Post news Report RSS The L4D Boycott Is A Showing Of Disrespect

We are a community of game and mod developers, and we've all shared the experience, yet, some of us still haven't learned anything from such an experience, or have yet to experience it, and so they blindly disrespect and punish the people who have felt it too many times, but still persevere for their fans, with Boycotts and denying any profit for their labor.

Posted by on

We've all had that moment in our lives. Well, if you've got a mod or a game here, you've definatly had this moment in your life. You know that moment, when you've finally released, anounced, or showed some progress of your game or mod, but you look at your comments, and guess what you see? This person who thinks he's something, saying how much your mod/game is bad, and how it doesn't deserve a page, or whatever.

We've all had that feeling, we've all felt the emotions, maybe it's anger, annoyance, or you don't care (unlikely.) Either way, it's left something on you, this person doesn't apreciate what you've done.

Now, imagine that feeling, multiplied by ten, and that's how Valve developers are feeling as the L4D2 Boycott carries on. There are close to no devlopers in this universe that are as dedicated to their fans as the ones at Valve, they've given so much to their community, and have asked for so little in return. They gave five full games for a price of $50 in the Orange Box, they allow a ton of publishing opprutunities for MODS, not even games, MODS that profitise off of their engines that they've worked so hard on, and they don't ask for that much of a cut in the profit in return. They are the most supportive of the Modding community, too, they have created their own Mod developement wiki, several programs and tutorials, and a ton of updates, and full access to their Source engine, in all its glory, they've given you everything they have, for free. If you want proof of how many mods use their engines and programs, look at the front Page of Mod DB and count how many Half Life 2 or Source based mods you see, I'm sure that you see quite a bit, not even a bit, a LOT.
Valve's also proved it's dedication to the gamers, the ones who've never touched a modding program, through countless game updates. Game's that are as old as Half Life, yeah, not Half Life 2, but HALF LIFE, still get updates, and that prooves something. You may say "But Blizzard's patched Star Craft about 1,000 times," but people are still buying Star Craft, and Blizzard's still profiting off of Star Craft tournaments.

Nobody still buys Half Life.
There are no such things anymore as Half Life tournaments.
And Half Life 2 was released 5 years ago.

Valve's money all comes from pure game sales, they do NOT make money off of anything else (aside for, if you want to sell your mod, but that's not that much profit anyways,) those constant Team Fortress 2 upgrades come to you for FREE, you are never charged, never have you been playing a game and you've gotten this message "A new weapon has been released for Team Fortress 2, do you want to pay up for it?" It HASN'T happened, and it WON'T HAPPEN.

But it has happened, that while playing, lets say, Battlefeild 2, you HAVE gotten a notice saying "A new weapon pack's been released for BF2, do you want to fork over some cash to get them?" This seperates Valve from a lot of developers, their production costs DO NOT match their income. Their weapons designers do NOT work for free, you know, but yet, they give you their work for free.

Production costs - no income = loss in money

I don't think a SINGLE one of you would be willing to do the same thing, unless you haven't finished a mod before. Those who have, have told stories of it being a personal hell, I've made a few games for Flash, and it IS a personal hell. People don't just snap their fingers and a game just becomes. And I'm SURE that if it wasn't for most mods on this site being, well, mods, they would charge for it. And even look at all the games on this site, about 5 of them are free, and those are the small ones, all the big ones will cost you.

Now, why would Valve be so different? Because Valve is something different, Valve likes to see the happiness of their fans more then their pay checks. Of course, they like their pay checks more, but they've proven multiple times that they will gladly reduce it. Just THINK about how much cash Valve would be rolling in if they DID charge you for those new weapons in TF2? If they put it all into an expansion pack, and gave you a $40 price tag? Yes, I need to bring this point up, the amount of content delivered to most Valve games is the equivelent of an expansion pack. It IS worthy of a $40 price tag, but there isn't one. There's a $0 price tag.

