BIG FEEDBACK Thread - IDF: Fight for Independence mod for Battlefield 2

Hi!

I need to say mod is great,models quality and soldiers exelent!! But it need still lot of work.Especially maps. Now feedback: Bf2 is specific game and has great mods. There are two ways of moding:If you want totaly realistic then its like PR,if you want to take best quality of maps and models on this engine then its FH2. As i see,you want quality mod,then your idol should be FH2.You have great quality models,but maps suck high.So here is few links of how to make great Bf2 map:

Fhpubforum.warumdarum.de -some good advices

Fhpubforum.warumdarum.de -exelent advices

Forgottenhope.warumdarum.de -lot of tutorials

Fhpubforum.warumdarum.de -THIS IS IMPORTANT!! LOOK AT IT AND MAKE IT REAL IN YOUR MAPS

Now,this mod,v0.15 is like LOTs of other mods that got realised and got dead after 1 year - they look too much BF2!!! Thats why FH2 and PR still living strong with multiplayer!They are diferent,better than vanila BF2.And thats where you are low.They changed EVERY single thing and made it 100% better than BF2 vanila and more realistic.This is what I saw and needs to be changed:

Second place in Egipt bomber doesnt have purpose,no gun

Optics of Israle tanks are lame,Egipt tanks have better,numbers and distances in optics looks good.

Ad AT and HE granates.That would be awsome.

Its stupid and unrealitic to have yellow aim on screen when you take gun(you know without right click).Only leave right click as aim.

Mashineguns on tanks and cars should have aiming like rifles.Also get out yellow aim!

Helicopter:You cant use other mashinegun(BUG)

Tanks:It would be better that you have on Shift "look outside of cupola" (like airplanes have) or that you are always outside cupola but use optic when press X

Egiptian helicopter gets up faster that Izrael(maybe less unrealistic?)

Look at "Push maps" that FH2 has.You should ask them and use(especialy on Last stand and Tobruk)

Dont put all assets/vehlichle at beggining.Put some as BLEED ASSETS-so you get them when you lose 200 tickets or lose 3 flags

Put fights and bombs sound/sound of fights in background

AA,AT,Tanks are too hard to destroy.Especially AA and AT(BIG BUG)

Mosing nagant has too slow animation when you fire fast without scope. Egiptian support kit weapon also has bad animation

When tank fires,and you get out then you can hear empty shell getting out(sound bug?)

Izrael enginner kit weapon has too big zoom when right click(BUG). Zoom should be like in Egipt enginner kit weapon

Tanks could have also some places for men to sit on then,not only two places in tanks

You should change look of minimap.This bf2 is TOO boring(just stupid circle.Look how fh2 has awsome look of minimap)

Put flags,they are missing on tobruk,also you can put them like they hang from box or stationary truck

Its stupid to have same rifles every map,example-put asault for Egipt once ak47 once PPsh.

Put PICK UP KITS,something like special enginner kit with mines,TNT,grenates,etc. Also you could put support kit and sniper LIMITED KIT

Its stupid to put airplane spawns in air,its stupid to put spawn points in vehlichles. You dont need to have big airfield for airplanes,it can be land too

Put more wrecks,destroyed houses and bunker from past fight,or wreck of spitfire from first arabic war.

TOO little emplaced mashineguns in bunkers,on wals,there is no ammo boxes for refilling(or put ammo truck,ammo at support kit is not enough)

THERE IS NO DETAILS ON MAPS!They are empty,flags are boring,WHERE ARE TRENCHES?? Where are boxes and "fake" ammo at AT and AA-there isnt just AT standing in desert,it has it own stuff,maybe put stationary truck which towed it there,ammo MUST be near AT or mortar. Where are other details,boxes,barrels, some sandbags that are not used,tents in mainbaze,commander tent,some stationary truck that brought ammo,medic tent,tank that is on repair,ETC

There is a lot of big camouflage tents that are not used.So anoying.Please TANKS CANT STAND IN FRONT OF FLAG WITHOUT COVER.IN real tanks are standing in camouflage cover,near bunkers so enemy dont see them,in foxholes.They can be outside if in map one side is "in moving".

That is all.Please read and watch on these details.

Edited by: JurisnikCRO