This group is for people who notice canononical contradictions within popular sci-fi and fantasy franchises and wish to discuss them in a safe, TROLL FREE, environment.

  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
Media RSS Feed Report media Updated Pros & Cons List (view original)
Updated Pros & Cons List
view previous next
Share Image
Share on Facebook Tweet Email a friend
Embed Image
Post comment Comments
Niner Skirata
Niner Skirata Jun 2 2013, 7:00am says:

Cad bane is not really a cool new character, I think so. Cydon Prax would have been better

I found the clone too humanized, a regular clone trooper can evolve and find himself different from an other, but he's far to be a deserter and develop a totally different personnality and be tatooed (Even if this was used to differenciate the clone from an other fellow).
An arc or a commando can be

In cons you should have added: "Ridiculous blocus and space battle"
-> 3 poor ships called a blocus, wow..
-> Also the space battle with their 2 venators vs 3 CIS ships

For the other Pros and Cons i agree

+1 vote     reply to comment
Lord_starkiller Jun 2 2013, 10:51am replied:

So just because some Clones were trained in higher levels means they can think higher?

+1 vote     reply to comment
Niner Skirata
Niner Skirata Jun 2 2013, 11:28am replied:

Yeap, their genetic constitution was made like this

+1 vote     reply to comment
Commissar_Delta Author
Commissar_Delta Jun 2 2013, 7:51pm replied:

ARCs, Commandos, and Bread Clone Commanders had the ability to think for themselves and question orders when they seemed unclear or endangered large numbers of troops/civilians. other than that, your generic private, sergeant and captain clone troopers did not have this ability. its when the generic bottom of the barrel, infantry grunts started to question orders is when they started contradicting Episode II Attack of the Clones.

as for the clones having personalities thats entirely plausable and i actually like how they did that. but your generic infantry grunt, boots on the ground, front line infantry clones were bread specifically so they took "any order without question"

therefore your generic clone is unable to intentionally dessert the GAR (MIA is completely different, if they go missing and are unable to regroup thats fine but if they were to be found or found their way back on their own, their genetics would kick in and they'd immediately regroup with their section), theyre unable to question orders (again only ARCS, Commandos, and Commanders posses that ability), and most certainly they're unable to commit treasonous acts.

+2 votes   reply to comment
Post a Comment
click to sign in

You are not logged in, your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) which we encourage all contributors to do.

2000 characters limit; HTML formatting and smileys are not supported - text only


I took the liberty of editing & Updating Ozzy's Pors & Cons list for TCW

Image Details
Jun 1st, 2013
Embed Thumb
Report Abuse
Report media
Add Media
Members only