This member has provided no bio about themself...
I'm going to state that what i'm about to say is not to be taken in offence it is mearly constructive critisism.
Texture: The textures are nice 9/10
Map: The maps are a bit rough around the edges and have way to many invisible walls 6/10
Audio: The sounds were all hl and unmodified which really lessened the experience 3/10
Difficulty and replay ability: the overall difficulty is really easy, except for when the map contruction was hindering you 4/10
Enemy creativity: the enemies where just redone hl2 enemies, but they looked nice 3/10
Camera/Cutscenes: the camera was buggy when it was forced to move for enemy appearences and I couldn't watch the end cause it spawned me back at the lighthouse 3/10
Lighting: there was no atmoshpheric lighting most of the time, 2/10
Story: it really needs some 2/10
Overall: 4.28/10
Could be a lot better with some more work.