Low-poly 3D Modeler, Texutre Artist and high/low-poly promotional artist. While I'm not increasing my risk of carpal tunnel and burning my retinas out, I enjoy survival type camping, dancing with and henceforth killing innocent woodland creatures, as well as taking long walks on the beach.

Report article RSS Feed WIP....a complete cop-out

Posted by Lazy6pyro on Mar 5th, 2009

I am seriously tired of mods saying that something is a WIP to completely dodge critique. It makes no sense...why would you even post it then? I wouldn't post a render of a cube and say it's a WIP of a ferrari, and then chide everyone that comments saying "It's just a WIP".

Maybe I'm in the minority here, but I feel that every single image you post up is basically promotional art; why would anyone post up promotional art that sucks....unless they want people to critique it. Accept or debate the criticism; thats all that you gotta do

Post comment Comments
open_sketchbook Mar 5 2009, 4:32pm says:

In the case of the image of ours you commented on earlier, it actually was WIP. We decided to post it as it was, just wanting to get it out there with the other EP image before going back to working on the Confederates and Allies. Eventually it'll look more finished, like the hunter-killer we posted alongside it, but we decided it was better to show off the WIP rather than wait. We weren't trying to dodge criticism; we actually weren't done yet!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Lazy6pyro Author
Lazy6pyro Mar 5 2009, 7:58pm replied:

That wasn't completely aimed at you at all. Just in my experience, I've seen quite a few mods that use this excuse to dodge criticism and then never actually change it.

WIPs do have their place, and that place is to get critique. I actually enjoy debating what can be done. So instead of just saying "Its a WIP" it will be much more beneficial to you if you discuss

My point of view, if the texture isn't in a showable/completed state, I don't show it; sure, it is still open to be changed, but I consider it to be "completed". Instead, I do a clay render. This is because bad textures can make models look worse, which isn't necessarily the case for your model, although it does sort of take away from your normals map and makes it blend in a bit.

Mods at ModDB hinge on how their media and images look; they become promotional artwork regardless of it is intended or not. This is why I always say "Make your worst look like your best" because you should always be trying to drive in fans, supporters, critics, and maybe some more help even if it's just a logo.

+1 vote   reply to comment
Madin Jul 29 2009, 4:45pm replied:

Your very skilled at critique. Most of the criticisms on Moddb are useless. "ummm...there is something i don't like about this...sorry!" and such nonsense.
I'll be sending you pictures of works in progress for your useful insight soon!

+1 vote     reply to comment
TotalSnappy Apr 11 2010, 4:44pm says:

Moddb needs critics, you are a minority unforunately but keep at our necks, it's the only way modders can improve!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Post a Comment
click to sign in

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) which we encourage all contributors to do.

2000 characters limit; HTML formatting and smileys are not supported - text only

Offline Since
Dec 1, 2013
United States United States
Member Watch
Track this member
Report Abuse
Report article