This group is for people who notice canononical contradictions within popular sci-fi and fantasy franchises and wish to discuss them in a safe, TROLL FREE, environment.
how the hell is this propaganda?
this is not propaganda, its demonstrating all the things that were saved from being reticoned. its purely informative.
THIS IS PROPAGANDA: Moddb.com
the way i see it you can continue to be butthurt about the goddamn show or you could look on the brighter side of things. you sure your okay buddy? you seem to be pretty negative today.
every other comment i see from you is "gaah ********" or "soooo not true". normally your comments are less negative
Ya. My problem is your busy claiming a bunch of stuff was saved from being NON CANON which is completely false because NOTHING is made non canon because of a contradiction.
Meanwhile Disney is shutting down every star wars production in existence. They need to finish the show. I don't care if they do just one more ARC where maul kills Rex and Ventress kills maul and disappears but they can't just leave the show open ended with Maul and Rex alive. So go ahead and post your baseless speculations while Star Wars is torn apart and all we are left with is a new movie which BTW is likely going to be filled with more contradictions to lower canon stories.
the movie conflicting with canon i am at peace with as ive said 100 times before, because that era in star wars history is still being written and seeing that theyre using gorge's original script with some changes.
i understand maul and ventress but why does Rex need to die? there are millions of clones, his existence does not conflict with anything. unless something happened with him in season five that im not aware of
Thats hypocritical. Its not still being written. Its covered very well by EU just like the clone wars. You will have a problem with a show from Lucas being done that conflicts with lower canon material but not a new movie from whats left of Lucas conflicting that eras lower canon.
I can't die, I'm your mods scripter :P
its not hypocritical, the movies are the ultimate source of canon and i respect that. its when the lower levels conflict with each other that's when things get tense.
and even if it were hypocritical everybody is a damn hypocrite.
"do you like gettin' handjobs? do you like givin' handjobs? then your a ****** hypocrite too now smoke meh weed" -George Bush from Harold and Kumar escape from Guantanamo bay.
and you still haven't answered my question as to why rex's death is essential to the plot?
I suppose Rex doesn't in fact I would prefer he didn't. I guess even Ventress could be left since she is a bounty hunter now and could be far from any events in the movies but Maul being a sith and Darth Sidious' puppet now must go
perhaps with the series ended with a cliffhanger, they COULD (not that they would) reticon some of that stuff. the whole maul arc was doomed from the start, why people liked it puzzled me
As I said before, making Maul live is part of this whole annoying pattern of Lucas and even EU authors, resurrecting dead characters and for that reason I was adimently against the whole idea, however once I saw what they did with the whole thing I was turned. No other story Arc was as good as the maul and Mandalore ARC and the ARC with him and the pirates was really good too.
how can you say such a thing? the maul arc was god awful. he's dead, when your chopped in half and thrown down a reactor shaft your dead your done you're dead you died and life goes on. and don't give me the "oh but palpitine survived the deathstar" because no, he didn't. his force essence transferred into one of many of his clones.
as for the mandalore arc, that ****** so many thousands of star wars fans off. i cant say weather the conclusion of the mandalore arc was good or not because i didn't see it so you have me there, however the sheer fact that it ****** off ALOT of people id have to say the mandalore arc wasn't a success. the only reason why the maul arc was so popular is because they broght back a familiar character. no one cared how he survived or why the hell it was even important to bring him back and do you know why? because little kids and stupid people like repetition. its essentially "oh! ive seen him before! oh wait? didn't he die? awe who care just as long as pretty colors flash into my retinas ill keep shelling out my money to these people!"
And there you go, being a degrading nitwit again, insulting the intelligence of other star wars fans as usual.
Fact #1: You did not watch any of this season and therefore have no right to comment
Fact #2: It is Star Wars, filled with force users who can heal the dying, fall from incredible distances without a scratch, shot people with lightning from fingers, destroy entire worlds with the force. General Grievious is a nothing more than a heart and a brain but you choose to ignorantly argue that in the star wars universe something is impossible.
Fact #3: You do not speak for star wars fans and judging others like you do is completely ignorant and ****** people off. You are not some champion for star wars history, you are a judgemental extremist who can't give a unbiased review of anything you have already prejudged.
Furthermore you are a hypocrit. Some of your beloved sources (Delta's preferred history sources) contradict other things of there same canon level yet they, in your opinion should be held up high as if they are G canon.
The purpose of star wars is entertainment and instead of acknowledging the fact that TCW's is creating a whole new generation of star wars fans, including girls for a change; you choose to bitch and judge it as the bain of star wars exsistence. Contradictions exist in every great franchise, I wonder if they have judgemental extremist like you who insult and belittle newer fans and older ones who have an open mind
Ozzy you continue to be an extremely erudite voice of reason.
Too bad reason is lost on those clouded with hatred.
dude i was on star wars.com reading the comments on some of the mandalore episodes. it ****** ALOT of people off.
That's likely because the people who liked it don't bother commenting. Isn't that like the first rule of understanding forums, the people who actually like the content don't feel the need to go and make posts about it.
Also make sure you don't fall for several people complaining over and over for a whole community complaining once or twice each.
You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account: