!). The additional videos show the progress that's been made over the last few months and even at this early state, it's apparent this game has the potential to turn me into a screaming ninny (I deal with horror games with about the same aptitude as the infamous MESH). The visuals already show their capability to deliver and if everything else matches up to the same calibre, The Hunted Chronicles will be one experience you won't want to miss. Considering this is the third Hunted game in the series, there's a good chance this will see the light of day. In the meantime, check out the first two:


Searching File Cabinet Shovel


Infinity: The Quest for Earth

(Prototype Unreleased I-Novae Engine, Multiplayer)
Infinity doesn't promise the world, it promises the universe. It's a tall order, but with an impressive proprietary engine and an already massive roster of ships, Infinity has garnered a lot of well-wishers in support. Media releases have already boasted seamless transitions from outer space to a procedurally generated planetside and visuals that include a variety of celestial bodies. Those interested in doing so, can already test out the combat prototype themselves. It's hard to even grasp the sense of scale this game will introduce. Everything from planet-sized destroyers to the tiniest escape pod will be incorporated. Infinity will be an online persistent world that does away with the turn based number crunching and instead relies on wits and reflexes to come out as the top gun. Combat, trade, explore and network with others anywhere, truly anywhere, within a virtual universe. Can Infinity deliver?

ICP 2.0.k screenshot ICP 2.1 Screenshot

Post comment Comments  (0 - 50 of 70)
Orion
Orion Feb 4 2008, 10:36am says:

Congratulations All Winners!!

Go Infinity..!! :D

+2 votes     reply to comment
sickre
sickre Feb 4 2008, 10:36am says:

Wheres the rest?

+3 votes     reply to comment
sickre
sickre Feb 4 2008, 10:41am replied:

Hang on... thats it? Pretty crappy selection of mods. No one even plays AOC or ES. One of the videos up there hasn't even been properly uploaded. Last year's awards were much better :-(

+3 votes     reply to comment
stenchy
stenchy Feb 4 2008, 10:44am replied:

What were you expecting? Part of the reason AOC and ES are up there is because I think players should give them more consideration.

+3 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0
Tatsur0 Feb 4 2008, 10:44am replied:

"The list focuses on projects that have been pushed to the sidelines in a flood of constant media and news updates, yet merit some of their own time under the spotlight."

Nice selection. Looking forward to Infinity and The Hunted Chronicles!

Congrats guys :)

Tats...

+2 votes     reply to comment
mtnmantromboner
mtnmantromboner Feb 4 2008, 9:06pm replied:

dude open your eyes tons of people play AoC there is even a tournament set up and a dueling league in the early stages it is a great mod that is just overlooked because people are brainwashed into thinking a first person multi-player game has to be a shooter and i strongly recommend everyone check it out and see the fun that is to be had in the unique way this mod has map objectives and besides this mod has blood, sharp pointy objects, people on fire, arrows flying by your head along with a spear or two, and HELMS DEEP!!! what more could you want. Just wait till the 1.1 release, you ain't seen nothin' yet ^^

and in Eternal Silence true there is more of a cult following to it but it is a great mod also and its a great mod for any sci-fi junkies that love futuristic combat.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Squeebo
Squeebo Feb 4 2008, 10:45pm replied:

Just because nobody plays them doesn't mean they're not good.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Ennui
Ennui Feb 4 2008, 10:45am says:

Heh, never seen Flipside before, looks pretty cool.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0
Tatsur0 Feb 4 2008, 10:49am replied:

I really like the style and art direction.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Dr_Spielmann
Dr_Spielmann Feb 4 2008, 10:59am says:

Flipside is amazing. Congrats to all the winners, all show an incredible talent. And I can't wait to be able to download some of those promising unreleased mods!

+3 votes     reply to comment
AlabasterSlim
AlabasterSlim Feb 5 2008, 10:16am replied:

Flipside is pretty incredible. I downloaded it after seeing it on this list. I can't believe they went from concept to completion in a month on this. The art is just so charming. It's too bad this is all we'll see of Flipside, because a long and more content rich game would have been amazing.