So, you'd think such a company would be economic troubles, well, the truth is, they ARE. Well, they aren't really on the verge of collapsing, but they need more money so that they don't end up like Free Radical, or Westwood, or some other company that doesn't exist anymore since it couldn't meet it's target profit.

So, you know what they decided to do? They decided to, for once, ask for money for their work. And you know what that's called? Left For Dead 2, it's funny, Left For Dead 2 is called Left For Dead 2 for a reason, it's WAY bigger then any update. It's HUGE, I mean, yeah, it's a whole new game for a reason.

But for some reason, the first thing most users saw when they came on this site one day was news of A BOYCOTT. Talk about disrespect? Valve? Honestly? The most generous group of developers ever? A BOYCOTT?

Suddenly, up was down, left was right, it didn't make sense. Valve's been shoveling so much free food into these pigs that they get annoyed when they are denied the right to free load. It's like complaining to your friend that he used to allow you to come into his house naked every day, but now that his Mom's moved in, he's not allowing you to. Now, that doesn't make sense, does it? But it's true, it's what's going on right here, as we speak. Valve, the friend who allows you to do anything in his house (well if he's allowing you to walk in stripped then he'll allow you to probably do anything) is getting yelled at because his Mother (financial troubles) moved in, and he doesn't want to look bad (close down for good) in front of his mother, or else she'll pull a pistol out of her purse and shoot him dead for good.

Valve can close down for good if this goes on, Valve NEEDS to survive, they DESERVE to survive, they are the perfect example of a group of developers who just simply LOVE their fans, and will do ANYTHING for their loyalty.

It would be a real shame if their down fall came from their own fans not appreciating their generosity.

A real shame.

If you agree, join the Anti Fan Idiocy group, we need to SHOW something to this world, we need to be living proof that we appreciate those who need to be appreciated!

Come on, guys, if they succeed, we'll loose Valve forever, lets not have the saying "You don't know what you've got until it's gone" apply to us!

Post comment Comments
CoachShogun20
CoachShogun20 - - 322 comments

Good article Conker. It makes perfect sense, and I loved the "naked" comparison.

Reply Good karma Bad karma-1 votes
Stubby
Stubby - - 207 comments

when you promise something, people expect it.

so seriously, get out of here.

Reply Good karma Bad karma-4 votes
Stubby
Stubby - - 207 comments

(buried)

"So, you know what they decided to do? They decided to, for once, ask for money for their work. And you know what that's called? Left For Dead 2, it's funny, Left For Dead 2 is called Left For Dead 2 for a reason, it's WAY bigger then any update. It's HUGE, I mean, yeah, it's a whole new game for a reason."

they replaced a few model and some texures and maps.

i could have done this all myself. NOT worth a update.

Reply Good karma Bad karma-8 votes
CoachShogun20
CoachShogun20 - - 322 comments

Have you seen the whole game? I think not. Have you played any of the game? I think not. Your theory has more holes then a slice of swiss cheese.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+7 votes
Gibberstein
Gibberstein - - 52 comments

Thing is, I see the friend analogy more like this:

Your best friend has stuck with you and supported you through thick and thin - he really is everything a friend should be. Then one day, instead of greeting you with a cheery 'hi buddy', he greets you by kicking you square in the balls.

At this point, do you continue as you were for the sake of old times, or has something changed, and your opinion is going to change with it? L4D2 is that kick in the balls - Valve just aren't acting like the Valve we thought we knew.

Reply Good karma Bad karma-4 votes
EvilConker Author
EvilConker - - 317 comments

Yes they are, but they're just asking for compensation, and instead of mugging you, they're giving you a new game for it.

They're giving you something for giving them compensation.
Nobody does that in the real world, and Valve is very generous to do so.

And stubby, replacing a few models?
New weapons.
New maps.
New enemies.
New campaigns.

THAT IS NOT SOMETHING YOU COULD'VE DONE BY YOURSELF.
It's taking THEM so long to do it.

