Report What you think of Desura?

Poll started by lodle with 3,114 votes and 51 comments. Browse the poll archive.

 9%

(277 votes)Game Changing

 21%

(666 votes)Interesting

 4%

(126 votes)Ok

 4%

(110 votes)Meh

 6%

(181 votes)Gah, not another one

 56%

(1754 votes)Desura?

Post comment Comments  (0 - 50 of 51)
lodle Creator
lodle - - 204 comments

Again for those who dont know what im talking about: Moddb.com

Reply Good karma+4 votes
MrTambourineMan
MrTambourineMan - - 717 comments

You're in for some tough competition, I wish you all the best!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+5 votes
Wiweeyum
Wiweeyum - - 347 comments

In tough competition for sure, but the focus is so completely different that the niche is what will make it fly. I have no doubts with this one... 'Game Changing' for sure.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Ark_
Ark_ - - 583 comments

It is certainly interesting and I hope it will succeed and do well.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+4 votes
Dr.Worm
Dr.Worm - - 181 comments

i love the concept of it and it is a game changer but im still curious as of how the games/ mods will work would we need to buy or have the game like in steam to play the mod?? or will this be fully for mods and able to play or buy the mods with out having that certain game?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
lodle Creator
lodle - - 204 comments

If you have the game installed it will find it and then allow you to download and install any mods for that game.

Reply Good karma+2 votes
SIGILL
SIGILL - - 1,157 comments

I voted game changing but maybe my opinion will be different after using it.. it looks and sounds promising though!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Gosthy
Gosthy - - 736 comments

Game changing. It sounds really exciting. I would vote "Desura?" first, but I have a habit of checking out what is the poll about, to make a vote that has a point.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+4 votes
Dremth
Dremth - - 1,400 comments

Interesting looking interface. I just hope it isn't clunky as **** like all the other ones.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Nebcake
Nebcake - - 443 comments

Its cool, it will make searching for stuff alot easier.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
Karriz
Karriz - - 226 comments

I voted Desura? andthen I checked what it is. Some kind of community, looks pretty good.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
NGS616
NGS616 - - 364 comments

Sounds great

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
coolkid87
coolkid87 - - 177 comments

there is something i believe that is similar called crosus but imo it doesn't work very well( tried it several times but not lately)

Isotx.com

I intrigued but we will see. Good luck and lets see what you guys do.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Death8338
Death8338 - - 126 comments

google anyone?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
RandomusIdiotus
RandomusIdiotus - - 957 comments

I can hardly wait to try it! But, alas, I must. V_V

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Mularac
Mularac - - 2,910 comments

An elite site for mods... sign me up! what'll be the requisites for a mod to be allowed in such a place?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
BrokenTripod
BrokenTripod - - 146 comments

Posting here just in case no one reads this on the other:

"If you can find some way to make it so that players can see who is playing one of these mods or how many people have it installed and generate some type of system for organizing games on the older mods, I can see a future for this, otherwise I'm fine with sticking with Moddb."

Otherwise it just seems like another attempt to make something that links people to games that is extraneous and simply eating up HD space and memory that we could be using to get slightly better fps.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
LORDDEREX
LORDDEREX - - 1,159 comments

Didnt hear about Desura until today.
Dont have any opinion yet about it.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
MechanicalPaladin
MechanicalPaladin - - 585 comments

I'll stick with steam.. sorry :/

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Wiweeyum
Wiweeyum - - 347 comments

I'm sorry for you.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
klemen1702
klemen1702 - - 131 comments

just another platform to make some money
rip off of steam
i support u guys on moddb but ill stick with VALVE any time
they do so much free content for us its crazy not to

Reply Good karma Bad karma-4 votes
CrazyIvan1745
CrazyIvan1745 - - 159 comments

I can see why you would go with steam. As far as buying things online I think Steam has the ultimate system. But Steam doesn't have a good database for FREE mods and games. This project could be just another steam but it could also be just what is needed.

If you search for Battlefield 2 Mods on Steam you will find MAYBE 2 mods. If I understand this site like I think I do it will make finding mods 100 times easier than it is now. Battlefield has never been that easy to find mods for, yet there is plenty out there. Filefront did ok for awhile but then their site kept corrupting 50% of the uploads.

I think Desura could be a really awesome program if they do it right. but based off what they have announced it looks to be on a whole different level from Steam.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
cortez666
cortez666 - - 158 comments

i hope it will be indie games and mods only, otherwise it would be just a steam rip off and if its indie only it would support the developers because most of them cant get thier games on steam

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
Kamikazi[Uk]
Kamikazi[Uk] - - 1,412 comments

Yah the compotiion is strong atm but i think if you make this so anyone can upload there mods/games to it and sell games but you recieve some royalties i think this would be really popular.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
cW#Ravenblood - - 6,703 comments

Desura FTW

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Lopper
Lopper - - 1,559 comments

Desura? What is that?,what does it mean?

Reply Good karma Bad karma0 votes
Joe_Shmoe
Joe_Shmoe - - 304 comments

Well I wouldnt say its game changing, but it sure is great if its aimed at the indie and modding community primarily... So what if its like steam?
Linux is like windows, Linux just open and free, and windows ripps you off... soo, while steam ripps us off, let desura be open and free =] sure it may not reach the popularity steam has, but there will be the faithfull few that will support it all the way =]

I for one prefer mods and indie games over AAA games, too few AAA games worth my play time, and then indie games and mods are always fascinating, so im leaning towards it, Id like to see this become something worthwhile...

