David alias Otter - Mod fan and and occasional mod critic, also wannabe game designer.
[Continuation from the first part]
But enough of that. I still really enjoyed it. Thank you for making it in the end and thank you for the experience. It really shows your passion for this little game and your tenacity to make it better every time.
And this game also reminded me to finish my own 13 year old project, which is a "graphic novel", that I swore to myself that I finish last year or stop working on it altogether, yet it's still unfinished and I'm still working on it, so I also thank you for the reminder ;)
Good luck to you with your future projects.
And for everyone else: Try this game out! It's really difficult, like almost "Edmund McMillen" level difficult twitch gaming combined with (sometimes out-of-the-box) puzzle solving, but for old-school gamers - especially for those who prefer platformers - and K&P/GF/MM veterans it will be a satisfying experience.
So I finally finished it, took me long enough (mainly due to frustration) but I did finish it.
So here is my critique:
This game - in it's own merit - was fantastic. As an experienced Klik & Play and Games Factory user I'm amazed what you could bring out of the engine. I used to think Antonio Barra's games (The Elk:SE, Bomberballs) were the cream of the crop back then (meaning: 10-14 years ago), but you outdid him by miles!
The puzzles were cleaver, some of the boss fights were nicely tough and making progress was satisfying. I sometimes felt like back in the day when I tried those cool Clickgames someone else made and I thank you for that feeling.
Now for the bad stuff, not really a criticism for you at this point :) Mainly as a note for others that want to try this game.
You mostly summed it up in your making-of video already: The pacing is sometimes bad; the difficulty curve has enormous ups and downs (I'm so glad for that Puzzle solver); the story is really nothing new; almost impossible to dodge boss attacks; too much stages for one boss (but still awesomely satisfying when you finally kill them); and the ending is a bit - for the lack of a better word - shallow and rushed.
So did he die in the end? That is why the king was there? Unknowingly sacrificed his life?
Also the controls. Yes, they are a bit tough to master. I got more used to it, since I'm an experienced Clickgame player, but I could see others having a hard time getting comfortable with it.
Lol at the entitlement. "Why do other people's work cost me money?!"
I noticed that in the past days this article gathered around 300 views. I know most of these are probably just clicks on my page, but even if only 2% actually read it then how come no one leaves a comment?
No one had a similar story? Or no one liked this blog entry? Was it to wordy? Or too vague?
I was trying to start some conversations. Can you give a guy a short feedback if you have a few spare seconds? :)
Oh hey, an 18 year old spoiler.
Also nicely hacked soldier stats.
I was afraid of a sh*tstorm in the comments to be honest, but this is a great idea. :) I already thought the pay-what-you-want feature was missing from Steam, so maybe Valve see this now and more small team indie games can follow this. I will definitely support the project when I have the means.
Well the last good games I played where you are a zombie is Infectonator and Sonny 1-2, both are pretty funny and enjoyable and both are flash games that came out years ago, so it's understandable if people have some concerns.
Haha, I tried a bit more sarcastic approach in the past ( Moddb.com ) when I was more active around here. Feels like throwing peas against the wall. :P
What? The person who wanted to destroy whatever is in the Borealis was Eli, that's why he sent Gordon and Alyx there. And even if Kleiner went rogue, how would we catch up to him when there is only one helicopter in White Forest the one Gordon was about to take to the Borealis.
Hah, Probably the only case I want to hear that sentence :)
I like how it looks so far.
Yeah, I seen the video and it already looks better in the small details. One more thing I would like is a bit more subtlety on the forth-wall breaking jokes. Mainly on the "it's in the script\" ones, but the pizza-cake joke should be heard once only too. But they can be really fun with the right pacing.
I played the demo. Really fun so far, I enjoyed that the mini-game mechanics were actually playable and just the right amount of length, not frustrating, hard or really slow like I seen elsewhere. :P
The only few problems I found were small graphical tearing on some background objects, but that's probably due to the engine. And one bug I found was when the blacksmith opens the door he goes ahead, but further down there in the dark in front of those boxes I could talk to him despite him being invisible since he wasn't suppose to be there probably and got the key from him early.
But other than that great job so far. Not sure how much it will cost when it's finished, but I will buy it.
