"Vojáky v čase potřeby budeme všichni!" - "We're all soldiers in the time of need!"

Image RSS Feed Latest Screens
Double Standards Czech mentality Sir McCrab
Blog RSS Feed Report abuse Latest Blog: Myth about massive soviet casualties in WW2

2 comments by Perun58 on Oct 31st, 2013

always hear about massive Soviet casualties at least 2 times bigger then their German opponents, so I decided to write this.

First and most importantly - German army was considered to be undefeatable until they met Soviets and it was greatest army of it's time.

And now, numbers.

According to post-Soviet archival work of G. I. Krivosheev in Soviet Casualties and Combat Losses number of men who died fighting for: 

USSR: 11,285,057.

Germany: 6,231,700.

Now it seems that Soviets really had 2 times bigger losses and that's the problem, because this is exactly the reason why people say that Soviets had 2 time bigger casualties ... well let's continue

Germany and it's occupied terriories: 6,923,700

Germany + occupied territories + satelate states (whole axis power that fought on Eastern front) : 8,649,500.

That means  11,285,057 against 8,649,500. 

Result is losses ratio 1.3 to 1.0 in Axis favour...

Is it really so bad for nation that had to build it's army under attack?

Germans executed 3.5 millions of Soviet prisoners, but Soviets "only" 300 000 German soldiers.

So if you exclude casualties of POWs and count only soldiers who died in the battle you'll get

SSSR: 7 785 057 AXIS: 8 348 500

With total ratio 
1,00 : 1,07 in SOVIET favour. 

Never forget to consider that eastern front was not only war Germany vs SSSR. There were also Hungarians, Italians, Romanians, Croatians and many others... their casualties should not be counted?

Also don't forget to consider that 3.5 million of 11 million soldiers were prisoners executed by Germans... on the other hand majority of German POWs (about 70%) inprisoned in SSSR returned home. So were Germans better warriors because they killed more POWs?

Doesn't matter how you count it but number of soviet casualties to german casualties will be always NEAR TO 1:1.

So please, don't make fun of country that have suffered biggest casualties (11 million soldiers and 14 millions civilians) fought against 80% of German forces and saved Europe from nazism.

Soviet army was very powerful and it's soldiers were brave and very good warriors. Don't let antisoviet myths to fool your mind.
Perun58

Media RSS Feed Latest Video
Groups
Atheists, Agnostics, and Anti-theists of ModDB

Atheists, Agnostics, and Anti-theists of ModDB

Educational group with 220 members, open to all members

A group for those without religion, as well as those who oppose it.

CAT Mod Development Studios

CAT Mod Development Studios

Developer & Publisher with 18 members, invitation only

The mod development studios for Battlefield: Scandinavia, Battlefield: Africa, Winter Warfare and BF2: Final War. If you are intrested in joining ethier...

Československo ( Czechoslovakia )

Československo ( Czechoslovakia )

Geographic group with 14 members, open to all members

Skupina pro všechny, co s láskou vzpomínají na svoji vlast. Pro ty, kdo chtejí Československo zpět, i pro ty co chtějí pouze vyjádřit silné pouto ke svým...

CSLA Mod Develepoers

CSLA Mod Develepoers

Developer with 8 members, invitation only

The developers of CSLA modification for Battlefield 2.

Czech Republic

Czech Republic

Geographic group with 19 members, open to all members

Group for all Czechs or people who like Czech Republic. Berte prosím v úvahu, že skupina je nová a není obsáhlá. Hlavní cíl je aby vůbec byla, protože...

Europe

Europe

Geographic group with 376 members, open to all members

This is a Group for all people who live in Europe.

Females In Uniform (Lovers Group)

Females In Uniform (Lovers Group)

Hobbies & Interests group with 452 members, open to all members

"They are beautiful. They are deadly. They are female soldiers. They are representing the army in that beautiful and popular way, and I think that every...

Firearm Lovers Club

Firearm Lovers Club

Hobbies & Interests group with 126 members, open to all members

We like guns. Real guns. Not some airsoft, or paintball stuff... Just the things that make a big boom and makes the television you set up down range pop...

