Make Mordor Great Again group

I see two valid problems so far that you've brought up:
1) The lack of AoE tier 4 spells
2) The usefulness of Gorthaur transformation
3)Mollok
The rest is nonsensical rambling which you will have to refine if you wish for me to debate those points too. But enough standing around, let's get talking.

1) I don't know if you've noticed but Edain has moved away from AoE spellbooks in general. The Arrow Volley being the last remnant of that. The reasoning behind that is that they no longer wanted battles to turn by simply using a single spell on the enemy army. They wish for players to use their powers in addition to their armies in order to trick the enemy. For example, summoning army of the dead is not always enough, the enemy can run away from it. However using Denethor's Farsight and summoning it behind the enemy while they are locked in combat is a real strategy. This the base of the reasoning behind the spellbook overhaul. Being able to use insta kill spells is terrible for game balance since it means that the enemy army can easily be killed and the tide of battle turn too quickly since you could then lead your rebuilt army into the undefended enemy fortress. In comparison, the Tier 4 powers (apart from Avalanche in my opinion) can be used to even deadlier effect as long as they are properly supported by other troops:
*Grond can level a base given that troops aid him to either soak up the damage or push the enemy forces back. And if the enemy focuses Gond then the army can push through and invest the base.
*Gorthaur: Gorthaur is one of the tankiest non-ring heroes out there, even rivaling the powers of Ring Heroes. His ability set is deadly and he can call up terrible allies using his Tol In Gaurhoth. Supported with a proper force he can level an enemy army and build up enough momentum to push your foe back into their base. His abilities also allow him to flee from combat if needed, buff the beasts he summons from his fortress and disable the enemy fortress (Annatar is OP).

2) Gorthaur's transformations. They may seem weak but all of them are good enough to be a hero on their own especially Annatar. His werewolf form can tear open enemy units and even minor heroes with deadly efficacy and can flee the battlefield quickly if needed. His bat for is extremely strong since it does not have the usual flying unit weakness to arrows sucking the strengh of enemy troops slowly.

3) I can agree with Mollok, he's useless that is for sure. I've been trying to get the ET to rework him since I started playing the mod. But just because they don't do it doesn't mean we have to resort to taking our anger out on others. You must push trough with thorough arguments and viable solutions. Not lash out, demanding that the ET make it better.

Things not considered as arguments:
- "Mordor is its not one of the strongest lg faction"
- "has forced gamestyle" Mordor has the most amount of units, that's ridiculous. You can play Mordor in so many ways.
- "Gorthaur is looking like a travestity"

All I see on the Edain page is a couple users causing trouble because their wishes are not executed. I have seen nothing that could be considered a proper debate where good arguments and interesting solutions are brought forward. The best way for change to happen is to make it easy on those that need to create that change, if we come up with solid concepts ET is more likely to implement them.

I will have a further look at the other arguments you have once you've properly presented them, taking facts from the game and not from your personal opinion. Gimme me stuff I can see for myself: unit stats,ability descriptions, ect...

If you believe that Edain doesn't care about community ideas, not about Mordor, then this defeats the whole point of this group in the first place.