+1 vote     reply to comment
KnightTemplar
KnightTemplar Feb 4 2008, 11:02am says:

I never realised Empires was a "realistic military shooter". I'll remember that next time I want to go out and create 20 metres of wall along with turrets and a camera that can track targets through walls. I'll then go around to all the dead people (only if they're friendly) and push them with my calculator until they are alive.

I'll also make sure to give people ammoz, especially if they have no idea what's going on, like this guy - Moddb.com

+2 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0
Tatsur0 Feb 4 2008, 11:05am replied:

Speaking majority not all.

+1 vote     reply to comment
MCDT
MCDT Feb 5 2008, 6:44am replied:

Yeah, at least, rewrite the review of Empires or delete it.

Gratulations to all, I hope we will see Empires, Master Sword:Continued and Sandbag´s CnC-mod next time here :)!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Domipheus
Domipheus Feb 4 2008, 11:03am says:

Congratulations to all winners!

However, to the organisers: An absolute FARCE.

From the awards page:

Mod of the Year Editors Choice
* Design Award
* Graphics Award
* Originality Award
* Audio Award
* Upcoming Mod Award
* Upcoming Indie Award
* Single Player Mod of the Year
* Multiplayer Mod of the Year
* Indie Game of the Year

To me, this is just rushed. No others awards ceremony that tries to mean something would be so stupid as to through its own plan out the window.

Very dissapointed this year. Hope next year goes much, much more smoothly.

+8 votes     reply to comment
INtense!
INtense! Feb 4 2008, 11:54am replied:

This was the approach we had originally planned, however when picking and choosing "best graphics, originality" we found the same candidates kept popping up. The problem we saw with this approach which we didn't anticipate during planning, is that it really limited the mods we could pick and meant many creative deserving titles we wanted to pick missed out. Plus having good graphics, audio, physics etc doesn't necessarily equate to a good mod. We want well rounded mods which are the total package, not a mod which excels at audio but not much else. Finally it saps a little excitement out of the awards when say the mod with best graphics was picked because it has uhh... best graphics?!?

These days a common complaint is that games lack originality (sequel anyone!?) and focus too much on the graphics and not the gameplay. We wanted to show that mods do amazing and different things, hence the switch.

+7 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0
Tatsur0 Feb 4 2008, 12:28pm replied:

Unfortunately you can't make everyone happy. This list is pretty solid.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Orion
Orion Feb 4 2008, 1:07pm replied:

Very well said and Explained INtense..! And as Tatsur0 has said, You cant always please everyone!

Personally I think the Editors Choice Awards has been a good one this year but on the other hand I do see some of where others are coming from as far as solid categories are concerned! I know it can't be easy considering what you've just said, so hopefully this years awards and comments could act as a learning experience and help you come that little bit closer to perfecting the system and maybe we'll see the results of such next year! ;)

Overall though... It's a Good Editors Choice in my opinion! The chosen have earned it! Good Job! ;)

+4 votes     reply to comment
smurfbizkit
smurfbizkit Feb 4 2008, 11:05am says:

Nice! Grats especially to the Shockwave team. :)

0 votes     reply to comment
Dr_Spielmann
Dr_Spielmann Feb 4 2008, 11:23am says:

True, I was waiting for a categorized editor's choice list of awards: design, graphics, originality, audio, etc. It's a bit of a shame because Editor's Choice has become now more of a "honorable mention" than a true award, which is a shame!

For mod developers it will help a lot if we could have categorized awards, so that we can know where our mods stand out, and give the work of our contributors and developers proper recognition. Lots of room for improvement for further awards, but who knows, maybe you guys will think about it and redo the Editor's choice awards before it's too late?

+5 votes     reply to comment
Betelgeuze
Betelgeuze Feb 4 2008, 11:32am says:

Thanks everyone, we appreciate it!

Congrats to the other projects.

+1 vote     reply to comment
meazum
meazum Feb 4 2008, 12:24pm replied:

I'm also looking forward to infinity, and I hope this list will do its job aswell. If AoC and ES would get more players, I'd be the happiest boy alive. they are my favorite mods for Half-life 2 so far.

+2 votes     reply to comment
yafn
yafn Feb 4 2008, 1:22pm says:

Congrats to the winners. Esp. C&C, nice to see something other than an FPS winning.

