This member has provided no bio about themself...
That's the spirit. :)
Warner Brothers wants us all to lose hope and to forget about Merp, accept their supposed authority and then go out and buy Lego lotr and Guardians of Middle Earth. They'll lose against the Estate and at least 27,000 people and counting will know what they tried to do.
I don't know about a gif. But maybe just use a regular signature.
On this other forum, my Signature is
"No one knows what the new day shall bring him" -Aragorn T.A. 3019 March 4th
Save Merp for 2013!
25,000 and counting. 12-23-12
Something to that effect is productive, I think.
I believe that's correct.
Anyone want to chime in?
AlchestBreach made top comment on the map tour of Merp.
Never mind. I figured it out.
How do I PM someone? I have something important to tell the Merp team.
My bad, it was week 56. The first mod he shows is the one he makes fun of and the one that caused a mini backlash.
Let's all post comments to get his attention... and to bump the thread from the second page ;)
Setch Dreskar posted a comment in the first page, saying Warner had every legal right to do this. Granted at the time he may have been right, but now that we know better someone else here should post and counter his point directly. I'd do it myself except I think it'd help Merp's image to have more than just one vocal fan in the thread posting more than everyone else.
I believe Setch Dreskar is Joe's representative in the forum. If Warner's apparent legal rights are his only objections to helping Merp, then countering that point directly may help.
He featured a mod just to make fun of it. A lot of people were mad about that.
We should try to get alchestbreach to talk about Merp.
He has a lot of subscribers so it's difficult to get a hold of him. But if we all message him, it may work.
There's certainly a large pool of mod reviewers, but mmoxreview does consistently get the most views. He could help a lot.
I only mention mmoxreview now because I saw the episode for two weeks ago had "Lord of the Rings" in the title. I clicked on the thumbnail hoping he was finally going to give Merp the spotlight. Instead he talked about some other lotr mod.
I don't get it. Why hasn't he featured Merp yet? He's clearly aware of it; when he did give it a brief mention, he said," for all those of you who are continuously messaging me about Merp...". I don't want to press the issue for fear that it may annoy him. The word "continuously" and the recent flak he's been getting about Week 55 makes me fear that's a possibility.
I guess all we can do is wait and hope he decides to feature Merp.
You know, mmoxreview never made an episode with Merp.
It's been almost two months since he said he would...
I left a comment about Merp on this video. Please thumbs up my comment to help it get noticed.
Stop right there, Criminal Scum! No one violates Merp on my watch. I'm confiscating your Cease and Desist. Now pay the Estate a fine, or it's off to jail.
Except WB is going to lose certain licensing rights soon. If Merp is under WB when it falls (metaphorically mind you), it will fall too.
I don't blame Jackson for the C&D or any of this.
I think what the Great Mungulor meant was that Jackson's films have increased the general interest in Middle Earth and by association, Merp.
Jackson has helped Merp, without knowing it.
I just saw the updated, update.
Thanks, Merp team :) and everyone else :)
You guys are going to pull through this. You're talented and it shows through your work. Merp stands to be better than Skyrim and I believe 2013 is going to be a good year for Merp.
" I look to see the Dawn.../
No one knows what the new day shall bring him." -Aragorn
I feel that's applicable here. I mean the whole C&D business was bad, I think we'll all agree to that. But maybe, because the Tolkien Estate is getting involved, it may end up helping Merp. I posted this here before, but here it is again. Wired.com
If this is a legacy issue for the Tolkien Estate, they won't back down. They will win and Warner will lose and you guys will be left with 26,000 followers. I think you guys are going to pull through this and the project will be all the better for it in the end.
Great update, guys.
I've just updated all the threads I've started on various forums about Merp with it.
"I look out to see the dawn.../
No one knows what the next day shall bring him."
I think commercial exploitation is the key word there. They probably issued that statement for legal reasons, asserting their authority over the IP.
If one has power, it's best to only use it when one must. Technically, all those sites with lessons on how to learn Sindarin or Quenya violate some sort of copyright law, or so I believe (they all have legal disclaimers). Yet the Estate has allowed those to continue and I haven't heard of any fan-fiction being taken down for legal reasons.
I don't know how they'd react to Merp. Personally, and this is just me, if the Estate wins - when they win - I'd ask them for permission to continue. Appeal to them, make a case and emphasize the non-profit fan part of the project. This mod has too many followers to remain hidden from them for long and trying to hide from them might just make them mad. Of course this isn't up to me, whatever you guys decide to do: God Speed.
I wouldn't mind an easter egg, like finding a large bow near his corpse. But I wouldn't want Lurtz, or any of Jackson's other additions inserted into the mod.
That's what makes Merp special (aside from the enormous map and high quality): It's fidelity to the books.
I started a thread about Merp on Forumshire (a really great Tolkien site with a lot of awesome people).
While I agree that Warner probably won't sue them. It's the team's decision to make, not ours, and we should support them in whatever they decide to do.
They're doing this mod for free.