Comments - SneakAttack

"Finally, I remember you saying in a reply to anther review that you were teasing your sequel, but it really added nothing to the story, even though I thought it would (and it would give the story a change from Bioshock)." To clear that up, I was talking about the water monsters.

Part 3

Despite all of my criticism, I didn't hate the game, and it is obvious that you put a lot of effort into it, but it just felt like it could have been a lot better if it wasn't so "inspired" by Bioshock, and if the gameplay was improved. Hopefully all of those problems will be fixed in the sequel, since the universe of this game seems pretty interesting and quite original. Yeah but still, it is an interesting mod, and is nowhere near the worst out there. It's worth a download, but (in my opinion) not worth a second playthrough.

Part 2
Now for the story. Personally I liked it, but like I said, pretty much all the main parts are taken from Bioshock. Also the characters are not nearly as interesting, and I knew that [SPOILER] Wilson was evil [END SPOILER] when I listened to the audio recordings in his room. Also, why are you not able to [More SPOILERS] stop obeying his orders, even after Woodrow Bell tells you his intentions. In fact, the whole scene there was pretty lame. I liked the reveal, but they never explained why you were held to the spot, or why you couldn't kill Woodrow Bell (I mean, that guy killed his son in cold blood, and is partially the cause of this whole thing) and why you had to keep following Wilson, even though you knew he really doesn't have the best intents in mind.[Less SPOILERS] In addition, the audio quality was awful. I mean, the voices are so quite, I had to turn up my sound to hear it, but I still had to stand still, since any background noise would make the voices inaudible. The voice acting wasn't bad, but it wasn't very good. It was certainly better than quite a few mods out there, but it still isn't amazing. Finally, I remember you saying in a reply to anther review that you were teasing your sequel, but it really added nothing to the story, even though I thought it would (and it would give the story a change from Bioshock). One thing I liked was the music, it had an eerie feel and added to the atmosphere of the game. Speaking of atmosphere, it sort of died down as you went on through the game. For example, the crow level, where you see the creepy shadows and stuff, was one of the most atmospheric scenes in any mod, but you never see any of that again, and all your enemies for the rest of the game can be killed in a few seconds. So by the end of the game the atmosphere had become incredibly dull, and I didn't really get scared or creeped out at any point after the crow level.

Part 1 of my review

I have very mixed feelings about this mod. I can't really dislike it because the story is interesting and in some parts very clever, but I can't really like it because pretty much all the main parts of the story (including the twist and the whole "Crazy Artist") parts are taken from Bioshock, the graphics look like something from the year 2000, and the gameplay is incredibly lacklustre.

The thing is, the gameplay and graphics are generally bad. The textures are bland, the animations are jumpy and don't look very good, most of the models look blocky and aren't very well made, and there are only like 3 different physics objects in the whole game. As for the gameplay, the levels are all basically the same, and "exploring" is basically just going the wrong way, hitting a dead end, listening to the recording, and then going back. I saw no "survival gameplay" since I usually had a lot of ammo, and never really felt the need to conserve it. In fact, I don't think I ever had more than 1 weapon without ammo, and even when I did the ammo was usually restored within a few minutes. The enemy AI is not very good, but they did seem like they were being controlled by a hive mind of sorts. However, I never really found them to be much of a challenge since you can usually take down a group with 6 shotgun shots, and they don't get the chance to do too much damage (I was playing on normal). The crows on the other hand are interesting, but stop being scary after the first and start getting annoying after the second (I'm glad you didn't put too many of them in the game).