I like Domipheus, was a bit disappointed. I'm hoping next year we see more follow through with categories. Best Graphics, Best Audio, etc are a nifty idea, though there are some challenges as INtense mentions.

Why not look at some easier categories, like genres? RTS, FPS, Platform, MMO, etc, etc. Wikipedia has a list of other game genres - En.wikipedia.org

+2 votes     reply to comment
Nuka5
Nuka5 Feb 4 2008, 1:54pm says:

I like the list in that it is promoting some of the less mainstream games. But honestly, I thought the editors choices were going to be about "what's the most fun to play" having played AoC, ES and Flipside, i must say that the gameplay for ALL of those isn't very deep at all, fun to play for perhaps an hour or two, but not exactly what I'd call deep.

Good to see that Zero Hour hasn't been totally forgotten about, (though thats not the mod i'd have chosen :P), well done to the shockwave team anyway.

If it were up to me, I wouldn't include unreleased mods either. I'd rather come here and find 5 great new mods to play than 3 great new mods and 3 other mods that I just have to wait for. Whats more, you can't tell fromt the ideas and graphics of a game if the gameplay, that actual "fun" is going to be there at all.

Paranoia and E.Y.E both look awesome.

+3 votes     reply to comment
Betelgeuze
Betelgeuze Feb 4 2008, 2:47pm replied:

So unreleased indie games cant participate at all in MOTY?

+1 vote     reply to comment
L3TUC3
L3TUC3 Feb 4 2008, 7:38pm replied:

He never said indie games couldn't participate. Only released ones.

+1 vote     reply to comment
INtense!
INtense! Feb 4 2008, 10:55pm replied:

The Hunted Chronicles game series is unreleased indie. Infinity only has a prototype out. Apocalypse Rising also got a honorable mention.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Jyffeh
Jyffeh Feb 4 2008, 2:14pm says:

Way more comprehensive than the Player's Choice.

+1 vote     reply to comment
BlueWolf72
BlueWolf72 Feb 4 2008, 2:44pm says:

Solid list. Any one of of us could add a couple to this list but its still the list of the site admins.

+1 vote     reply to comment
ambershee
ambershee Feb 4 2008, 2:51pm says:

Now this is a list I can whole-heartedly agree with. Everything here has oodles of effort, creativity and inspiration poured into it straight from the heart.

That's what MOTY should be about, not the latest 'realistic warfare' clone.

+3 votes     reply to comment
Imperial88
Imperial88 Feb 4 2008, 6:05pm says:

A bit disappointing. I read why you tossed out the category system in a reply already, but it's a real shame. The editor's awards are suppose to show where individual mods shine in specific categories, not just talk about what HL2 mods the editors think should be more popular. Whether or not it makes a mod great, it's nice to see credit given where credit is due. All these things may be required to make up a good mod, but it's very rare for any mod to be composed of the best content in all areas, so why not acknowledge the mods who really strive for excellence in any of the areas and give them credit for their work?

Overall, it really seems like ModDB is going down the drain and the MotY awards is turning into a bit of a joke. The video that was composed for the MotY awards was shoddy at best with terrible voice overs and poor editing. No information was supplied other than a video to acknowledge chosen mods such as it was here for these editors choice. And now these awards aren't even what they were described to be when the contest began. You'd think with these big names sponsoring you that you'd try to improve things, not ruin everything that was working. You've had good ideas (video, the style of award that you gave here, etc.) but they probably should have been in addition to the MotY awards that we all know and have come to expect and much better quality than the poor product you produced.

+4 votes     reply to comment
stenchy
stenchy Feb 4 2008, 6:15pm replied:

It very rare for any mod to be composed of the best content in all areas and we believe these mods listed here are the ones that come closest, in 2007, to offering a complete package. The overall objective is to give these mods more attention and get them onto players' lists of mods to try out. Does awarding a mod with the 'best audio award' really make you want to play a mod even more? At the end of the day, the greatest thing you can do for mod teams is recognize their body of work and point more people towards their projects so others can appreciate it. That's what Editor's Choice achieves.

