Post feature Report content RSS feed IOTY 2011 Editors Choice

Welcome to the Editors Choice award for Indie of the Year 2011.

Posted by Henley on Dec 23rd, 2011

Welcome to the Editors Choice award for Indie of the Year 2011. Here the editors of IndieDB have their say on the most prolific Indie games both released and unreleased to grace our presence over the past year. The awards have been split up into smaller categories, for more information on why that project was selected for the award please keep reading after the video below.

Interaction Award

Most unique use of player interaction

Interaction is a complex and strange beast, it could be as simple as removing traditional controls or as complex as breading a new strain of camera controls. Interaction is not limited to just what lay between the keyboard and the chair. The winner of this award needs to reinvigorate our perception on how video games should be played, and Dungeon Deities does all of that and more.

Rob the nest is a fantastic concept, we all played it as children. The aim is to take and defend your own stash of goodies from other people. Dungeon Deities works the same. Players create a dungeon to house their treasures, other players login to your work and attempt to take what is yours. It is really unique and the game plays really well.

Creativity Award

Most unique use of gameplay/game direction

To say that a game is creative in it's design is a little like saying it is hip to be different (sometimes). The Indie title needs to stand out from the pack in both the direction of the gameplay and the overall look and feel of the project. Magicka is one of those games.

Delivering an experience so very different from anything we have seen this year Magicka is not afraid to poke fun at anything and mix the arcane arts dangerously. Name one other game where you are both working together to stay alive from the world and each other, the co-op is so maniac, the story is so wacky, Magicka is so good!

Musicality Award

Best use of music/original score

Music can be used for so many different applications, within movies it is used to influence how the audience is supposed to feel during a scene, in a game it could define a game's genre. The use of music can not be overlooked with games, some make better use of it then others. To win this award the game needs to have music be intertwined into the game and have a kickass OST too boot. Sword & Sworcery EP is that game!

Sword & Sworcery EP is just flat out fantastic, the music is stunning, matching the game beep to bloop. When a project mixes this well you cannot have one without the other. No other game this year has made music such a big part of the overall experience. This is why Sword & Sworcery EP has won this award.

Worldly Award

Most complete realisation of a virtual world

Just about anyone can create a world in a game, you could simply say this boxed room is a world and be done with it. That will not cut it for Editors Choice. To even be considered for the Worldly Award you must first create a world, then fill it with lore, places to explore and no shortage of a looming threat helps as well. Bastion is a fine example of this.

Bastion has done right by all of us, the narrator is well executed example of how to engage your player in the story you want them to know, without slowing down the pace of the game the narrator gives instant player feedback on what you are doing in the world. Equip different weapons and you are told a small story of the weapons, find parts new parts of the world and you are in for a little bit more history. The story and history of Bastion is compelling and you WILL want to know more!

Best Upcoming

Best unreleased/alpha indie title

New unreleased/alpha Indie game appear all the time, it takes something really special to announce and make an impression. You need to have something considerable to show, have an intriguing presence/idea and capture the attention of a large audience not just on IndieDB. Project Zomboid did just that.

A zombie city sandbox done right. Freedom and the struggle to stay alive are the main aims of Project Zomboid. While you can currently pre-order the game for instant access to the current Alpha version of the game Project Zomboid still has a ways to go before the developers deem it perfect. The foundations are in place for one of the best Zombie games yet!

CEO's Silver Spoon

IndieDB's founder mod selection award

Now I see a lot of things every day here on IndieDB. The founder of the site however spends a lot of his time on business related tasks and site expansions. Once in a blue moon he will take notice of a project, the reasons are mostly unknown to myself, maybe it reminds him of a younger self, maybe it tickles that primal urge we have as gamers, maybe he just enjoys the name. Whatever the reason this is his selection based on what I have seen him react to throughout 2011. Honestly you have to be something special for that to happen.

King Arthur's Gold comes from the mind that braough you the sidescrolling epic Soldat. Now with a medieval theme and world building (and destroying) abilities. Build and protect your castle the only way your medieval mind knows with VIOLENCE! It is possible that KAG reminded the founder of when he was a knight at the round table, yeah that explains it.

Best Multiplayer

Best released multiplayer focused indie game

To even qualify for Best Multiplayer for Editors Choice you need two things. First you need to be released and a new IP within 2011 and secondly you need to be super fun with other people. Frozen Synapse gets two ticks!

Frozen Synapse is quite possibly the longest and quickest turn based strategy of all time. You first plan your attack down to the finest point, then hit execute and watch as you win or loose within a few seconds. You could spend hours working out the best plan only to have it ruined within seconds, this is what makes Frozen Synapse so compelling. You will want more and more. Best Multiplayer Indie game by a long shot.

Best Singleplayer

Best released singleplayer focused indie game

2011 has seen so many awesome singleplayer Indie games, it was very hard to pick just one winner, just take a look at our top 100 to get a vague idea of the quality we were dealing with when we made this selection. However in the end there NEEDS to be a winner, and that winner is To The Moon.

It is very very hard to pull yourself ahead of the pack when you are a RPG game (even one made on RPG Maker) what you need to do different will always cull off the audience who likes that particular genre. To The Moon however does it right, a very deep story about a man who get his dying wish granted from the help of two doctors. This is a must play in 2011!

Post comment Comments
FW:ToW_Sushi Dec 23 2011 says:

Congrats to all the indie games!

+3 votes     reply to comment
IvanErtlov Dec 23 2011 says:

Interesting choices. Congratulations to the picked ones!

+2 votes     reply to comment
Lethalanvas Dec 23 2011 says:

Congrats to the winners!

