Comments - Tallamy

The only way they won historically was with vastly greater numbers, thus should be reflected in the game, and it's legit. They could probably use some more mamluk units though.

Actually the easiest solution might be to nerf the serjeants capability in melee vs knights, and buff knights' melee capability, by almost double.

My biggest concerns is how poor the knights are in combat, I know that 'melee' cav is going to beat 'shock' cav hands down when you just throw unit classes in the mix, but in my opinion all knightly cavalry should be thrown into the melee category and given incredible charging bonuses and maybe even Trample ability. Knights dominated the battlefield in almost all aspects that cavalry could, Mounted Serjeants should only be a really cheap alternative mostly meant for holding things in position or running down archers, they should NOT be kryptonite for HEAVY KNIGHTS.

The archers are also acting kind of weird yeah.