All the best to you guys!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+4 votes
eXeC64
eXeC64 - - 225 comments

I will go for Desura on linux as an alternative to steam. But on windows steam will remain my primary way of getting games.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
PiNwOrM45
PiNwOrM45 - - 66 comments

I like the GUI, and I love the mod support, but I'm sick of the different Digital Distribution programs and accounts. One thing I loved about the idea is that I would be able to just log into one account, and have a nice way to launch games. But now that there's so many, it's an even bigger hassle as I have to log into the right thing, etc. So right now I'm only using steam and don't bother with non-steam games (unless it's something really big). So my vote goes to "not interested". But best of luck with it.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
OrdinaryMagician
OrdinaryMagician - - 136 comments

I hope it's better than the extremely sucky Steam.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
mastersrp
mastersrp - - 132 comments

I'm not sure it's gonna be exactly "game changing", but def. interesting!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
destroy3r3
destroy3r3 - - 46 comments

It's been a long time since I last visited the site, so I guess I am a bit out-of-date...

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
chaosmaster4
chaosmaster4 - - 2,256 comments

i voted before i got to see desura -.- should have picked game changing =(

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
BluishGreenPro
BluishGreenPro - - 534 comments

This could mean a lot for developing developers who want to market their games...
aka me...

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
RedTiki
RedTiki - - 221 comments

"gah, not another one" as in: not another poll i have no opinion on.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Chrissstrahl
Chrissstrahl - - 411 comments

Interesting, it does focus on things which steam doesn't and if it doesn't do things which are quite annoying at steam it will be successful.

I think we all know that we can trust in moddb to put a lot effort into Desura, making it one of the top platforms. Flexibility, compatibility and the support of the communities can bring Desura to great success.

Perhaps Desura comes with a sleep function. You can start the sleep function manually or when you start a game over the Desura interface it will minimize to a try icon and disable the rendering of websites/flash animations plus everything else that isn't needed, things as checking for updates, downloading news/files. Manually disabling the sleep function must also be a option.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
putrid_being
putrid_being - - 22 comments

I picked interesting because I have yet to try the program out so I can't really say it's game changing. The summary of it sounds good though.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Kys
Kys - - 346 comments

It is look very interesting.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
ultimate
ultimate - - 137 comments

For anyone that thinks Desura isn't a great idea, read this please.

I think some people are missing the point of Desura. It's not there to replace steam, with it you will have automatic downloading of patches for both mods that valve haven't yet decided are worthy of Steamworks, and for mods that don't use the source engine.

For too many people (myself included) patching all their multiplayer mods is a very tedious process in the long run, automatic patching will just make a lot of mods more popular.

Also, I'm pretty sure I read a comment somewhere that said Desura doesn't have to be running while the game is running. This would mean that you could start Desura, which will then download and install the patches automatically, and then you are free to quit the program, run the game from the desktop or from Steam if you want the in-game overlay. You choose.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
CrazyIvan1745
CrazyIvan1745 - - 159 comments

You have a very valid point. For anyone that tried ModJive it was basically a mod downloader and updater, but it wasn't run well enough. ModJive was setup so you didn't have to leave it running but it notified you for updates.

Where I think Desura will be better than ModJive as far as updating is I see they made a Beta Testing section. My teams mods the beta testing was always the worst because you had to patch A LOT. You're constantly finding issues or something to fix and you would like to make an update but updating every single day get's annoying for your testers. Our current solution is to do most of our testing within our development team then just release a new beta every month or so. Something like Desura that Auto Patches for you could Really help us make quick simple fixes in maybe one or 2 things we missed so then we can get to the game play testing and find things that need to be changed or added on a large scale instead of people repeatedly finding and reporting all the small simple issues that you have already fixed but are waiting to patch with a major change.

Desura is something I look forward to. Whether it fails or succeeds I think it will still have a usefulness for me personally. I really hope this thing is as good as it sounds.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Reactorcore
Reactorcore - - 644 comments

I think its pretty great, there are plenty of mods that require some tweaking and kicking to get it to work on your game, but desura completely skips that **** and installs the mod, patches (hopefully) and any other addons in a single operation so you just need to select the mod you want and bam, desura delivers and all you need to do is play it after its done installing.

Not to mention its going to be a collection of ready and released mods, aka the gems, the top of the crop that you usually search moddb with filters and such. And as they have a crew evaluating the works uploaded there, they will make sure you wont download any crap on the way or stuff that doesnt work.

And on top of that its an awesome chance for modders to get their work there since its all about high quality and it will be very visible and presentable in desura, just like in moddb, but with extra coolness and higher value.

All hail desura! : D

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Rigelblast
Rigelblast - - 220 comments

Desura looks interesting in my opinion.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
ImYourSanity
ImYourSanity - - 3 comments

Well i have to say you guys should be proud of 2 things
1. Creating somin that might Give Steam a run for its money

and 2. Being able to keep a secret project SO secret that 50% of the community doesnt know what the hell ur talking about

lol

props guys ♠

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
hardriver
hardriver - - 181 comments

there missing 1%?

WOULD THAT 1% HURRY UP AND VOTE!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Sparky245
Sparky245 - - 172 comments

Trying to compete with Steam? Uh oh. Didn't Windows Live, try that?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
fameless.face
fameless.face - - 412 comments

this is gonna be ****(in a bad way),im sure of it
50% dont know about it eaven after the big reveal
and another 6% say "gah not another one"

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
sasuke2490
sasuke2490 - - 347 comments

Never heard of it.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
GigaCake
GigaCake - - 35 comments

Okay, so Desura will just redistribute the mods?
What's the point?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
DNAz
DNAz - - 29 comments

@hardriver

not right now...its 100%

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Aaagreen
Aaagreen - - 225 comments

It just seems like Steam but for mods - even though Steam already has the ability to add your free mods if you talk nicely to Valve.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Post a comment

Your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account: