Poll started by INtense! with 7,085 votes and 399 comments. Browse the poll archive.
I don't, I buy them! (2007 votes)
To try them, but I usually buy if they are good (2553 votes)
It is easier to pirate than to buy (289 votes)
They cost too much (1394 votes)
Because I can (438 votes)
To avoid DRM (404 votes)
Hearing a few stories from newly released indies that are seeing plenty of players but few sales, so clearly their game's piracy rate is high.
Really sad to pirate indie games, let alone anything - but I understand that everyone has their reasons, so I wanted to find out what is yours. I hope you were honest as to why you pirate games, so that we can help indie developers better optimize their conversion rate, as it is a hard to make a living and future game with high piracy.
I've also kicked off a news post with a few more of my thoughts on the subject: Moddb.com
Pirating an Indie game is no different from pirating a... a... Hmm...
See what I mean?
Answer: Supply a decent demo.
Agreed. I don't support pirating, but I won't claim to have never done so. I pirate only when a demo is not provided and when I get a feel for it I either buy the game or delete the pirated copy. Pirating Indie games however is not acceptable for several reasons: 1)Indie games are not supported by production companies and make all their money directly from sales that are already minimal to large scale games. 2)Pirating an Indie game may make profit so low or discourage the developer to such an extent that future games might not be a possibility. Every time you buy a product is a vote, and every time you steal a product you are making it less available in the future even if it deserves your vote.
Exactly, most demos our over before you even play.
I totally agree. To me, pirating is an alternative when there is no decent demo. I always buy a good game to support the devs.
Definitely agree here. People shouldn't pirate indie games. Thats just wrong.
I'd just like to note how many people have checked this out. It's quite amazing that it attract everyone because of the word "pirate", don't you think?
A sensitive topic though as I can see! :P
Yeah, piracy sure is a hot topic, indie developers really depend on their first game. If the game sells, they can afford to make a new game.
I I like a game, I always buy it to support the developers. Else is greedy and selfish.
Pirating ANY game is "wrong," not just indie's.
If you pirate a game to get around crippling DRM (ie- SPORE) is that so wrong? In some cases pirated versions of games are actually more stable than the legit ones.
I personally pirate to try (and avoid DRM) If I like what I see, I'll usually buy the game, if not? Removed from Hard Drive, Nothing wasted. I can't afford to buy games I'm not going to play.
Well even if you download a pirated copy so that you get around DRM that isn't much of an excuse not to buy a legit copy and support the developers (even if you'll only use the pirated one)
all the great titles i've bought were first downloaded at LAN-Party and proved to be good, so i bought them when i had the money and found them at a good price. also most games are crap when they get released too early. so i wait for a "Gold Edition" or "Game of the Year" where all necessary bugfixes and addons are included.
also most demos dont show the game the way it really is.
and sometimes games you cant even buy in my country, just because some crazy people with blinders on say they are too cruel even for people above age 21.
anyway i buy games when they prove worth the money.
just look at Gothic 3...... i wish i never bought it.....
I actually pirate a ton of my owned games, since the DRM is just crippling and buggy.
You do realize some games simply aren't worth money? And It's definitely true that some games, like Spore as the given example, will totally **** up your machine. Spore, I admit I pirated. Glad I did too, not only would a legit copy have screwed my machine, but it wasn't really that great of a game anyways. It became long, boring and tedious when you get to the age of interstellar travel and it was over simplified and really not all that entertaining after the first...oh...'bout 50 hours of messing around with it sounds about right.
50 Hours? I'm sure that's your money's worth.
spore never shipped with drm btw, it was added with the first expansion i believe... glad i was done playing it at that point.
ONLY 50 hours?! God, most modern FPS games have campaigns 10 times shorter than that, and people fork out 70 bucks for them. You need to reconsider what is a "small" amount of time spent on a game, in my opinion.
Well people most buy FPS games in this century mostly for multi-player component of the game...
True, but if you didn't enjoy those hours it still wasn't worth the money.The reason you'd actually keep playing, however, is just to see if it really was worth it in the end. I occasionally borrow books from the town library, which are usually bad, but I keep reading until the end just to see if the ending's any better. It usually isn't though.
i dont pirate cause im rich
maybe u buy the gaming company and give all games 4 free then!
I pirate games for their single player, and buy them for their multiplayer. I made the mistake of spending money on fallout new vegas, just not my cup of tea. I'm a total ego shooter player, UT3, CSS, CoD, etc. I have no qualms with piracy and wish people donated food and shelter tokens (moneysss) to their favorite game developers, movie makers, actors, and musicians in return for giving them honest entertainment. We simply don't live in a world like that.
I would never pirate an indy game, all the major indies either have a pretty good demo, a previous mod version to try, or something. Especially when you cant get a square meal for the price of some of the great indies out there, there is no real loss.
cost of entertainment is high. a Movie runs you $10-$15 for 2 hours of entertainment (and too many movies suck), I know games cost more because of high development costs at AAA studios, but the ratio is spot on: $60-70 for 10 hours of single player entertainment. (granted I've had 1000s of hours of entertainment from cheaper games like CS, which never get old thanks to a strong community and mappers!
