This member has provided no bio about themself...
I'll bite. I'm guessing it can build planets. Seems about the right shape.
Ozzy you continue to be an extremely erudite voice of reason.
That's likely because the people who liked it don't bother commenting. Isn't that like the first rule of understanding forums, the people who actually like the content don't feel the need to go and make posts about it.
Also make sure you don't fall for several people complaining over and over for a whole community complaining once or twice each.
That turtle based walker looks promising. Hope you don't scrap the whole thing because that really does just scream UEF. Some of the other designs look great too. Can't wait to see what these inspired, got replaced by or favored for.
I've just realized this looks like a gunship from metal gear.
Catamaran of some sort?
May I suggest saving directly to drop box.
Your argument is good except for one small problem: it's not an argument. Had TCW been before SW:CW you'd be for the former and against the latter. What you and many others fail to understand is this: 1. Lucas has the last say when it comes to star wars (or did till he sold it, thank the stars) so if he wanted to change the established cannon so be it. 2. The books whilst cool aren't established cannon, they are not quite cannon not quite fannon, a limbo state between the two. Yeah I'll give you the bad writing in TCW but it was hardly better in SW:CW they're for kids what do you expect? TCW has however despite your many attempts to ignore it stayed pretty close to established cannon, with the Rep' Commandos for example. They kept what they liked from SW:CW too e.g. V-19 Torrent.
My point? Whilst I know you do this with the best intentions, your hatred for this show relies on just as much bias on your part as it does on TCW being poor in places.
Not sure about the Leman Russ, are you going to be adding Sky Ray and Hammer Head Grav Tanks? May I also recommend, if possible, to add Piranha. That and some of the Larger battle suits.
Other than that, great work, cannae wait, I love the Tau.
Cool, this might be interesting to see.
I can't wait for all the spoiled fans to cry when Character x isn't in the right place or vehicle y gets introduced at the wrong time, because that's what will happen I assure you.
Just look at the description, couldn't not take a dig at TCW could you. Can't just pull that self righteous stick out of your own arses and get over that you don't like what Lucas did with the Clone Wars and that this is his brain child not yours. Don't like it, write a fan'fic' and create your own personal cannon. Act like a mature human being, if the star wars community can actually manage that.
That looks pretty cool. Can't wait to see some Cybran support vessels.
What role do these frigates fill?
Why can I imagine this saying "Po Po" or "You know where they're not? Safe." or laughing creepily.
There is a difference between polite requests for changes and complaints. Besides making something smaller would make it easier to fit. xD
p.s. You made MRs large, so why not the crucible.
This unit should also be available to be built by ships but have it named slightly differently as a variant armed with sonar and depth charges and a weaker gun because this thing seems like a very versatile platform.
What job will this fighter have? Will it be a close support for bombers, able to hold its own against ASF especially in numbers, or will it be a T1 exterminator that will prevent spamming of T1 aircraft and force a switch in strategies from your opponent.
What kind of bomber is this? Precision/ Carpet, Missiles/Rockets/Bombs. Will the bombs have any specific effects EMP/Napalm.
Still a few scale related issues*, other than that, this looks amazing.
* Reaper Destroyer is still too big.
* The Crucible is too small.
Read the reason why the Reaper Titan is so big. It is quite interesting Moddb.com
In this games law Shepard failed to save the Geth, they are now all enslaved by the Reapers. I will be playing Council just so I can avenge their deaths.
It was definitely a cruiser. No Turian dreadnoughts were seen in that battle.
The "Reaper Destroyer" is too big. It's small enough to walk on a Turian cruiser.
Do the reapers get the Geth dreadnought?
No it doesn't, too many Cybran units have tail guns already. The UEF certainly doesn't need any.
I noticed it too.
It is the missile pods, they look too big. The take up too much space. Perhaps making them smaller or changing their shape. That is the reason I recommended either making it wider or longer. It should still be a smaller vessel but it just seems out of proportion with its weapons especially at the front.
Wow the service here is top notch.
Ok Whirlwind is cool. I like.
The "No Name" still looks weird, I'm not sure what it is, something just doesn't look "right".
Ok you've sold me on the Aegis. Perhaps it is just that it hasn't been textured. The weapons just look a little too close together at the front. It looks cluttered. I'll reserve judgement until I see it textured.
Thanks for the quick feedback.
The Aegis needs to be a bit longer or a bit wider. A good concept though, help keep a fleet covered.
Could we get another view of the whirlwind I can't quite get how it moves.
The "No Name" looks pretty cool. Though it looks a little too tall/ top heavy. Though the concept sounds pretty dang cool.
The sub looks great (oddly reminiscent of a Covenant cruiser from halo, no complaints.
Ooh what kind of weapons are you thinking of adding? Don't over do it because it doesn't look half bad as it is.