0 votes     reply to comment
Imperial88
Imperial88 Feb 4 2008, 6:55pm replied:

If a mod won the Best Audio award, yes I would try it out, as sound and music is something I pay particular attention to when I play a game, if the sound is poor a game doesn't cut it for me. That's the point of this whole system. As I said, I know no mod achieves the best in all these categories, however you should acknowledge when a mod achieves great things in any category as some people play a mod for their gameplay, some for the graphics, some for the music and sounds, some for the originality of it, etc. That's what is so great about gaming, it covers so many areas that it can cater to an infinite amount of audiences depending on how a game is made.

+5 votes     reply to comment
yafn
yafn Feb 4 2008, 8:09pm replied:

Me too, take BtRLs VO. Fantastic. The VO was mentioned in the award video as well. If you like good VO and haven't checked out Beyond the Read Line, I would recommend it.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Orion
Orion Feb 4 2008, 9:36pm replied:

100% agreed..! The VO on BtRL is in my opinion better than some of what you would expect from an official paid for title, never mind a free for all beta by an unofficial team! Very professionally done in my opinion and deserves all the praise and cred it gets! ;)

+3 votes     reply to comment
stenchy
stenchy Feb 5 2008, 8:49pm replied:

This is the reason why it won for best Indie of the year.

+1 vote     reply to comment
holyknight
holyknight Feb 4 2008, 7:21pm says:

yay go Age of Chivalry :)
I really like that mod.
And EYE looks damn good, and I'm downloading Flipside right now, yea!

+1 vote     reply to comment
AgeofChivalry
AgeofChivalry Feb 4 2008, 7:51pm says:

Thanks for the votes of confidence and acceptance to ModDB and the rest of the community.

Team Chivalry is extremely happy to be part of the mod community and we are looking forward to all the future updates we are planning!

Arm yourselves for 1.1! Coming very soon!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Neurological
Neurological Feb 4 2008, 8:31pm says:

Thx for Mind beign here, I was really surprised and can't believe it :D.

+1 vote     reply to comment
jaboo224
jaboo224 Feb 4 2008, 9:41pm says:

To be perfectly honest i think PVK2 and Empires should of been in this list.

+3 votes     reply to comment
Ethan101
Ethan101 Feb 4 2008, 9:44pm says:

If you like BSG you NEED to try Infinity, it is one of the most amazing Indie games ever. Its like they are working for perfection, I would buy it if they slapped a 30 buck price tag on it (50 dollars is to much, i not made of green!).

+2 votes     reply to comment
fldash
fldash Feb 4 2008, 11:50pm says:

I'm very honored! RTS mods usually get the short end of the stick! I'm glad to see a C&C mod as well! Europe in Ruins ftw! ;)

+1 vote     reply to comment
J.D.
J.D. Feb 4 2008, 11:51pm says:

thanks for playing Paranoia!

+2 votes     reply to comment
formerlyknownasMrCP
formerlyknownasMrCP Feb 5 2008, 12:43am says:

I would rather we just have editors choice from now on, this was an excelent pick this year :D good work editors ;).

0 votes     reply to comment
phipe
phipe Feb 5 2008, 1:01am says:

Haha! The Hl1 engine still kicks ***!

+2 votes     reply to comment
ruMpel
ruMpel Feb 5 2008, 8:18am says:

Isn't there supposed to be winners of genres like the other MOTY? Just wondering, Gz!

+5 votes     reply to comment
frvge
frvge Feb 5 2008, 1:42pm says:

Bit disappointed since I hoped my Mod would have a chance in the Originality category, but better luck next year.

+4 votes     reply to comment
Chandler
Chandler Feb 5 2008, 3:41pm says:

Play something different*.

*But only if it's a shooter for a mod-friendly engine.

Honestly, MOTY was a major disappointment and daresay failure this year. Certainly Player's Choice lacked diversity, but at least that was to be expected. But not Editor's Choice. This is nothing more than a reaction to the players' picks - and a poor one at that. It still fails to be representative of the different engines and genres of the Top 100.

Why is representation important? I've been modding for a long time and I can say from experience that it's a lot easier to produce a FPS than, say, a RPG or an RTS. Not only that, but you'll get better results in terms of graphics (the most important selling factor) because of the camera position. You cannot, after all, screenshot the AI. It's no surprise that the vast majority of winners on both sides are shooters, because there were no categories to ensure anything else.

