I make computer games, mostly small ones, in Java. My favorite games to play are probably Armageddon Empires, Minecraft and Master of Orion II.

RSS My Blogs

It's occurred to me that all three dungeon crawler games I currently play have something in common: positioning matters a lot.

Hoplite is literally the only Android game I actually play. It's a simple but elegant hex-based dungeon crawl wherein you must traverse sixteen levels to reach the Fleece of Yendor. Each turn, you can move one tile in one direction or use your limited special actions to jump, bash with your shield, or throw your spear. Enemies are defeated by either moving straight towards them or starting and ending your move on an adjacent tile.

This means that good Hoplite play is all about reading the juxtaposition of your enemies and finding a path that lets you kill them without taking any damage. It gets particularly satisfying when you manage to kill multiple enemies at once.

The Binding of Isaac, both in its original and second version, is all about predicting the movement and attack patterns of your opponents. Some move in straight lines, or jump diagonally, or charge. Some fire shots in bursts or specific patterns.

It actually reminds me of chess a bit: hoppers' jumps are like knights', while the crosswise and diagonal attacks of clotties and clots requires you to superimpose the same pattern onto the screen as you would while evaluating an enemy rook or bishop.

And in Crypt of the Necrodancer, the positional aspect is both in the movement patterns of the enemy - skeletons move every second turn, so you have to make sure you are in the correct phase of the beat - and in the damage patterns of your weapons. In a traditional roguelike, swords and daggers and spears all operate at point-blank range and are differentiated by their damage and maybe certain bonuses. In Necrodancer, a basic sword, dagger and spear all do the same damage, but in a different pattern of tiles. This again makes positioning more interesting - in fact, I'd rather have a normal sword than a titanium (double-damage) dagger.

(As an aside, this held true in real life too - in medieval warfare, the main weapon was the spear and rather the pike. Daggers and even swords were secondary weapons you'd use if you had to. Our modern depiction of everyone using swords is like showing a modern war where everyone is using pistols instead of assault rifles.)

In comparison, other, "classic" dungeon crawlers like Nethack or Diablo make poor use of the fact that they happen in a 2D environment. There are some area of effect abilities, true, but nothing like the positional gameplay you get in the three games above. Positional gameplay is so fundamental to each of them that if you were to reduce them to a linear 1D environment, the gameplay would fold in on itself. They can get away with otherwise pretty simple rules because the 2D environment makes for so many different interesting game situations.

On the other hand, it's perfectly possible to make a one-dimensional dungeon crawler. Look at Darkest Dungeon, by all accounts a deep and engrossing game, whose combat situations are in a 1D environment. But to compensate, it has to have much more complex mechanics otherwise.

I don't think that positioning-based mechanics are easier to develop. They have more complex interactions. But they are easier to understand for the player, and players will have an easier time spotting interesting game moves thanks to all that brain circuitry devoted to visual processing.

In conclusion, I think that positioning-based gameplay in dungeon crawlers still has a lot of unexplored design space, be it through movement and attack patterns, or in other ways yet to be discovered.

Dungeon Granularity

Dungeon Granularity

Zarkonnen Blog
Granularity

Granularity

Zarkonnen Blog
Start a group Groups
Indie Gamers

Indie Gamers

1,523 members Hobbies & Interests

For fans of indie games and hardcore indie gamers, no matter at all whether these indies are commercial or freeware/opensource! This is a hub used for...

Turn-based strategy fans

Turn-based strategy fans

331 members Fans & Clans

For all fans of turn-based strategy genre, those that are entirely different from regular wargames or grand strategies, like tactical squad TB based games...

Swiss Game Developers

Swiss Game Developers

13 members Geographic

This group shall connect all game developers, designers, artists, etc. who live and work in Switzerland.

Post a comment
Sign in or join with:

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) and join in the conversation.

Level
Avatar
Avatar
Last Online
Country
Switzerland Switzerland
Gender
Male
Friends
Become friends
Member watch
Follow
Statistics
Rank
2,544 of 629,046
Visitors
5,604 (1 today)
Time Online
19 hours
Activity Points
1,013
Watchers
3 members
Comments
76
Site visits
5,158
Contact
Contact
Send Message
Homepage
Zarkonnen.com
Twitter

Latest tweets from @zarkonnen_com

Well, just switched to @fiber7_ch for Internet. Let's see how that goes. :)

43mins ago

The City and the City: If you wake up, after a night's drinking, in the gutters in a cross-hatched area near Copula Hall, what do you do?

2hours ago

That pyramidal TV is the most wonderful vintage SF thing ever. T.co

5hours ago

RT @bigpotplant: And here is another @tiltbrush creation by Tobias Wustefeild. Honestly the #VR recently has been mind blowing. T.co

5hours ago

RT @brian_bilston: A Brief History of Modern Art in Poetry. T.co

6hours ago

Doing some #boardgame prototyping. Early stages yet, think Betrayal at House on the Hill in space? #gamedev T.co

18hours ago

RT @EpicGameJam: TIME HAS COME! We reveal our insane plans to create the most epic #gamejam ! Check it out Epicgamejam.comT.co

Jun 28 2017

Summer sale haul. T.co

Jun 27 2017

Friends
Adolio
Adolio Online
DIFTOW
DIFTOW Online