This member has provided no bio about themself...

Comment History  (150 - 180 of 2,798)
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 19 2014, 3:34pm replied:

No.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 19 2014, 3:34pm replied:

Afaik nothing of that has changed yet. But a lot of players already have managed to beat the map.^^

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 19 2014, 2:41pm replied:

At the moment the witchking of angmar is already really strong (afaik banned in the last few tournaments) and as ring hero he is considered as one of the strongest of all factions.

I don't really understand your idea, what exactly do you want?

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 19 2014, 2:39pm replied:

We are a mod of the wotr. The Valar never fought in that time period. Additionally a Valar would be super-overpowered. Just imagine the power of 20 Balrogs combined... even in the spellbook it would be totally overpowered. (that's why we are only referring to them, f.e. lorien has the ability "tears of the valar")

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 19 2014, 2:37pm replied:

No. Downloading Rotw is ILLEGAL. You have to buy it or find your own way to download it.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 4:03pm replied:

THen you have installed something wrong.
If you have installed the newest patch (Rotw 2.01) and no other mod it should work without problems.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 3:56pm replied:

Depends on the dwarven faction you take, there are three different possibilities, every faction has different heroes. (you choose ingame which dwarven realm you want to command)
I don't have all in my mind, why don't you just play the current version? But you can also read about the changes in our news section. :)

+2 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 3:48pm replied:

No, Thror won't be added, as he doesn't fit into the time.
All factions are placed in a certain time window, as otherwise it could happen that you have two heroes under your comment at the same time, who have lived hundreds of years apart from each other.

The edain-team creates the mod, not a single person. I'm part of it, so you can just ask me, I can transmit everything to our intern forums.

+2 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 3:37pm replied:

1.
Dwarves
Imladris
Lorien
Gondor
Rohan
Mordor
Isengard
Angmar
Goblins
2. Mordor
3. Yes

+2 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 2:33am replied:

You can't download version 4.0 yet. The last published version (edain mod 3.8.1) is downloadable on this page. You just have to click on "downloads".

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 18 2014, 2:32am replied:

Gorthaur is strong, but in no comparance to the Balrog. The Balrog is a completely different story.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 17 2014, 12:40pm replied:

No.
The Balrog was discussed quite often. We are NOT integrating the Balrog as a normal hero. He will remain a spellbookpower.
Have you ever played a mod with a buildable Balrog?
It sounds cool and is really fascinating for the first 2-3 times, but afterwards it gets boring - the Balrog looses its special place and becomes just a normal hero, with totally overpowered abilities.
If we would integrate it, the Balrog would be either a "buy the Balrog and the game is won"-feature or really weak. At the moment he is strong vs everything, he can escape easily, is VERY strong against troups AND heroes and he can even reach archers within seconds. Therefore he would need a weakness, even as an ultimate ability.
Heroes? It would look stupid, if he would deal no damage against them/get a lot of damage from them. Units? This would look really horrible ingame.^^
The Balrog can be so overpowered and can have this incredible feeling because you can't control him forever, but only for a small period of time. Otherwise he would loose much of his coolness-factor.

Additionally we're trying to get away from expensive heroes. All heroes will cost between 50 and 3000 ressources in the next version. (this makes the balance for us much easier, the AI better and the gameplay is much more fluently)

+4 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 16 2014, 10:34am replied:

It will be released when we've finished the work on it.

+4 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 16 2014, 10:33am replied:

Noone knows.

+3 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 16 2014, 10:33am replied:

We think that the design doesn't fit to the Beorn which was described in the books AND doesn't fit into the world of Tolkien.

+4 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 16 2014, 10:01am replied:

As said before:
We don't like the beorn design and will stick with ours.
Thrain and Thror will NOT be in the skirmish mode, as they don't fit too the factions. We will probably rework their looks in the campaign, but probably not for the next version, as there are much more important parts.

+3 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 15 2014, 9:59am replied:

We are currently working on some news, I think at least one will come in the near future (next couple of weeks). :)

+6 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 14 2014, 7:48am replied:

We will give him the skin (colors etc.) of the movie, BUT we will use TOlkien's version of Smaug. Therefore it will have: 4 legs and 2 wings.
Jackson's Smaug was not a dragon, but a wyvern.

+7 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 14 2014, 7:47am replied:

Yeah, there were some dwarves... some, but not many. We have discussed that a long time ago and decided not to integrate dwarves, as they don't really fit.
Probably there were even more different nations (perhaps even hobbits), but that would just be too much. It wouldn't look like a strong army, but like a randomly compiled cluster of people. That wouldn't fit for an ultimate power.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 14 2014, 7:43am replied:

No, there is nothing. But you can't get further than the third map, as there is a bug.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 14 2014, 7:43am replied:

We will try everything to make it work. Of course all of your points are important and we have thought long about it.

Concerning 1) and 2):

They have a small advantage because they aren't just bounded to the normal spots, that's correct.

BUT:
The fortresses, camps and outposts have less build plots. Therefore you need around 2-3 additional camps for a similar amount of buildings on a normal map.
Those camps also have a minimum distance to other camps, therefore you can't build them as close to each other as the current Isengard buildings.
Therefore you already have to defend much more camps (which aren't very strong without you defending them) on a wider area, which makes them very vulnerable. If you build even more you have to pay 4000 just for 3 more build plots. That is a lot of money and your enemy can put 4000 in his troups , therefore his army should be much stronger afterwards and he should be able to get some advantages elsewhere on the map.
In a normal game you will hardly ever build more than 2-3 of those points, as it is much too expensive AND it will be very difficult to defend all of them and you will loose a lot when your camps are destroyed (more than 4000 ressources just because he has destroyed a camp with 3 plots... other factions just loose around 1000-2000).

With the minimum distance between the camps you also can't build endless camps.

Concerning 3:

I wouldn't say that the balance was destroyed. Bfme II 1.06 had a good balance. But you're right that we never liked the barrack spamming... the problem in edain was:
You had the possibility to build endless farms and endless barracks. Even with the additional camps you won't be able to build so many farms and barracks, you always have to decide what you want to build. But as said: You won't be able to build many additional camps.^^

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 13 2014, 8:44am replied:

You have to level up Sauron. As long as he is alive he gains experience when the Nazgul or the Mouth kills enemies. With Sauron gainig level 3,6,9 you have the possibility to choose one more domain.

+2 votes   download: Edain Mod 3.8.1
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 13 2014, 7:32am replied:

Edain 4.0 will not be the final version, we will continue working on the mod afterwards.

+4 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 13 2014, 4:31am replied:

It has not been released yet, so you can't download it. You have to wait until we've finished the work on it. :)

+2 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 12 2014, 1:05pm replied:

Dark King has explained it really good.

Additionally you are the leader of your faction. I personally wouldn't like it to understand my own inferiors. When I'm playing as goblins I think I'm a goblin who's leading all of them, not a human. Why should I not understand the goblins? I give them all orders... how do I give them orders when I don't understand them?

(finally: We don't have enough voice-sets to make so many different voices in different languages)

+2 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 12 2014, 1:00pm replied:

Dwarves will have the possibilities.
Why should it be easier to place them on walls? In the current version I have no problems.

Catapults will be similar strong against walls. But we are weakening them against units.
Catapults are so strong atm, as most players are clumping all of their units on a small spot - catapults deal aoe-damage. It is possible, but very difficult to forbid your units to clump up in small spaces.
Yes, that is normal.

+1 vote   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 12 2014, 10:21am replied:

1.Yes, there will be some more maps, I made two completely new 1vs1 maps for Arnor and as far as I know the other mappers also created some new Arnor-maps. :)
2. No.
3. I think we have enough beta-tester at the moment. Normally we just want german beta-testers as the betas are all in german and the english translation comes afterwards. Additionally we want players we know quite good and are part of the community a long time, so we know if they will really help us and give us regularly helpful feedback or just play the beta without helpung us.
4. We are already using voicepacks of other games and movies. :)

+3 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 12 2014, 10:18am replied:

The problem with such "special upgrades" is that they are very strong versus some factions, but useless against other factions. Not all factions have those upgrades, so it can happen that just because of this upgrade a faction has no chance against any other faction, for example:
Gondor can buy fire upgrades. Against the dwarves this upgrade is useless, so you'll never buy it.
Against Rohan it is really strong, so Rohan has no chance against it - or the upgrade is so weak that we will NEVER see it against any faction who doesn't have only wooden buildings. So you will never have upgraded archers, which would be also very frustrating.
All Archers (including all upgrades for archers) will be weaker in the next version, as the current version is a battle of archers and knights. Those two unit types dominate the whole game at the moment. Probably your problem was not the upgrade, but the normal archer-damage.
Accuracty is always a very difficult thing - giving a unit more damage and less accuracy is the same thing as not changing anything. There are so many arrows in the game that the player doesn't notice the difference. (have you noticed that orc archers hit only 40% of the time, normal archers hit about 50-90% of the time and elves hit 100%? Probably not, you have probably just noticed that elves do much more damage.^^)

Gondor batallions normally can't resist a real assault of trolls and uruks, at least in all of my games.^^ Uruks are stronger than normal gondor soldiers and trolls are very strong against all melee units when you have 3-4 at once. Only archers can destroy them easily. But normally Gondor should loose against Isengard or Mordor in the current version.

+3 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 10 2014, 3:28pm replied:

In the future.

+6 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Gnomi
Gnomi Sep 10 2014, 2:45pm replied:

Tom Bombadil. :P
You don't know what it is. :D
Then a lot of other heroes, which aren't named in the movies. (additionally it is not sure that Gothmog is an orc - he could also be a Nazgul or a dark numenor).

Sauron controlled additionally some "half orcs". The Barrow-wights are also not shown in the movies. The Old Man Willow also had no appearance. (probably she was an ent, but it was never said exactly. Perhaps she was just something similar)
Additionally the huorns just have a very small appearance in the second SEE. Wolves and foxes also weren't shown in the movies, just the bigger wargs. (and all the small bugs. :P )

Tolkiengateway.net

This is a big list of all the creatures - I don't know if it is complete, but many creatures which are not shown in the movies are listed up there.

+3 votes   mod: Edain Mod
Avatar
Avatar
Offline Since
Dec 19, 2014
Country
Germany Germany
Gender
Male
Member Watch
Track this member
Comment Statistics
Posts per day
1.4
Members
10
Mods
2,516
Articles
108
Media
71
Downloads
196