+2 votes     reply to comment
Dr.Goupyl Dec 23 2011 says:

And Project Zomboid as best upcoming ! :D

+2 votes     reply to comment
Velox Dec 23 2011 says:


+2 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0 Dec 23 2011 says:

Excellent choices! I loved Bastion :D

+2 votes     reply to comment
Baryonyx Dec 23 2011 says:

All this is why I love Indie.

+3 votes     reply to comment
cW#Ravenblood Dec 23 2011 says:

Nice to see that indie is more than a "minecraft hype".
There are some awesome indie projects.

+3 votes     reply to comment
Kamikazi[Uk] Dec 23 2011 says:

Great indie games this year. Alot of variety aswell :D.

+2 votes     reply to comment
sharktamer Dec 23 2011 says:

"To the moon" is one of the most beautiful games I have ever played. Definitely well deserved.

+2 votes     reply to comment
CumQuaT Dec 23 2011 says:

Some awesome titles there! Well done!

+2 votes     reply to comment
ComposerGuy Dec 23 2011 says:

congratulations to the winners! I really appreciate you care about music in games. cheers!

+4 votes     reply to comment
AirborneSn1p3r Dec 23 2011 says:

congrats and great job to all

+2 votes     reply to comment
Hamumu Dec 23 2011 says:

I am so frustrated to see Dungeon Deities! I've had that idea for years, loved it, and never quite did anything with it. Well, I guess I can check out what they did and see what worked!

+2 votes     reply to comment
oversoul Dec 23 2011 says:

Great choices Editors! Well done! I especially agree with your best multiplayer and best singleplayer picks. I convinced all my roommates to buy Frozen Synapse, and we have been playing it nonstop since. As for To the Moon, I have never cried while playing a video game before, a feat this game accomplished not once but twice.

+2 votes     reply to comment
reok Dec 23 2011 says:

Congratz to everyone!

+2 votes     reply to comment
Armageddon104 Dec 23 2011 says:

I don't understand why Dungeon Deities is here, but why isn't Pirtes of a New Horizon here? Or The Tiny Bang story.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Tatsur0 Dec 23 2011 replied:

Editor's choice not "some guy's choice" :)

+2 votes     reply to comment
Cryaotic Dec 23 2011 says:

Great choices all around - glad to see Dungeon Deities is getting some loving, and To the Moon is the kind of story that makes a real man cry like a baby.

+2 votes     reply to comment
KingPhazon Dec 23 2011 says:

Star Trek: Excalibur should have won the best unreleased/alpha indie title, STE looks far more interesting to me than "Project Zomboid", heck it looks exactly like Dead Frontier except with 2D graphics! :O In fact I would rather play Dead Frontier because it has 3D graphics and it looks prettier, copycat!

-2 votes     reply to comment
Dr.VX Dec 23 2011 says:

while im happy for project zomboid, im still sad that Natural Selection 2 didnt even get a mention, oh well, grats all :) (though there should be an Honorable mentions section next year)

+2 votes     reply to comment
Zacker_lvldsnr Dec 23 2011 says:

It is pretty ironic to see Bastion on this list though. It is published by Warner Brothers, exactly one of those companies which indies were originally defined as NOT being published by back when the term was defined in the movie industry.

+5 votes     reply to comment
BurningPet Dec 23 2011 replied:

True that, also, magicka was published by paradox. not so indie.

+3 votes     reply to comment
vincent074 Dec 23 2011 says:

no contagion? for shame

+2 votes     reply to comment
Diddykonga Dec 24 2011 says:

That stinks i was really hoping to see Overgrowth on the list somewhere :(

+1 vote     reply to comment
Harimau Dec 24 2011 replied:

Overgrowth won the players choice award already...

Dungeon Deities, King Arthur's Gold and To The Moon interest me.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Harimau Dec 24 2011 says:

Ugh. Why didn't it post as a reply? How do I delete this?

+1 vote     reply to comment
Harimau Dec 24 2011 says:

Edit: OK, reply system isn't working. This is in response to Zacker_lvldsnr and BurningPet above.

You're wrong.

Now that that's out of the way, I'll tell you why.
Supergiant Games did all of their own funding, marketing etc. They only went through WB to get them onto different platforms. The same kind of thing applies to Magicka (though Paradox took up the funding after Magicka was initially funded out of the pockets of its own developers). Funding, development, marketing - that's the key to being indie; especially the funding. Hell, you could technically call Valve the publisher for some of these, since they're published on Steam.

+1 vote     reply to comment
JibbSmart Dec 27 2011 says:

So happy to see Dungeon Deities getting some well-deserved attention. Bring on the next public alpha session!

+1 vote     reply to comment
tuhi009 Dec 31 2011 says:

CONGRATS!!! TO THE MOON!!! truly deserves it

+1 vote     reply to comment
Post a comment

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account:

Related Games
Bastion Role Playing
Dungeon Deities
Dungeon Deities Role Playing
Frozen Synapse
Frozen Synapse Turn Based Strategy
Magicka Hack 'n' Slash
Project Zomboid
Project Zomboid Role Playing
To the Moon
To the Moon Adventure
Related Engines
Crimson Engine
Crimson Engine Proprietary Released 2010
GameStudio A8
GameStudio A8 Commercial Released 2010
RPG Maker XP
RPG Maker XP Commercial Released 2004
Torque Game Engine
Torque Game Engine Commercial Released 2006
XNA Public Domain Released 2006
Related Groups
2011 Indie of the Year Awards
2011 Indie of the Year Awards Event with 110 members
Freebird Games
Freebird Games Developer & Publisher
Mode 7 Games
Mode 7 Games Developer & Publisher with 4 members
Paradox Interactive
Paradox Interactive Publisher with 3 members
Superbrothers Developer
Supergiant Games
Supergiant Games Developer
The Indie Stone
The Indie Stone Developer & Publisher with 5 members
Transhuman Design
Transhuman Design Developer with 2 members