Comments - Hawkbat

I don't think the word "mutant" really fits. But overall the design is excellent!

Not Rohirrim. They are just described as wearing green in the books.

So awesome to watch this progress from concept to model on Youtube. Great job guys!

This mod is a lot of fun, but does anyone know why I can’t select any of the dwarven characters? Are they just not available or am I missing something?

True. It is mentioned as being in service with the Galactic Republic Navy towards the end of the Clone Wars in the new Canon novel Tarkin. They haven't mentioned the separate Victory I and Victory II class existing, just that the Victory SDs did exist during the Republic Navy.
Starwars.wikia.com

So I understand if you don't want ISDs, but if you are looking for Super Capital Ships, then even in Canon the Republic used the Victory-class. Most of the other mods for this era use them too if I recall.

How about the "Guards of Rammas Echor"? Or maybe the "Wardens of Rammas Echor"?

That is the outer wall encircling the Pelennnor Fields around Minas Tirith.

Dalian Kings Guard sounds good

Lol Good one

Excellent work.
Will there be a variant of the Army Airborne that wears the Air Assault helmet which some apparently wore?

Awesome job. I am glad your back at it, I was starting to miss your updates.

Before anyone posts "it is dead" comments I would advise you to check out their twitter page and Soul Games youtube channel.

No it is not dead.
See Soul Games playing the pre-release version or check there twitter.

You find that minor inaccuracies "ruin the fun", but not removing the war from its historical context and thereby removing it from most of its meaning and history?
I am sorry but that doesn't seem to make much sense.

It seems most people here agree that a bunch of little inaccuracies are preferable.

Trucks looked more like this in WWI:
En.wikipedia.org

Please set the game in the real world. It is a very good mod, but I believe that it loses something when you remove it from it's historical context. Being able to recreate the actual battles and campaign scenarios of the war could only make the mod better.

And I may possibly be able to help you with accuracy. Although I am not a historian, I am studying history at University. But there is so much easily accessible information out there that it shouldn't be too difficult anyway.

Great job, there is so much content in this mod. The units look amazing as well.

They could still work as the 327th heroes as their Battalion was a part of that unit.
It would be interesting if it worked out as I know no other FOC Clone Wars mod has implemented them.

The only other lore issue I could point out is that I'm pretty sure the 65th Legion is a fanon name as they are only ever referred to as Coruscant Guard or Shocktroopers in the lore (of course if that was chosen because you like it that is totally fine).

Anyway thanks for considering my input. Keep up the great work!

Captain Deviss' K Company, the hero unit for the 327th Star Corps, was a part of the Hawkbat Battalion according to the lore (which was a sub unit of the 327th)

Although Deviss looked similar to other 327th clones (except for his Red markings), we know that Hawkbat troopers wore cloaks in Phase 1 (see below):

Vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net

Jedibusiness.com

Of course we don't know if they wore those in Phase 2, but they did wear them in Phase 1.

Like I said, I don't know if that would be hard to rig or not, but it was just a suggestion for their Phase 1 variant if you wanted to do them accurately. If you don't like the look, that's fine.

I was going over some of your older pictures in the gallery and I had to ask, will you be adding the standard grey 41st Elite Corps Troopers?

I know you are doing Green Company as a Hero unit, but will the regular 41st troops look like how we see them on Coruscant in Episode III? And what about the Forest/Jungle Camo they wear on Kashyyyk?

1999.co.jp

Another question is since you are including K Company of Hawkbat Battalion, will they have the cloaks for Phase 1 like out of the microseries (like my picture)? I don't know if it is hard to rig or not, just a thought.

Anyway, sorry for rambling on. Love your work so far.

Looks great.
And I totally agree with you about the Open Circle Fleet. Simply because they have been given the most coverage in the lore, everyone treats Open Circle Fleet ships as the default.

Wow! Well done, that was really well made.

Apparently they specialize in tropical environments in general.

I would go C. It is a clever idea and both skins are great.

Awesome job!
The models look amazing, I can't wait to try them.

A few suggestions:
1) As has already been said, the Knights probably should be renamed.
2) It would be cool to see some region specific units eg Rills cavalry, Crannogmen, Skagosi, Northern Mountain Clans and White Harbor Knights.

However, as it stands, this looks really great.

This is something I have been really hoping for. I really think that it would set your mod apart from all the others.

I think you should go with the new skin.

Sounds good. Variety is always better!
As for the CIS, Trench is an obvious choice. I don't know much about Admiral Kirst and Tonith, but they could be good options for the CIS Navy.

Don't worry about them. I have often found that people put unfair or unrealistic pressures on Mod creators.

These guys look very cool. I really appreciate the effort you guys are going to with the amount of Clone legions/battalions and unit types.