And Gibberston, your analogy is incorrect:

Your best friend has stuck with you and supported you through thick and thin - he really is everything a friend should be. Then one day, instead of greeting you with a cheery 'hi buddy', he greets you with a kinda cheery "hey man"
You then proceed to yell at him for not calling you "buddy" and then you kick HIM square in the balls.

Reply Good karma+4 votes
mikejkelley
mikejkelley - - 874 comments

I think boycotts are great. It's nice to see that some ppl aren't apathetic sheep. I couldn't care less about L4D2, but I boycott Valve for a variety of reasons; chief amongst them the fact that they make their money illicitly through vicarious copyright infringement.

Reply Good karma Bad karma-4 votes
EvilConker Author
EvilConker - - 317 comments

What do you mean? Are you confusing companies? Valve only makes original IP's, and off of Mods that people wish to sell, Valve gets a cut of the profit from there too, Valve DOES NOT DESERVE THIS.

Reply Good karma+6 votes
zerocreatorz
zerocreatorz - - 632 comments

Theres only one reason I hate valve and thats for selling Garrys mod, I mean up till 9 it was free then 10 and 11 were both sales items I mean come on its a mod, a mod that ive seen done in the classic goldsource (gomod) and they expect us to pay for it that was the first piece of software I illegaly stole from a friends hard-drive. XD

Reply Good karma Bad karma-3 votes
rockythedude
rockythedude - - 2 comments

The creator of GMOD made it cost money not Valve

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Wraiyth
Wraiyth - - 483 comments

It hasn't taken them so long to do it, its probably taken 12-18 months, given that it started development straight after the L4D release

Your article is simply flawed in so many ways its not funny. A few points...

They gave five full games for a price of $50 in the Orange Box

Valve were able to do this purely because of Steam and probably made more money as a result. Going through a traditional publisher selling on the shelf at full price, Valve might have seen 25% IF THEY WERE VERY VERY LUCKY. Because of Steam, Valve saw the full profits of the game, meaning they made more money but were still able to sell everything cheapy to the consumer.

MODS that profitise off of their engines that they've worked so hard on, and they don't ask for that much of a cut in the profit in return

Err, where did you get this idea?

created their own Mod developement wiki

Which is maintained by community members... Epic have a Wiki as well for Unreal, and I'm sure theres a CryEngine one there somewhere. This is not unique to Valve.

Nobody still buys Half Life.

I disagree 100% on that. There was a sale for Half Life on last year to celebrate its 10th anniversary, selling at 99 cents. I bet people got it then.

Valve's money all comes from pure game sales, they do NOT make money off of anything else

Wrong again. Steam sales.

those constant Team Fortress 2 upgrades come to you for FREE, you are never charged

But what you miss is the fact that with each content release, TF2 is VERY heavily promoted and put on sale all over Steam, very highly publicised, and probably sells more copies because people know its going to be supported freely. If you look at the sales of expansions vs the additional sales Valve wouldn't have gotten without these updates, you'll probably see Valve ahead.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Wraiyth
Wraiyth - - 483 comments

So, you'd think such a company would be economic troubles, well, the truth is, they ARE

Along with every other company in the Western world...

Talk about disrespect?

Ignoring the fact that Valve came out before the release of L4D2 and said that it would be supported the same as TF2 with free content...

Basically, people are ****** off because they bought the game under the impression that there would be updates like TF2 (and you talked about the content in those updates anyway), and Valve havent delivered. Instead of announcing what they will deliver in TF2, they announced a new product.
Say you bought a car and the manufacturer said that later on, they would upgrade your car with a new stereo, new leather interior, mags... all for free. But instead of upgrading your car, they bought out a new one with all those features and the same price tag. You bought the car under the impression you'd get it upgraded, but you haven't, and instead theres a new product with things that you believe should have been in your car. You have a right to be angry because you have been misled in your original purchase.
Thats whats happening here, and thats why consumers have a right to be angry.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
zerocreatorz
zerocreatorz - - 632 comments

Just like the orange box has had many versions all priced around the same margin with people buying them over and over again (just to get the upgrade) my local gamestation had 3 different versions of HL2 when it came out WTF, Normal, Black and Special why do we need so many versions, for the idiot consumer of course...

