It has begun! ☃

  • View media
RSS feed My Blogs

I recently read that J.R.R Tolkien intended for the Lord of the Rings universe to be like a 'forgotten history' of Earth. For example, areas like The Shire are supposedly set in ancient Europe.
I think that's strange and very interesting, to think that the whole time the story is playing out, the setting is actually on the planet Earth and not in some fantasy world like I once thought. It feels like a different perspective of things for me.

It's all fiction, but it's still very neat.

Recently, I was downloading and playing old demos of games from the 90s like Grim Fandango. One fantasy game I played was set in a fantasy setting with fictional races, with locations such as medieval fairs and castles, but supposedly later on (as I saw in a video) you go to an ancient human ruin - which is a decaying concrete river dam with modern objects like beds and computers. The game does establish in the intro that there were once humans, with the fact that they vanished due to mysterious reasons. But still, once you go into a location like that, an abandoned and decrepit dam, it really does create a strange new atmosphere. All that fantasy feeling just vanishes and now you're looking at something entirely new. It's uncanny.

One can become established in a fantasy world. It's full of wonderful things and all this rich content to explore; things just present themselves as fantastic and engaging. They can feel like there's this new universe to learn about, untouched by nonfiction. But when the story of that fantasy suddenly establishes that the this 'fantasy world' is actually the remnant or precursor to a very real and not-so-fantastic Earth - it's like a skeleton is found buried within the gut of the fairy tale. In that moment, all those fantastic elements are skewed into a new, strange light.

Putting it in that light, that the fantasy story is before or after Earth, seems to portray some very dark elements. For example, in the game I previously mentioned involving fictional races and placing humans in the past, it implied that the humans vanished due to some kind of plague, and then stated that the humans may have either fled to the depths of the ocean, or into space. There's also the possibility that they all simply died off. Despite all the wonderful and cheerful fantasy elements that the game may present to you while you play it, you can't help but wonder about what happened to former civilization; everything turns into a post-apocalyptic feeling instead of a fantasy feeling at that moment. The brilliance of the world suddenly gains a much darker history.

I personally think this form of a setting has interesting effects on fictional fantasy stories. I feel it really does make the story darker than it appears to be. It can also bring up some very bizarre and exciting story elements. For instance, during and after the time I played the demo of that fantasy game, I continued to wonder about what would happen if a modern human suddenly returned to Earth? What fascinating scenario would that introduce to the medieval denizens of that world?

If similar elements were incorporated into a story, what would happen if they were introduced to the audience later on as a surprise, and not in the beginning? A similar circumstance occurs in the novel The City of Ember. Upon first reading it, the reader may be drawn into the dark grungy world that is the City of Ember. It presents a very surreal version of a world without any stars, sun, or natural light. The only light is from the electric light bulbs that illuminate the city.

Upon first reading this, I was drawn into the story, I wanted to know more about this dark world and why it was like so. Throughout the story, the lights of the city are failing, so the protagonists need to find a way to save the city. They find escape plans and eventually leave. Where do they turn up when they leave? The surface. They discover that they have lived in a massive underground cave, placed there by their ancestors to shelter them from a previous apocalypse. Unfortunately, the movie adaptation of the book quickly dispells the mysterious location of the City of Ember, and even announces in the movie trailer that they're underground. This completely disregards the element of mystery that I loved.

The point still stands though. Learning that their story was set in the remnants of a previous Earth created a new light for everything.

This was originally supposed to be a short PM to someone, but it has grown into a long blog post. What do you think about this subject?

Start a group Groups
Definitely not a league of villains

Definitely not a league of villains

6 members Developer

Varied members with talents, who were drawn together with one major purpose in mind: To make some stuff or something. With a summary that vague, you would...

New Folder Devs

New Folder Devs

2 members Developer & Publisher

This is the developer group for the New Folder project.

Post comment Comments  (0 - 10 of 22)
AngryRockStudios Oct 2 2013 says:

Thank you very much for supporting our game, DümBot! Your support is very important to us and we truly do appreciate you for it. :D

+1 vote     reply to comment
HeadClot May 16 2013 says:

Hey thank you for tracking RedCon.

Means allot.

+1 vote     reply to comment
SinKing Feb 12 2013 says:

There are a lot of historians that say LOTR's is based in Tolkien's fear of the colonies breaking off. The British Empire was in a state of change and first waves of immigration flooded the country. It is said that Tolkien was concerned with the English nation and felt like the empire was surrounded by its enemies.

So what LOTR is really about is reinstating the empire, slaying back the savage hordes and ensuring the white man's dominance over all lowly creatures. So, from this standpoint T. was a racist, who put it all into a fantasy book. Certainly, Tolkien was alienated by what happened to the Empire, back then. He wished for an ideal state, exactly like how it was before.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Warner Creator
Warner Feb 14 2013 replied:

Interesting. I'm no LOTR fanatic, but I've only heard that Tolkien wanted the story of LOTR to be interpreted in many ways.

If that's really the case (about the reinstating of the empire), that really does seem to put a damper on the whole thing.

+1 vote   reply to comment
argonzeit Dec 4 2012 says:

Hey, I move the 21st of this month. We should try and hang out before I leave and fall off the face of the earth.

+1 vote     reply to comment
oleomingus Aug 13 2012 says:

Thank-you for tracking our game,
Your support is most encouraging.

+2 votes     reply to comment
ReTRoKiDDe Jul 25 2012 says:

Thanks for following Star Knights! It's a pleasure!

+2 votes     reply to comment
argonzeit Jul 6 2012 says:

Hey man, I am starting up a Unity Game. I texted you a few times but it seems like you dont use your phone any more xD

Unity has to be my favorite engine right now.

Thats the horrible concept art i made on the front page. If you go into it it has the description of the game.

+3 votes     reply to comment
ninjadave Jun 1 2012 says:

Actually, at this exact time of post, there are 984,647 Moddb Members,

+3 votes     reply to comment
Silverfisk Apr 27 2012 says:

The icon in my avatar is the new logo for Overgrowth Weekly (the weekly web show that I do). It really doesn't make a lot of sense to have that here on indiedb though now that I think about it. But that's what it is anyways.

+2 votes     reply to comment
Post a comment

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account:

Last Online
Nov 25 2015
United States United States
Become friends
Member watch
Start tracking
735 of 541,617
15,583 (5 today)
Time Online
1 week
Activity Points
5 members
Site visits
Send Message
ninjadave Online 2 days ago
iQew Online 2 days ago
nosfer4tu Online 6 days ago
argonzeit Online 1 month ago
Bakscratch Online 1 year ago