Post news Report RSS Dev Blog #33: Player Identification

One of the key issues we have discovered during our testing is that despite playing the game 'seriously' testers are continuing to struggle with identification of friend and foe. This has led to a high rate of friendly fire and some rather frustrating gameplay. A typical solution to this problem is either making player silhouettes more distinctive or by introducing helpers into the HUD to compensate for the fact that the world is scaled down onto a computer monitor, rather than 1:1 real world sc

Posted by on

Friend or Foe

One of the key issues we have discovered during our testing is that despite playing the game 'seriously' testers are continuing to struggle with identification of friend and foe. This has led to a high rate of friendly fire and some rather frustrating gameplay. A typical solution to this problem is either making player silhouettes more distinctive or by introducing helpers into the HUD to compensate for the fact that the world is scaled down onto a computer monitor, rather than 1:1 real world scale.Our focus on historical accuracy and realism presents us with some challenges, and this is a key example of where we are having to explore different options to find the right balance between replicating real life situations and designing compelling gameplay.In order to be historically correct we cannot significantly modify the silhouette and uniform of the players. On top of this, adding layers of HUD elements in the form of coloured silhouettes or markers would have a huge impact on the immersion of the game. It would also detract from the realism of spotting hidden enemies, and so we have been looking into alternative ways of reducing friendly fire incidents.

Another issue we uncovered during our testing was that when players picked up a weapon from the opposing team the number of friendly fire deaths increased dramatically. Players then couldn’t use someone’s weapon to identify their team, and in the heat of the moment the individuals holding the stolen weapon became confused as to which team they were on.

Our Solution

We are currently testing a couple of solutions to help fix these issues. Firstly, we've disabled the ability for players to pick up the weapons of fallen enemies (which in reality rarely happened). Secondly, we've introduced small white icons over the heads of teammates. These only display when you're within 25 metres, and help simulate the situational awareness that soldiers have on the battlefield in real life.

We hope this design will encourage more team work and better tactics by making it easier to track the spacing, distance, and position of your nearby squad mates who have green icons. Teammate’s names are also hidden by default in order to minimise distractions, but become visible when looking directly at the player. We are still testing and refining the concept, and have a few changes already planned - for example the green dots are too bright at night - but in current testing the concept is proving to be successful.

Human senses can be difficult to convey in games, and we hope this will prove to be a useful addition without being too intrusive.As the system further develops we would like to create class icons, so players will not only be able to quickly identify their teammates, but also what kit they’re using.

Community Survey

As you well know we have always enjoyed reading the community's feedback and suggestions for the game. This time however, we are looking for specific input regarding certain questions as we make a plan for how and when the game will be released.

We have prepared a short survey and would really appreciate our community members taking the time to answer. We will be reviewing the results at this year's DevCon so please spare a few minutes and give us your thoughts.

Thank you!

Post comment Comments
Zabargad
Zabargad - - 14 comments

Can't wait to try this out, its looking really good rn

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
Hezus
Hezus - - 561 comments

I think these are good additions to the game for regular servers and casual players. What I would love to see is the option to switch these things on and off. This would allow people to create realism servers where enemy weapons can be picked up and there really are no HUD-elements.

I've played WW2 shooters in the past which had the above options and it worked just fine for the people involved.

Filled out the survey, btw!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Serathis
Serathis - - 468 comments

Nice to see this project is still going on, unlike In Country: Vietnam and Festung Europa(?)

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
vfn4i83
vfn4i83 - - 692 comments

Was wondering about this game, good to see you guys.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Rrtaya_Tsamsiyu
Rrtaya_Tsamsiyu - - 244 comments

Might help on the realism side of things if the dot was the same color and had the same lighting effects as the player's helmet, so it wouldn't be so obviously different from the rest of the look of the game.

Would also be good if it disappeared if they went behind a wall or something.

It wouldn't be quite as effective at stopping friendly fire, especially at night, but then again friendly fire is a constant issue in real life, and even more so at night.

And i think picking up enemy weapons needs to be added back in, but have it to where when you pick it up it only has what ammo was left in the clip. This would allow you to pick up a dead guys gun if yours ran out at a critical moment, but wouldn't be useful in general game play.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Landrik
Landrik - - 31 comments

Amen to this!!!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
RangePlusOne
RangePlusOne - - 3 comments

Looks very cool! Always down to check out a ww2 shooter!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Knez
Knez - - 1,416 comments

Oh my God, that graphics! It's beautiful

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
HectorShiroi
HectorShiroi - - 302 comments

Very good idea, this is a perfect compromise to cope with real life situations shrunk at 1920x1080, 90 FOV and only 2 of 5 senses at work

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
notaclevername
notaclevername - - 522 comments

If you push for realism there should be a server mode for hardcore please. A mode to do away with indicators and hud information, or options to let the server host pick and choose. These things attract server hosts if they have an option to tailor the gameplay. please. Great looking work team!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
Post a comment

Your comment will be anonymous unless you join the community. Or sign in with your social account: