Co-leader of Epoch Games, developer of The Lays of Althas: Sundered Order (please look up the team and project on IndieDb) -------------------- Also a former modder of the canceled Middle Earth Roleplaying Project (MERP), a Total Conversion Modification of Skyrim (you can look that project up on ModDb)

Comment History  (210 - 240 of 288)
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP 0.2.6 Trailer: Bree

You realize that the architecture in Bree in the films is nearly spot on with this architecture in the video, right?

Good karma+5 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

Yeah well, try removing the other half ... I can't believe anyone would have THAT many Skyrim mods :P

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

I don't think the battle was as large as you might think. He definitely used a lot of creative angles spliced together though.

MERP will actively be trying to find ways to create large battles in Skyrim, so stay tuned for that ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@1st_of_the_Nine*WoA*: Creating a "Sauron got the Ring" sort of scenario is quite a lot of work (which sort of sounds like your proposed "Rise of the Dark Lord" mode). It means we have to create destroyed versions of settlements we've created ... its just not worth it (MAYBE some later point, but I doubt it).

Basically we don't have any planned game modes to change the number of NPCs patrolling Middle Earth.

The current "game modes" planned for MERP right now is Free Roam (where the player plays as a no-name NPC with a lot of freedom), Ringbearer (where the player gets to play as Frodo, where it is your task to destroy the One Ring), and White Council (like Free Roam except your character has some history with White Council and can take part in the White Council questline).

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Legion9339: Beorn is a bit of an anomaly in the lore. Tolkien never says WHY he and his people can transform into bears, but I do have my own theories. Since Beornings will be a playable race, I'm sure there will be at least a quest or two that will cover their origins and why they can transform :)

Still, just because the Beornings can transform doesn't mean the other races should: its a special ability of Beorn's people (minus the Maiar, who can shapeshift too, which I pointed out earlier).

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@KidStein: That is definitely THE racial ability we want for Beornings: to be able to transform into a bear, so way ahead of you ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@1st_of_the_Nine*WoA*: I can answer that question. Well, there are werewolves and vampires in Tolkien's lore, BUT they are unlike werewolves and vampires in most fiction in that they are generally believed to be dark, angelic-like beings (dark Maiar) who have taken on these forms wolf and bat like forms, and joined with Melkor in the elder days of the First Age:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werewolf_(Middle-earth)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vampire_(Middle-earth)

So to answer your question: no, the player will not be able to become a werewolf or vampire in our mod, since we won't be letting the player play as a shape-shifting Maiar of any kind.

Also mind you, MERP takes place in the late Third Age, so I doubt you'll be seeing many, if any, of them at all in Middle Earth, but you never know ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Ricewind: We don't take donations. It would only give more grounds for lawyers to sue our mod for use of the Tolkien IP. If you want to help us out, continue to follow progress and support us. Btw we are always in need of music composers, so if you have any Middle Earth-type tunes you'd like to share, feel free to create an application on our dev forums :)

Merp.straygenius.com

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@ChuckNrs: Smaug may be dead by the time of the War of the Ring (LOTR), but there are definitely still dragons in Middle Earth. You just have to know where to look ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Mhaedros: I can't really answer your question, BUT I did want to let you know that I keep a listing on what needs modeled for MERP. Send me a PM over the SkyrimNexus forums (my username is "names_are_useless") and I can let you know what's top priority for us in the way of models ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Elendil1325: And here I would disagree. There are no big battles in Skyrim. At most maybe a couple dozen between sides. A true big battle should be in the hundreds, if not THOUSANDS, and I hope we can hit that mark some day.

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

Well Maegfaer's comment is semi-correct: evil races such as Nazgul, Orcs, Uruk-hai, Trolls, etc. are enslaved to Sauron's will and have no true free will. It just doesnt sit right with me to allow the player to play as an Orc who goes about picking flowers :S

Now Evil Men such as Haradrim, Easterlings, Black Numenoreans, and Dunlendings are a different story. They are just Men, and do have Free Will and the chance to do good or evil. Faction does not always define every individual, remember that. In Two Towers, when Sam sees a fallen Haradrim, he wonders if he is truly evil at heart. So yeah, Evil Men races could be playable in a future release.

@1st_of_the_Nine*WoA*: I don't think you understand the Ringwraiths. When the 9 Kings (well, lore says they were warriors and sorcerors as well actually) took the 9 Rings of Power, they became slaves to Sauron. They will do EVERYTHING he commands. While Orcs might fight with one another and do things SOMEWHAT against Sauron's will (but still nothing considered "good"), the Nazgul will not. Every command Sauron gives them they WILL follow.

And you can't say "well what if they take off their Rings?" In the books, its actually unsure if they even wear their Rings (if not, then they're probably in Barad Dur or Minas Morgul, somewhere safe). But the real point is that not only are they slaves to Sauron, but also their Rings. When Sauron is destroyed, so is the power of the Rings, and thus they are destroyed as well.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@klaasvdb: The Creation Kit will actually let us mod Skyrim ... so yeah, I guess you could say that it will make work a lot easier :P

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@runescaperian: Currently, this mod is planned to take place between the years of 3018-3019: the final two years of the War of the Ring, and then probably into the Fourth Age some time after that (basically the time period of the LOTR books). So no, Smaug will be long dead; we have no intentions of creating a questline based on "The Hobbit."

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ December 2011 update

@shaga1: You really think we would create a Helm's Deep model for MERP Oblivion and NOT try porting it over to MERP Skyrim? :P

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ December 2011 update

@neigenoire: You do know that we are looking to try to create (or at the very least look like) actual large-scale battles for MERP in Skyrim, right? ;)

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP 0.2.4 & 0.2.6 comparison

@Ulorndir: MERP v0.2.6 is currently our final-planned MERP release for Oblivion. After that, we will be moving what assets we can from MERP in Oblivion over to Skyrim, and start creating MERP in Skyrim. Something like that :P

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP Team

@kalaur: Check your hotmail account, I sent you an email (under names_r_useless @ hotmail.com).

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Ralok: Watched a Let's Play of War in the North. Design-wise there is some good stuff, but then some of it is kind of over-the-top and doesn't seem very Tolkien-ish to me (the dragon in the game reminded me a little too much of Deathwing from WoW for example).

MERP is generally sticking to the books and films.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@stef364: We're mainly focusing on the Free Peoples and its factions. Evil playable races are a way's off, and joining the big evil factions like Isengard or Mordor is not a feature we're looking to implement right now. HOWEVER, don't let that fool you: there may just be other evil factions to join ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ December 2011 update

@guiaranha: Both Oblivion and Skyrim use the same file types for models, meaning we can import them into either game.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ December 2011 update

@Holgof: we're planning to follow the book's take on the Battle of the Hornburg, where Isengard's forces had more then just Uruk-hai (Orcs, Half-Orcs, Dunlendings, Wolf Riders, etc).

Also we currently aren't planning on evil playable races for initial release, nor the option to join the big evil factions like Isengard and Mordor. That doesn't mean we don't want to include evil playable races in later releases (I know I sure do!), but they're a way's off.

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ December 2011 update

@u-raptor: There will be one more release of MERP for Oblivion (v0.2.6), then we're moving MERP onto Skyrim.

Good karma+2 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Ruubie5: We plan on releasing an installer for the next MERP Oblivion release, don't worry.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Ruubie5: We do not plan on completing the Oblivion version of MERP. We're moving onto Skyrim after the next (and final) Beta version of MERP for Oblivion is released.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

We had a tenth Fellowship member as an idea, but its completely unrealistic and really goes against the lore. Elrond chose 9 Fellowship members for a reason - in contrast to the nine Nazgul. Also I can't imagine playing as a tenth Fellowship member would be all too fun. It would basically just be an escort quest, with your character being overshadowed by the other 9 members in all the various scenes.

Trust me when I say that playing as the Ringbearer will be a fun and unique experience ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

You will be able to play as Frodo in the Ringbearer Questline. Currently, we plan that upon character creation, there will be a section in-game that the player can make some important decisions, such as (if they're a male Hobbit) that they can take on the role of Frodo. And before you ask, no, you can design your Frodo to look like whatever you want and develop your Frodo character as you please.

Currently we don't have plans to allow the player to play as other Fellowship members (Aragorn, Legolas, etc.), or as any other established character in Tolkien's lore for that matter.

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@Sambugaro: If you can find the name of the mod, I'll suggest that mod resource to the rest of the team ;)

Good karma+1 vote
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@EricWass: Right now they're just static objects, but I hope in a future version of MERP we can make working siege equipment :)

Good karma+3 votes
names_are_useless
names_are_useless @ MERP | Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project

@vrock627:
What is everyone's obsession with wanting to be a Ringwraith? Anyways no, there is no chance as far as I'm concerned. The Ringwraiths have no free will and are slaves to Sauron's will, even more so then Goblins/Orcs/Uruk-hai/Trolls/etc. Don't expect any of these evil creatures to ever be playable.

Good karma+1 vote
Level
Avatar
Avatar
Last Online
Country
United States United States
Gender
Male
Friends
Become friends
Member watch
Start tracking
Comment Statistics
Posts
288
Per day
0.1
Members
1
Games
23
Mods
196
Articles
12
Media
55
Downloads
2
Groups
4