Furthermore, it's much harder to mod a game with no SDK opposed to one that gives you free reign. Again, this is from having done both. The engine I'm currently working on has no source code access, you cannot alter the main style of gameplay, and there's no control over the interface. As a result, I've had to scrap about half of the ideas I come up with because they're just plain impossible to implement. That's not lack of originality - that's lack of SDK. But I guess starting with a GOTY pretty much makes you a shoe-in for MOTY.

In a community of gamers, it's a travesty that you've been unable to ensure balance in a simple awards competition. I hope that drastic changes are made to the event next year - and prior to the results - on threat of becoming trivialized.

+6 votes     reply to comment
formerlyknownasMrCP
formerlyknownasMrCP Feb 5 2008, 5:21pm replied:

I'll agree on the trivialized part, but FPS aren't the easiest games to make as opposed to adventure games. It's obvious that FPS mods are designed purely out of popularity not out of ease else moddb would be loaded with adventure games..

Popularity is what is killing the diversity hence why player's choice is so unbalanced. The editor's choice is a lot more accurate as it rewards the projects that have made major contributions to the site, I think a majority of the mods on this list have done that as opposed to player's choice.

0 votes     reply to comment
Dragonlord
Dragonlord Feb 6 2008, 10:44am replied:

I disagree in this point. FPS games are easier to make. They compose of a few things only: a set of guns, some linear maps, some mobs spawning in at predictable times, keycard hunting sequences, maybe a few cutscenes. Most of those things are already in the game you mod for included. The only tricky part is to get weapons balanced so people don't pick all the same gun in the end. Story is usually a no-go since FPS are about shooting things ( which is wrong but this is the major consense about it ). If you want to make for example an adventure you need a real good plot, clever maps which are especially not linear, good puzzles which are not so easy to build, interaction with your environment and people, very good characters since this makes or breaks the mood.

Hence for an FPS just make a gun and something to shoot at and you have 50% of the job already done. For other genre types it takes much more before you have something on the dishes.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Post a Comment
click to sign in

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) which we encourage all contributors to do.

2000 characters limit; HTML formatting and smileys are not supported - text only

Established
Nov 14, 2007
Privacy
Public
Subscription
Must apply to join
Homepage
Moddb.com
Contact
Send Message
Email
Members Only
Membership
Join this group
Group Watch
Track this event
Feature
Browse
Features
Report Abuse
Report article
Related Mods
Age of Chivalry (Half-Life 2)
Age of Chivalry Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
C&C: ShockWave (C&C Generals: Zero Hour)
C&C: ShockWave C&C Generals: Zero Hour - Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Eternal Silence (Half-Life 2)
Eternal Silence Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
FLIPSIDE (Half-Life 2)
FLIPSIDE Half-Life 2 - Single Player Platformer
PARANOIA (Half-Life)
PARANOIA Half-Life - Single Player First Person Shooter
Related Games
C&C Generals: Zero Hour
C&C Generals: Zero Hour Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts
Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
E.Y.E: Divine Cybermancy
E.Y.E: Divine Cybermancy Indie Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Half-Life
Half-Life Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Half-Life 2
Half-Life 2 Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Infinity: The Quest for Earth
Infinity: The Quest for Earth Indie Single & Multiplayer Realistic Sim
The Hunted Chronicles
The Hunted Chronicles Indie Single Player First Person Shooter
Related Engines
I-Novae engine
I-Novae engine Commercial TBD
Related Groups
2007 Mod of the Year Awards
2007 Mod of the Year Awards Official event with 186 members
Crankshaft Games
Crankshaft Games Developer & Publisher with 7 members
Europe In Ruins Development Team
Europe In Ruins Development Team Developer & Publisher with 8 members
Infinity devteam
Infinity devteam Developer & Publisher with 5 members
PARANOIA TEAM
PARANOIA TEAM Developer & Publisher with 3 members
SWR Productions
SWR Productions Developer & Publisher with 14 members
THC Developers
THC Developers Developer & Publisher with 2 members