Post comment Comments  (0 - 10 of 23)
Turkish007
Turkish007 Jul 30 2013, 6:55am says:

PR 1.0 is coming out this Friday! :D

+2 votes     reply to comment
Perun58
Perun58 Jul 30 2013, 8:15am replied:

Yay! Great! Thanks for info!

+2 votes     reply to comment
GypsyBastard
GypsyBastard Jun 15 2013, 5:10pm says:

Kámo podle tvých komentářů v "Athejistickým" kroužku kde tvůje komentéře co se týče víry v ježížka na kříží jen stěží mohli vynechat "cigány". Můžu hádat že jsi další příznivec tajnýho spolku anonymních neo homosexuálů ???

+1 vote     reply to comment
CommanderDef
CommanderDef Jun 16 2013, 7:31pm replied:

Státní občanství z tebe nedělá příslušníka národa.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Perun58
Perun58 Jun 16 2013, 7:13pm replied:

Homosexualy silne nepodporuji a nezvpominam si ze bych o "ciganech" neco psal, jedine co jsem napsal bylo ze se oficialne se hlasi vice lidi k nabozenstvi jedi, nez k romske narodnosti. Pokud narazis na mapu ČR.

+2 votes     reply to comment
D3ads
D3ads Apr 29 2013, 6:42pm says:

Hey man, did you get my reply to your pm?

+1 vote     reply to comment
Perun58
Perun58 May 3 2013, 11:56am replied:

Yes I forgot to answer... thank you very much =).

+2 votes     reply to comment
Perun58
Perun58 Mar 18 2013, 10:16am replied:

We don't have any mental tests right now, but we will in the future. Automatic guns are prohibited. However you can get exception because of work (bodyguard for example), if you're collector (in that case you can have automatic gun, but you can never hold it loaded), or if you're an inventor of guns or ammunition. We can't own silencers for some reason (really don't know why, it's good solution for open shooting rages, that are bothering people with it's loud sound). To get gun license I had to learn about 480 questions including "What should policeman do, it shooting range is threating life of health of another people." and other questions that have nothing to do with my class of gun license :D. Then I had to get confirmation from doctor that I am able to use gun. After that I am able to get gun. Every gun has it's own license. I am planning to get license for SVT-40 or Mosin-Nagant M91/30 I am not sure right now.
Gun license contains:
Name of the gun
Type of the gun
Cartridge
Weapon class
Number
and so on.
Then it needs to be confirmed and everything is done.

+2 votes     reply to comment
InsanityPays
InsanityPays Apr 9 2013, 3:56pm replied:

I want to move to your country- The US has such crappy and ineffective gun laws, and no one here seems to understand that it's mental health that's causing these problems, not guns. argghhhhh

+3 votes     reply to comment
Perun58
Perun58 Apr 12 2013, 9:32am replied:

I was envy you about gun laws just few months ago. Possibility to get automatic guns and so on.. but after problems you had recently I believe that your new laws won't be so good :(.
But you're right - problem is in mentality.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Post a Comment
click to sign in

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) which we encourage all contributors to do.

2000 characters limit; HTML formatting and smileys are not supported - text only

Level
Avatar
Avatar
Offline Since
Apr 16, 2014
Country
Czech Republic Czech Republic
Gender
Male
Member Watch
Track this member
Statistics
Activity Points
1,671
Rank
942 of 446,072
Watchers
8 members
Time Online
1 second
Comments
594
Site Visits
5,451
Profile Visitors
32,134 (24 today)
Contact
Private Message
Send Now
Email
Members Only
MCh2207Cz
MCh2207Cz friends since Dec 5, 2011
Yukino-Yukinoshita-♥
Yukino-Yukinoshita-♥ friends since Sep 16, 2013
=СРБ=Ori`verda
=СРБ=Ori`verda friends since Oct 22, 2011
InsanityPays
InsanityPays friends since Jul 12, 2012
ℱℓơℊℊℯɾ✈
ℱℓơℊℊℯɾ✈ friends since Nov 6, 2013
spetsnaz_stalker
spetsnaz_stalker friends since May 8, 2013
jnoonfelt
jnoonfelt friends since May 24, 2012
SRB-HawkEye-
SRB-HawkEye- friends since Dec 5, 2011
Vassili_Tzaisev
Vassili_Tzaisev friends since Jul 15, 2012
GordonTheCat
GordonTheCat friends since Jan 28, 2014