Report What would you like to see more of on the moddatabase?

Poll started by ForK with 1,123 votes and 31 comments. Browse the poll archive.

 8%

(90 votes)Competitions

 35%

(392 votes)Mod and Game Reviews

 45%

(508 votes)Tutorials

 5%

(51 votes)Interviews

 7%

(82 votes)Awards given out

Post comment Comments
Nigther
Nigther - - 15 comments

Wow, how is it am almost first to post everytime!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
chis
chis - - 1,510 comments

everyone loves teh tutorials

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
duckedtapedemon
duckedtapedemon - - 557 comments

yea agreed, to bad i fail at writing them :(

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
AJ_Quick
AJ_Quick - - 1,321 comments

Proper mod reviews, and more awards and features.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
ForK Creator
ForK - - 721 comments

Well, if you guys are mod leaders and would like us to review your mod for the site, all you have to do is contact one of the feature writers on the staff page and they will do it for you! So make sure you keep that in mind!

Reply Good karma+1 vote
NewfZ
NewfZ - - 42 comments

Theres nothing better then a good competition.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Froyo
Froyo - - 10 comments

Deffently more mod and game reviews! a few more tutorials would be nice too

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Guest
Guest - - 689,439 comments

This comment is currently awaiting admin approval, join now to view.

Guest
Guest - - 689,439 comments

This comment is currently awaiting admin approval, join now to view.

dDefinder
dDefinder - - 85 comments

Tutorials
anyone? :D

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Zacker_lvldsnr
Zacker_lvldsnr - - 84 comments

Interviews, you usually get to hear a lot of interesting stuff in those.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Guest
Guest - - 689,439 comments

This comment is currently awaiting admin approval, join now to view.

GangstaThug
GangstaThug - - 5 comments

more mod and game reviews

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Forsete
Forsete - - 619 comments

Interviews, always interesting to read.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
kooper
kooper - - 192 comments

lots more tutorials

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Minigun_Fiend
Minigun_Fiend - - 83 comments

i want to win stuff! you hear me? WIN STUFF!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Crispy
Crispy - - 602 comments

Tutorials are a big part of developing a Mod, but often forums can be a better source of information (at least this is what I've found as far as mapping goes).

As a Mod leader, I'm more concerned with game development as a whole, not the mechanics, which I know I can pick up from various sources on the net. I'm kinda contradicting myself here, I know that the ModDB doesn't have enough tutorials, which isn't a problem because I know where to find these, but at the same time it would be nice if there were more tuts around. Last time I looked there were 4 tuts for mapping for Source, and one of them was just a Hammer (one could even say WorldCraft) rehash tutorial on how to make a room.

I prefer interviews overall, though, and would like to see much more. With so many Mods still in development for games like D3, Source, Farcry, and Dawn of War, Mod reviews will mostly be for games that less people play. Yes, every Mod worth reviewing should get a review on release by either a team member or a guest member of the public, but with the Modding community concentrated on the latest engines I think interviews would be the best thing to focus on for two reasons:

1. Most current gen Mods will be in development for a while, and so reviews won't be an option until much later. Perhaps previews should fill this spot, with a vote out of the top ten publicly submitted games to win a preview spot by ModDB; a 'One to Watch' of sorts.

2. Interviews can be done with Mod teams for updates on their projects, keeping the ModDB community up to date with the most promising Mods.

3. Interviews could also be done with professionals from the world of Game Development to give the sort of information that can usually only be gained from experience: advice on what steps to go through when making a Mod, and in which order; how to manage your team members effectively and keep them working efficiently; how to enhance your communication skills and their importance both within the team and when keeping the public informed; how to choose your 3D scale for maximum results in your game; how to pace a story (single player); map design and level flow; weapon design and balance.

I suppose the last reason is like a tutorial taken one step further, not to talk about the mechanics of the game, but the reasoning behind it. I think a greater understanding of the latter would greatly improve the quality of Mods and Modding in general.

- Crispy

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Qwertyz
Qwertyz - - 354 comments

Need toutorials.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Kalashnikov
Kalashnikov - - 92 comments

Since the modification databases houses the largest listing of modifications for games out there, I would personally like to see a larger movement to speak with the developers themselves on them. It would really quite secure your place as the modification-database as not only do you list modifications, you also provide a closer and more in-depth look into them. Reviews are also up there with Interviews.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
josendk
josendk - - 3 comments

tutorial rox t3h b0x

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
SEThorian
SEThorian - - 93 comments

Interviews are more interesting because, as someone mentioned before, you usually get to know loads of interesting stuff.. Not only do the interviewed always leave behind nifty clues as to what features or plot related features there might be in the mod, they also give a good insight in how those mod teams handle their business.

Also interesting is to know how mods came to be and how all the features were thought up. I certainly would be interested for instance in reading interviews with Andrew Weldon, Marc Schröder, but also from people behind lesser known yet promising looking mods.

(Such as Bugstompers! :))

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
bart2o
bart2o - - 1,863 comments

Tuts tuts tuts.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
San-J
San-J - - 662 comments

It is funny that the one type of feature that is user-made would be the most saught after. If you want tutorials so badly, write some! :D

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
M@ty
M@ty - - 508 comments

Tutorials are easy to deal with. I plan over the summer to wirte a 3DS tutorial covering; Modelling, UVmapping, texturing (to a small extent) and compailing into hl2 in one long-*** tutorial :)

Interviews for me, would like to know more about mods and hear it from the teams.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Ikarus
Ikarus - - 50 comments

I'm backing up Crispy all the way. Interviews are the best way to learn about upcomming mods, new features in already released ones or just to learn what modders have to say. Besides making interviews is a lot easier than trying to put all the info in an article (preview, review, whatev), and the real deal is that the mod makers actually get their chance to talk about what's on their mind that way. As for reviews and tutorials - there are a lot of other specialised sites for those and i personally would like to visit an Unreal tutorial site when i'm mapping for UT (just an example, I'm actually just a press member:)) rather than visiting a site that has all sorts of stuff in it.

All in all - interviews. That's the right and most painless way to let the modders speak up and fill us in on the latest news about their projects and teams. And that's what MODDB is all about - it is not a place for judgement, it's about letting modders show what they have in store for us. Pls keep it that way:)

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
fino963
fino963 - - 10 comments

This poll looks like its just been one-sided to modder's votes, not Mod Watchers and people who play the mods. I personally would like to see awards to see what mods I should check out and what mods are worthwhile to try. Interviews would be given to mods that are a working progress on how they are doing and what their mod will be about and reviews would tell me, again, what mods are worthwhile.

I would rather see more awards, interviews, and reviews because I am not one to take time or have the experience to mod.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
J1mmmy
J1mmmy - - 169 comments

I'm in favour of something that isn't on the poll at all. Feature articles on modding.

Where it's going, where it's been, the present state of modding, why it is special and retrospectives on the classic mods. You get the idea.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
kol
kol - - 15 comments

Tutorials :P

But also, "Printer Friendly" versions - some tutorials have a paragraph on one page... its not very practical.

But Mod Reviews are a very good idea.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
garrett
garrett - - 378 comments

Come on Mod and Game Reviews! It's starting to catch up! O_o

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Guest
Guest - - 689,439 comments

This comment is currently awaiting admin approval, join now to view.

Guest
Guest - - 689,439 comments

This comment is currently awaiting admin approval, join now to view.

Post a comment

Your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account: