Archasis II is a moderately-paced first/third person shooter total conversion for UT3 set in a fantasy world of swords and magic. It features RPG-like player progression, cooperative objective-oriented gameplay, a variety of character classes, multi-path skill trees, and a hybrid of 3rd-person melee and 1st-person ranged combat.

Report article RSS Feed Archasis II - Modding to Win

The brief history of Archasis (I & II) and its development.

Posted by stenchy on Jul 15th, 2009
Article


Development for Competition

It’s safe to say the notion of creating a video game has crossed the mind of almost anyone that has played one, the nearly 10,000 modifications on ModDB alone attest this. To accelerate the production of these mods, Epic Games tapped into the competitive nature of gamers and modders with the Make Something Unreal Contest. The MSUC made its first appearance in 2003, sponsored by Nvidia and utilizing the UnrealEngine 2.0. The outcome was the production of such acclaimed modifications as Red Orchestra, Air Buccaneers, and Alien Swarm. As Epic Games polished their third iteration of the UnrealEngine, they teamed up with Intel to once again revive the competition. The Make Something Unreal Contest for UnrealEngine 3.0 was announced in April of 2008.

The idea of the MSUC resonated well with my competitive personality. The thought of being rewarded for work I was willing to do for free was enticing. I participated in Phase 4 and the Grand Finals of the original Make Something Unreal Contest and revived the project for the second MSUC. It started with the typical naivety that I could single-handedly put together the greatest mod imaginable in a matter of months and claim my reward. My scope of work was way out of perspective.

It has been six years since I imported my first weapon into the Unreal Editor – an untextured bow that lacked animations and fired rockets – and I can only imagine what I would have done differently had I the modding insight I have now. I cannot say there is a definitive right or wrong way to approach modding for competition since every project is unique, but there are some general strategies I have learned that make success within reach.


The Never-Ending Design

My first mod, Archasis: Battle for Durian, was started just for the fun of it. I had been playing a lot of Team Fortress Classic as well as Day of Defeat, a WWII mod for Half-life that involved capturing flag points. My affinity for fantasy games led me to the idea of a class-based multiplayer game (TFC) with swords, bows, magic, and capture points. My “design document” was a paragraph long with a few bullet points. I started production right away and let the project evolve as I learned more about the Unreal Engine and the ins & outs of modding. Archasis was my experimental project, but the adlib design kept production moving very quickly. I used a lot of “programmer art,” which of course didn’t look great but still allowed development to move forward. By the end of the project, I had a multiplayer game with six unique character classes, RPG-like progression, and a bunch of special skills and character upgrades for players to choose from.

Archasis IArchasis IArchasis I[click an image for a direct link to the gallery]

When the second MSUC came around, it was time to get serious about competing. A team was assembled and we got to work on a fully-fleshed out design document for Archasis II. This ended up being a disaster. No need to get specific, but basically the whole team fell apart from detail-related disagreements and a lack of motivation since there was no visible production. After several months of design, the team went from eight to two and all we had to show was a lengthy design document full of unpractical detail (of which maybe 1% is actually being used now). At that point we knew our strategy had to change, so we reverted to Archasis 1’s improvised style of design. The team focused on one core aspect of the game at a time, evaluating how time-consuming it would actually be to implement and then test it out in-game. Within a few months, we were actually hacking each other up with swords and having fun doing it!


Team Member Flux

Production since our initial turning point had been steady and fruitful, but not without trouble. Team management was a significant struggle. After the departure of the original team, the remaining members put in a huge recruitment effort to attract talent; but without content to show off our mod, our lack-luster attempts to get help failed. The team advertised “the opportunity to boost your portfolio with modding experience” as well as “the chance to compete in the MSUC and win prizes,” but with so many other promising mods in existence there was nothing unique in our offer. We managed to catch the attention of a few contributors, who offered their two cents and then vanished. Our best bet was to move forward with who we had in order to show the modding community we were serious about development.

For most of Archasis II’s development to date, the team size never exceeded more than a few active members. Since we are dealing with a competition deadline that is fast-approaching, we had to scale the scope of work to accommodate this, deciding to eliminate superfluous ideas and details that could not be accomplished with the current team. Although there is the possibility of finding additional contributors and team members before the end of the competition, we also have to deal with the possibility that the pool of available talent is empty. After all, a finished simple mod is far more effective than an incomplete complex one. Currently we find ourselves relying on the fluidity of the ad hoc design process, which allows us to adjust the direction and amplitude of development relative to the available workforce.