If you're poor, just try some of the best mods, they're free and just as fun. Soon the indy sector is gonna be pushing on the "pro" sector to make better games and lower their prices because they'll be losing players and hurt their bottom line.
Personally, I download to try them before I buy them, If the game is bad, I uninstall/delete the game to move on with other things. But for every good game I've tried. I buy a hard copy for legitimate collection (because of this, I have a good collection of games in my media shelf next to my compy).
I never downloaded Indie games before. But I mainly use this method to commercial-grade games. To ensure I never get ripped off over a bad product. Because the first ever bad RTS game I've ever wasted money on was Empire Earth II.
And because of this method, I've saved more money than wasting cash over a terrible game title.
I do it to try, with in the next few days if i like it I buy. the makes deserve money if i like it :)
They Cost Way Too Much In Indonesia(My Country)
and I never Pirated a Indie Game...Never !!!
Sometimes is good then you can try game even pirated. If you like you buy it, if not then you just uninstall it. That's all.
Is this supposed to be a trick poll so you can call the authorities on whoever vote on anything but the first option? :B
I pirate games to avoid abominations like HOMEFRONT, I usually buy them later, taken that there is no demo.
of course not
Hey now, Homefront was that bad... :/
I'm jealous of you, I pay for every game, and Homefront caused me to waste 60 bucks on the biggest POS I've ever played.
I was at a GameStop somewhat recently... they tried to push that game onto me. I don't tend to play shooters on console, so I expressed my disinterest.
Rather annoying how some retailers try to make the hard sell like that.
Then again, who can tell my precise location?
nsa cia fbi, some europe's inteligences, an lunatic from the deep web, fidel castro, chinense spies, your landlord, your bank, the police in vatican city, S.H.I.E.L.D ETC...
homefront had a demo though?
Pirating indie games is a sin. But neglecting to give money to the likes of Boby Kotick is not if you ask me.
If I really see potential in a game and its devs I will DEFINITELY buy it! So yeah, I too want to avoid abominations like Homefront and I'm glad I didn't spend any money on that!
So a game not having indie status justifies stealing? And pirating indie games is a sin only because they are indie? :P And Activision/Blizzard is indie as well by the way ;)
What he means is, big companies can take a pirate hit, and some almost half ask for it with the way they put some nasty DRM in it.
But indie companies have small budgets and are trying to make their big break, they have a lot to lose if everyone pirates it. Its not on the same multi-million level as the likes of Activision or EA.
As for the poll question, I don't pirate good games, always buy them. Games that don't realease demos I don't usualy buy, why risk my hard earned money?
Oh hey I got a negative karma while it wasn't offensive what I said. Here we go again.
Anyway, of course I understand what he means, and I kind of agree that big companies like Activision can take a hit and all that, but piracy = stealing = wrong, period :P In my opinion that is (so no need to downvote this comment as well -_-).
EDIT: Oh and I can 'respect' the choice to pirate, I mean, I won't be a bitch about it if I see someone pirating, but to me it just feels wrong.
I've +1d all your comments:)
I've never pirated a game either, but I almost never pay full price for them. I usually wait a year or two for the price to go down ;)
(Btw, Portal 2 is on sale at amazon, I just got it!)
Lol, thats right, I just bought Halo 1 for a couple of bucks at ebay
the difference is that if I like what I pirated I'll buy it. On the other hand if I buy it and don't like it I can't get my money back. In the end some one is always getting robbed it's either you because you bought it and hate it or them b/c you wanted to try it first.
Personally I think come of these companies ask for it when they pull stuff like crysis 2, silent hunter 5, farcry 2 etc. Hell if they just release a respectable demo they wouldn't have so much piracy.
and for all those saying it's so wrong, do you mind sending some of that money my way. I'm afraid I don't have an infinite supply of cash do waste on crap games that I can't try any other way.
Actually, piracy isn't stealing. It's copying. The only thing you're stealing is $50 from some rich guy's pile of 500 million
"What he means is, big companies can take a pirate hit, and some almost half ask for it with the way they put some nasty DRM in it."
Big companies take a hit like that by closing studios. Wake up.
no it because they don't listen. Stardock did. And they had sucess on a game having a buget lower than a million dollars. EA is ignoring it customers again and now they are paying for it. And they have terrible customer service when it come to fix the problem their "hacker proof" sofware cause. And I lost all repect for activision cause they ignored PC when it came to release a collector edition for us too. They can go both to hell.
Many UK companies have closed down recently. :(
That's likely because only one good game ever came from the UK. Metal Fatigue. The market is dominated by American, Canadian and Japanese companies.
You're obviously not old enough to remember the golden age of games in the UK. Many, many popular games today would be a shadow of themselves or wouldn't even exist without the contributions of UK developers from the 90s.
Little Big Planet, Grand Theft Auto, Tomb Raider
thats nonsense most good games come from uk or uk devs that moved to US
Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) and join in the conversation.