Also I have a scene idea/suggestion: You know how in some Rpgs like Skyrim you get a sudden power and the people around you know you are the Dragonborn. How about a scene where our (not the) hero gets some kind of magical power no one seen before and everyone thinks she is the chosen one of legends!...But then it turns out she isn't, and it's a pretty common power, just the villagers are so disconnected from the rest of the Empire they have no clue about it.
I think it would fit well in the game's theme. :)
Well competition isn't always a bad thing. We, the customer, can choose from the better product in the end.
The thing that bothers me is if this is supposed to take place in a whole galaxy:
- Then why is their a stone castle with wooden stairs the most emphasised thing in the screenshots? Isn't this supposed to be futuristic? Or is it supposed to be like Spore with an advancing system? (like the Thaumcraft mod for Minecraft, but with science)
- What will prevent people to group up and build like a Deathstar, going around either blowing solar system to bits or just rapid mine the whole thing?
- Where will they get the powerhouse computers and server capacity to run this whole operation?
Oh, that's his back. I first thought he had a weird yellow head (and related to Gondar Dota2.gamepedia.com) before I checked the other pictures :D
Well this looks pretty fun and funny. Glad I checked it. I hope you throw in and twist every cliché from the usual "RPG maker" games :D
"Put your door on the north side" Ohhhh, I can already see this will be a good one.
Quite ironic isn't it. The brave heroes who save the world are always petty thieves as well.
That's a nice set for Drow Ranger.
(sorry, couldn't pass this up)
"Zweistein". Lol. Looks like I'm not the only one who thought of this joke :) (Although it's a pretty obvious one)
They are using Vista and IE 6. Nothing can be done.
I was never a fan of Sonic and probably never played any of the games, but even I have to admire the dedication put into even such a little thing, especially with that promo video explaining everything clearly with a calm voice and logic even a non-player like me can understand, and with custom animation and all.
Other small mod/addon developers, take notes!
(No, not you nude mod creators, go back to you holes and shush.)
This current influx of stupid comments asking the same question reminds me of the time in primary school when we were given a paper with a bunch of tasks and asked to solve it as quick as possible.
The first task was to read the paper from start to finish, and that was followed by a bunch of logical puzzles and math problems, nothing to hard but takes time to solve. The next to last task however was the question: "Did you remember the first task?" and the last one said: "I you do and did so, you now don't have to do any of the tasks above, only write that first sentence down for you to remember." So all of the fools who started doing the tasks right away - without reading them all - got tricked, while me and the other patient ones who actually did everything in order got a free pass.
What I'm trying to say with this, is that some people didn't learn the ability what I've been taught in primary school a decade ago, or at least use Google and common sense; and also that Guest accounts commenting is still a stupid idea. At least "having to register" would hold back some of these simpletons because of their laziness.
Now I'm waiting to see the closed page for "Prop Hunt" mod to pop up in the list.
Hmm, the music sounds familiar, but I can't remember where I heard it before. Isn't it Kevin Macleod?
Simeon? "Simeon" the sorcerer? :D
Radír means eraser in Hungarian. :)
The time it took you to write this comment, you probably could have found the solution. This might help:
3 years since last update? Original creator went on other projects? I think you can draw your own conclusions.
He really kicked himself in the balls when he joined that team full of retards, but even if it would came out it would have quickly lost its funny value anyway, the same way (I and probably other people) don't find 3-4 year old g-mod parody videos funny anymore either.
I hope that was a joke.
That could backfire on you so horribly it won't be even funny.
*sniff* *sniff* I smell a really bad troll.
Come on dude, are you even trying? The least we could expect is more grammatical errors and exclamation marks.
You know what would improve the Opposing force campaign greatly? When you are in boot camp, the drill instructor says to one of the guys that: "Where you from soldier? Texas? Holy cow, you know what comes from Texas don't cha?"
Then the soldier/marine should reply: "Sir, in this game you are free to kill innocent scientists, friendly fire is allowed and you can gib enemies to a bloody pulp. I pretty sure it's safe to actually quote Full metal jacket at this point without getting a higher maturity rating."
I would prefer if they wouldn't actually include the manhack arcade in the mod, expect maybe as an easter egg sign that it's "now closed". I won't like to go into in-depth details why it doesn't make any sense to include it, let's just say it wasn't Valve's strongest moments when they came up with that idea.