Which graphic's better? Thread

Which graphics better?

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

i think they both look pretty good, but if i hadto decide, id say the one on the right is more detailed

Ok, but to decide i need some more opinions, hmm?

i like the one on the right more

but with new grass, am i right?

Admittedly, it's easier for me to tell what the ones on the left are. It took me a minute to figure out what was going on on the right, especially that guy who appears to be some Crusader. The detail and shading on the right ones is a little nicer, though.

I found the one on the right to be easier to understand quickly, as they all have different poses and contrasting colours -makes them easy to tell apart from each other. The muted colours and identical poses on the left make it that little bit slower to work out who is who.

The one on the right looks the best. Much more detailed and there is more of a variety of characters.

The spell effects make the one on the right look better.

Edited by: dbest

Ok, second will stay

The right one is sightly better according grass and stuff like that.

One on the right, the perspective is way better, it looks much more 3D. The one on the left looks too flat.

the one on the left is easier to tell what it is, the right one is soo.. it is too detailed, i believe is the right word