This group is for people who notice canononical contradictions within popular sci-fi and fantasy franchises and wish to discuss them in a safe, TROLL FREE, environment.

Forum Thread
by member
B2(s) vs. Phase II clone(s) (Groups : Alliance to Restore Canon (ARC) : Forum : Clone trooper vs Droids : B2(s) vs. Phase II clone(s)) Locked
Thread Options
Jan 25 2011, 10:16pm Anchor

title says all, Im for the B2, merciless, has a tri-blaster and dual autoblaster, hand to hand it can pwn any soldier save a jedi, and can be equipped with a rocket launcher.

Jan 25 2011, 10:29pm Anchor

Clone Jet Trooper with an EMP Launcher.


(cite note: Lines 14 - 15 )

Jan 25 2011, 10:31pm Anchor

Rocket launcher blows clone up, lets stick with standard clones and standard B2's :P

Jan 26 2011, 12:05pm Anchor

Standard Clone throws EMP grenade?

Jan 26 2011, 5:02pm Anchor

standard trooper with thermal detanators

Jan 26 2011, 9:57pm Anchor

B2 with autocannon kills them before in range. please specify why they would win and in what situation. It defeats the purpose

Edited by: Akalonor

Jan 27 2011, 4:06pm Anchor

They carry their dead brethern as sheilds or crawling on the ground while holding two thermal dets dead man switches. They blow up the droid and throw shrapnel everywhere. and also there would at least be two troopers with rocket launchers, they would never send in clones that unprepared.

Jan 27 2011, 6:52pm Anchor

Explain why an outpost would only be defended by 5 men with no rockets then.

Jan 27 2011, 7:02pm Anchor

Because it is a listening outpost not a garrison, and in case you forgot there was an armory, they just were unprepared for a sneak attack. So of course they would have no chance to properly arm themselves, for a B2 attack. Anyways a bulk of the army was composed of easier to kill B-1s

Jan 27 2011, 7:52pm Anchor

What happened to the fact that clones are omnipotent super soldiers than ?

There are too many Republic fanboys here, this thread is useless so please close.

Jan 27 2011, 8:06pm Anchor

OK also they were rookies

Jan 27 2011, 9:38pm Anchor

But that goes against them having trained 10 years, making that point false. You can't help but find so many contradictions in Star Wars clones.

Jan 28 2011, 6:02am Anchor

I agree, but I never said they were infallable, personally my favorite are the good mandalorians who fight with the republic, they should bring some of those in

Jan 29 2011, 4:43am Anchor

Lol Akalonor. You're just backing down to an argument that you yourself started. That's pretty lame. And no they're isn't too many Republic fanboys. There's just as many if not more CIS fanboys. The CIS group has nearly 20 more members than it's Republic counterpart.

Also there's too many contradictions in Star Wars. This group is a testament of that.

Jan 29 2011, 10:08am Anchor

Discussion, not argument, the GR group his newer and hasn't been found as much, you all are refusing to keep a basis about the 1v1 pros and cons and instead pull out some other gun used by some other kind of trooper. I agree that there are too many contradictions, I am backing down but because this was a bad idea where everyone would vote for the Republic because the only people that are on this forum are republic fanboys.

Nick has an LAAT as his avatar, you have a 501st, Delta, I can't tell what Sebaanators is ^.^ the point is most people in this group is and I don't wish to have a discussion with people that are biased enough to say the same things over again.

Jan 29 2011, 10:32am Anchor

It is from the scifi at war bg pack, its a fleet of venerators attacking a borg cube

Jan 29 2011, 11:37am Anchor

Oh so you aren't biased either? I bet if there was more CIS fanboys in this forum then you wouldn't be backing down. Numbers don't have anything to do with a discussion. You can't attempt to end a discussion just because the majority do not agree with your opinions.

Jan 29 2011, 2:17pm Anchor

Really I cant? Im not that biased, I recognize that the republic was infact superior to the CIS since it was a humanoid force and not AI, aswell as having equipment to counter the CIS. Also you just said numbers weren't important but went off of numbers 4 posts up.

To turn the thread to a more fruitful direction and more on topic, why not compare the original clones and B2's to the CW ones. It was very ignorant of me to start this in the first place, my failure is noted.

Jan 29 2011, 8:03pm Anchor

TCW clones do not look canon and neither do the B2's. The only good thing about the B2's in TCW is that their voices are deep, and not squeaky and childish like the B1's. The clones in TCW kinda' look like pansies to me.

Reply to Thread
click to sign in and post

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) and join in the conversation.