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
EvilConker Author
EvilConker - - 317 comments

Wrayth, you're argument is flawed, just because Valve still makes money, a small amount, by the way (half life does not take 99 cents to make,) that doesn't support your ideas in any way. You're thinking "OMG THEY R MAKING NOT A LOT MONEY OFF OF THEIR HARD WORK LETS BOYCOTT THEM LAWL"

Also, ok, they didn't fall through on their promosis, YET, Valve has a VERY good track record on DLC, they probably will keep updating L4D, they never stopped updating Half Life 1 after 2 was released, you know. But not if they don't find you people deserving of it.

Before this boycott, you respected Valve, and Valve respected you, both of you were happy, Valve's developers were proud that they had one of the longest standing fan bases in the history of gaming, but now, they don't, because you're not respecting them. They aren't making as much money as they deserve, and they deserve a whole lot more then they're making. Ok, good, they're making money, but they deserve so much more, DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND THAT?

VALVE WORKS THEIR ***** OFF FOR YOU LITTLE BASTARDS, AND THIS IS HOW YOU REPAY THEM? They make money, but NOT ENOUGH money for THEIR HARD WORK, it's NOT easy to give away free DLC that other companies would definatly put a price tag on, IT'S NOT EASY AT ALL, VALVE DOES IT BECAUSE THEY ARE GENEROUS, CAN'T YOU APRECIATE THAT? AT ALL?

I mean, you guys are REALLY starting to **** me off, EVERYBODY SAYS YOU'RE WRONG, EVERY NEWS OUTLET'S AGAINST YOU, EVERYBODY EXCEPT FOR THE 34,000 THAT YOU'VE GOT IS AGAINST YOU.

DON'T YOU ******* UNDERSTAND THAT YOU UNAPPRECIATIVE SONS OF BITCHES?

Sorry that I went out like that, it doesn't happen often, until somebody REALLY ****** me off, congrats, you just ****** me off.

Reply Good karma+1 vote
zerocreatorz
zerocreatorz - - 632 comments

if you really believe they aint making much money go and check out how much shares are worth in their company youll be shocked for a start their obviously making enough money to SELL shares you aint gonna buy 5 pennys worth of shares for a million, lol.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Wraiyth
Wraiyth - - 483 comments

I smell a more serious case of Valve Fanboyism than I have...
I never thought that they're making so much money that they should be boycotted as a result. Fans boycott things because they believe (correctly or incorrectly) that they are being wrongly done by. In this case, Valve haven't yet delivered what they said they would. Even if they do deliver on L4D content (I don't know why they would if they have a newer game to support), they've still got a fragmented community.
If you read reviews for Left 4 Dead, the general consensus is that there wasn't really enough content to justify the price tag and most people brought it on the promise that there would definitely be more. So far, that more hasn't been delivered.

Just because a company works hard on something doesnt mean everyone HAS to respect their work and agree with what the are doing. I'm sure there are mods or games or people or ideas that you dislike. The fact that you're disrespecting my opinion right here is a reflection on how hypocritical your whole stance is.
As a Source modder with a mod being distributed on Steam, Valve have done a hell of alot for me, and I respect that. That doesn't mean I have to agree with everything they do and have to support them 100% in every single thing they do

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
EvilConker Author
EvilConker - - 317 comments

I am not a Valve fan and I never will be until I'm 18 and can play any of the games that they make.

I am a developer of a few games myself and I know how it feels.

Reply Good karma-1 votes
gamefreak42
gamefreak42 - - 644 comments

EvilConker Jul 2 2009, 10:17am replied:
What do you mean? Are you confusing companies? Valve only makes original IP's, and off of Mods that people wish to sell, Valve gets a cut of the profit from there too, Valve DOES NOT DESERVE THIS.


Do i smell politcaly correctsness land nearby? i am a part of 7 boycotts...do you have a problem with that?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Post a comment

Your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account: