mikejkelley

mikejkelley joined Sep 11, 2004

I'm mikejkelley, currently living in Asia.

Image RSS Feed Latest Screens
buddah statue 텅영 me.
Blog RSS Feed Report abuse Latest Blog: An open letter to the moddb.com staff

0 comments by mikejkelley on Mar 8th, 2008 digg this super bookmark


I've recently researched and written an article regarding copyright infringement as it applies to modding (and, briefly, the legal repercussions of hosting copyright-infringing materials). I completed it with the input of several lawyers and a professional game designer.

I realize that the "soapbox" feature's establishment is probably not coincidental with the "IP in mods" debate and that the article may seem a good candidate for inclusion in the "soapbox" feature. However, as the article contains a much higher ratio of legal citation than opinion (it contains a singular conclusion that is the reflection of a multitude of statutes and legal precedents), putting it in an oped feature would tend to undermine the amount of research and professional input it includes. As a result I would only be willing to let it run as a feature.

I'm sure the staff and users of moddb.com are just as concerned as I am about the survivability of modding. Hopefully, understanding the legal repercussions of making and distributing copyright infringing materials will result in change for the better and help to ensure the survivability of modding for years to come.

Mikejkelley.com

Thanks for your time and consideration and I hope to see the article featured soon.

Sincerely,

Michael Kelley

Groups
3D Artists Group

3D Artists Group

Established Nov 21, 2007 With 102 members, must apply to join arts & literature group

Are you a 3D artist, are you looking for some talent or just want to collaborate or know who your fellow ModDB artists are. Doesn't matter what application...

Anime Fans of modDB

Anime Fans of modDB

Established Nov 12, 2007 With 65 members, open to all members arts & literature group

This group has been formed to gather the people who enjoy Japanese anime and all of its facets, to salute the people from the land of the Rising Sun.

Lone Modders

Lone Modders

Established Nov 22, 2007 With 7 members, must apply to join development & publishing group

A group for anti-social compulsive types. Lone Modders do it alone!

Musicians at ModDB

Musicians at ModDB

Established Nov 21, 2007 With 47 members, open to all members arts & literature group

This group is for all the musicians at ModDB. I place to show off their work and to discuss music. You could also ask for help for a song or give suggestions...

Old Timers

Old Timers

Established Nov 09, 2007 With 56 members, must apply to join official group

For all the old skool modders that have stuck by Mod DB from v1 to v4. A lot has changed as over the years as the site moved from a dark v1 to a bright...

Original Game Creators

Original Game Creators

Established Nov 19, 2007 With 6 members, must apply to join development & publishing group

Truly dedicated to the "make something different" ethos of modding, members of the Original Game Creators refuse to use other people's intellectual property...

Undertone: Music and Sound Team

Undertone: Music and Sound Team

Established Nov 10, 2007 With 60 members, must apply to join arts & literature group

Undertone is a music and sound based team. A "guild" of musicians in the mod scene. If your mod is in need of sound engineers or composers to create full...

Zero SFX

Zero SFX

Established Jan 05, 2008 With 25 members, open to all members arts & literature company

Zero SFX is an Audio Production Company based in Seattle/Marysville WA. If you are looking for Audio Production for Games or film look no further. Feel...

Comments  (80 - 90 of 107)
Halloween4
Halloween4 Dec 8 2007, 5:58am says:

Continuing on the subject of people contacting you in reguard to joining our group who are not lone modders.

Is the person we are talking about here 'esfumato', if so you want to watch this guy as he is a bit underhand.

I was the one who put him on to you about our group as he contacted me saying could I vote in the awards for him as he was another lone modder & he had voted for me, but then I found out that he isn't a lone modder at all, he is just trying to get peoples votes any way he can. But it dosen't matter anyway, for even though I told him I had voted for him I didn't because I believe in voting for mods because you think that they are going to win, not because the modders have voted for you, & I hate it when people vote for you, just to get your vote, as it's not realy saying anything about my work.

But continuing on the subject of 'esfumato', I also posted a comment under the MONTY's start up news post saying I think there should be an award for lone modders, to which he left a message agreeing, but then further down the page he left a message saying that he disagreed, so I don't think he realy knows what he's going on about. He just seems like a bit of an idiot to me, but that's my opinion.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Karuto
Karuto Dec 7 2007, 6:23pm says:

That's alright. It's obviously anime-inspired, so it doesn't matter. And I think the video is great. Lots of flippies and whatnot. I wouldn't worry about the video at all, because people do understand that using a regular ingame video recorder does produce some lag. So long as you mention it that's all that needs to be done. Keep up the great work. I like what I see! Quite impressive.

+1 vote     reply to comment
five_damned_dollarz
five_damned_dollarz Dec 7 2007, 4:39pm says:

Will do :P

+1 vote     reply to comment
Aeneas2020
Aeneas2020 Dec 7 2007, 12:38pm says:

Yeh no worries mate, not really sure why people dont seem to like DCD its original and innovative...i guess that could be the reason a lot of people just want medal of honor clones (says me making a ww2 mod :s) but u know what i mean.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Halloween4
Halloween4 Dec 7 2007, 11:49am says:

QUOTE:I've been getting a lot of weird LM join requests from ppl who seem unclear on the concept, ppl who have no mods listed under their profiles and ppl who are part of a team. I guess the group name is misleading somehow.

How clear does the name have to be, i.e LONE ( alone ), & MODDERS ( you make mods ), I don't think some people are playing with a full deck.

Perhaps we should call it, THE PEOPLE THAT MAKE MODS ON THEIR ONW & NOT WITH OTHER PEOPLE GROUP.....just jocking, but then you knew that as you've got some intelligence.

No, don't change the name as I don't think it can be any clearer, just change the subtext to more or less something like I put above, that should stop the wrong people bothering you about it.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Halloween4
Halloween4 Dec 7 2007, 9:37am says:

No, once you've uploaded the files to the L4Y site, which is the site we are talking about, you no longer have access to that uploaded file on their server. Not even to delete it.

But thaks anyway....;)

+1 vote     reply to comment
Aeneas2020
Aeneas2020 Dec 7 2007, 8:05am says:

wow mike u got a -15% influence score how did that happen lol? well that sux, hopefully see some updates from you soon.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Halloween4
Halloween4 Dec 7 2007, 9:41am replied:

I got 62% influence & 100% Karma, which is funny as I thought that my recent comments over the video servers were upsetting a lot of people.

Perhaps more people agree with me then I thought......:)

+1 vote     reply to comment
Halloween4
Halloween4 Dec 7 2007, 7:40am says:

Thanks for the info but my video's aren't uploaded to my oficial web pages as I can't do this, as you can only upload the video's to the downloads section of a particual game itself & not to your web pages.

Also, you can't watch the video's from the site either, just download them to watch.

However, I've already uploaded my video's to this site & I have no real interest in uploading them to anywhere else, as there are 4 or them & it took so long to do.

Also, I think that you got me wrong when I was going on about the video servers, as my comment's weren'tabout me as I couldn't care less if my video's are showing or not as the game I mod for has very little following any more in the modding world so I have no illusions of winning either with or withoout a video. No, my comment's were far play for all modders.

But Cheers anyway mate......;)

+1 vote     reply to comment
ambershee
ambershee Dec 6 2007, 4:34pm says:

It's looking pretty good. If you want an uber high quality video, if all else fails you can get a TV-Out cable, record it to DVD and then rip it from the DVD to your machine. Bit long winded and requires a DVD recorder though.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Post a Comment

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the Mod DB community today (totally free) and do things you never thought possible.

Avatar
Avatar
Offline Since
May 13, 2008
Country
United States United States
Gender
Male
Age
31
Member Watch
Track this member
Accolades
Old Timers
Statistics
Karma
1%
Rank
19,581 of 19,591
Activity Points
1,016
Influence
68% negative
Watchers
0 members
Time Online
6 days
Site Visits
4,123
Profile Visitors
2,930 (15 today)
Contact
Homepage
Mikejkelley.com
Private Message
Send Now
Email
Members Only
BlueWolf72
BlueWolf72
friends since Nov 16, 2007
ambershee
ambershee
friends since Nov 16, 2007
San-J
San-J
friends since Nov 16, 2007
Maddieman
Maddieman
friends since Dec 08, 2007
Chunky
Chunky
friends since Nov 16, 2007
Karuto
Karuto
friends since Nov 16, 2007
Baza
Baza
friends since Nov 17, 2007
Scottishdragoon
Scottishdragoon
friends since Dec 16, 2007
TKAzA
TKAzA
friends since Nov 16, 2007
methulah
methulah
friends since Nov 16, 2007