Involving the Community

Both Archasis mods had surges in production throughout their development, directly following their first public release. Unlike a game development company that had in-house play testers, I relied on the community for feedback. This meant I had to put together an alpha build and make it available as soon as possible. Screenshots and demonstration videos brought in valuable critiques on art-related aspects, but for me that wasn’t particularly helpful in development. After the first release of the original Archasis, my forum was instantly populated by community members that wanted to share their thoughts on the mod. The feedback ranged from “good work” to four-page design change suggestions. I wanted to please the community, but couldn’t possibly satisfy everyone, particularly with deadlines looming overhead. I filtered the critiques to those most appropriate for the mod and then explored them as viable additions or changes. The forum was a great place to do this because I could have an open, guided dialogue with the community who then became an element of the design process.

However, there were risks involved in releasing alpha builds of the mod. Plenty of trolls loved to prey on the early releases with unproductive critiques, which if taken to heart could have substantially hurt the motivation of the team. Also, some of the bugs and incompleteness of the content in early releases hindered evaluation and it was easy to overlook the completed elements. This reinforced the development team’s need to hold back on the details and solidify the basics first. The alpha releases were geared to demonstrate specific aspects of the mod, and were often a few steps behind the actual development.


Archasis II’s production had a rough start compared to the original mod, but our adjustments in workflow improved the rate of development and we have been able to get back on the competitive path. With phase 4 of the MSUC fast-approaching, the team has been working vigorously to put together something for all to enjoy and we are pleased with the direction the mod is headed. As always, the design continues to evolve and we look forward to the input of the mod community!

Archasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis IIArchasis II[click an image for a direct link to the gallery]


Written by Jamie Galimberti
Edited by Ryan Anderson

Post comment Comments
Dremth
Dremth Jul 15 2009, 1:11am says:

looks good. please make this better than the hl2 mod Age of Chivalry. i really wanted to like that mod, but something about it deterred me time and time again.
this was quite an entertaining article. i really liked the graph and it's probably fairly accurate.

+4 votes     reply to comment
sbnewsom
sbnewsom Jul 15 2009, 1:25am says:

Wow, that flow chart is absolutely true! Artists always seem to fail to keep a steady flow of enthusiasm. They always bust it all out in the beginning, then slack off not long after. hehe

+4 votes     reply to comment
Herr_Alien
Herr_Alien Jul 15 2009, 5:08am replied:

I think it's also a demand issue: their work is needed only after the first concepts are done, then only later on, for further aditions/corrections.
But no matter the cause, the graph does look right.

+5 votes     reply to comment
Cece
Cece Jul 15 2009, 5:52pm replied:

Concept artists always put in a heavy ammount of work in the beginning.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Ryswick17
Ryswick17 Jul 15 2009, 3:24am says:

This mod looks fantastic, times like these I wish i jumped on some of those steam sales for UT3.

+3 votes     reply to comment
AlCool
AlCool Jul 15 2009, 3:32am says:

Haha, you guys must have had fun developing the first XD

Goto see some more gameplay videos soon on here :D

+3 votes     reply to comment
Icedecknight
Icedecknight Jul 15 2009, 9:46am says:

You mod looks awesome im not surprised at all the you made it on mods and indies.

+2 votes     reply to comment
pvt.Johnson
pvt.Johnson Jul 15 2009, 10:39am says:

Very nice mod, keep up the great work!

+1 vote     reply to comment
spellman23
spellman23 Jul 15 2009, 1:42pm says:

very insightful article.

It's good to know that sometimes the ad hoc system works. I know that in many areas the better organized you are the better. But it seems you guys were able to take advantage of fresh talent and get rid of stale ideas very easily making the project something you could enjoy working on (and show results w/ quick turnarounds too).

And as all good teams, you've learned from your mistakes. A huge plus. Too many times the teams won't adapt to the criticism, the workflow, or even each others growing talents. It's encouraging to see a team that was able to stick it out even when reduced to the bare minimum workers.

Kudos and I can't wait to see the polished product.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Dr.Sean
Dr.Sean Jul 15 2009, 1:47pm says:

How do I install a UT3 mod for my steam copy of Unrealtournament 3?

+1 vote     reply to comment
Post a Comment
click to sign in

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) which we encourage all contributors to do.

2000 characters limit; HTML formatting and smileys are not supported - text only

Icon
Unreal Tournament 3 Icon
Platform
Windows
Developer
Team Archasis
Contact
Send Message
Official Page
Archasis.com
Release Date
Released Nov 12, 2009
Mod Watch
Track this mod
Feature
Browse
Features
Report Abuse
Report article
Related Mods
Archasis II (Unreal Tournament 3)
Archasis II Unreal Tournament 3 - Single Player First Person Shooter
Related Games
Unreal Tournament 3
Unreal Tournament 3 Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Related Groups
Summer of Mods & Indies
Summer of Mods & Indies Official event with 136 members
Team Archasis
Team Archasis Developer & Publisher