Report article Mods of 2004

After 2 months, 8 thousand votes and 1.4 million mod profile visitors, the 2004 Golden Spanner Mod of the Year Awards have been decided, by you the visitors and gamers who know best. Read on for the results & analysis!

Posted by INtense! on Jan 5th, 2005 digg this super bookmark Page 2 of 15    
Article


MOTY Image

3rd. Project Revolution

Project Revolution is a WarCraft3 : Frozen Throne Mod, that will turn StarCraft:BroodWar into 3D. With the release of the new Website comes a nifty gift to the community: Spinners. Spinners are gif animations of our Unit models, turning them 360°, so you can take a close look at them from every angle. And what a great view is too.. great models and this award is certainly deserved and great to see a non-FPS mod receive such recognition!

Zerg Devourer High Poly Devourer Spinner Ultralisk Spinner

2nd. MechMod

The Mechmod team has already released a primary Alpha 1.0 version of the mod, which was based on mechs taken from the Gundam and Macross/Robotech series. Alpha 1.0 was a 'test' release which the team put together while waiting for Half-Life 2 to go public, and the Alpha is also considered as a stepping stone towards something much bigger and with sweet huge mech-models who can complain?

Mechs Mechs

1st. Insurgency

The Insurgency team spends a lot of time perfecting all of our art so that it looks great ingame and makes the game feel realistic not only in the way its played but how it looks. There are a lot of people working on the art, whether it be models or skins in the mod, to make it look as good as it does. There's Spydr, who did most of the weapon models, Fiblah who did quite a few, Spezz who did a couple, and Jeremy who did some. However, the models would be nothing if it weren't for the wonderful skinners on the team; DarkNemesis, Polygon, and Seth. Jeremy spends lots of time perfecting the character models to make them how they will eventually turn out by the time the mod will release. Expect the artwork to only improve as the time ticks down to release. From hanging in the teams chat room they appreciate all of you who appreciate all of our hard work in the artwork/modelling part of the mod!

Official Karkar Screenshot #4 Official Karkar Screenshot #6

Comments  (0 - 50 of 73)
San-J
San-J Jan 16 2005, 2:00pm says:

W00t! What an excellent feature! I love the looks of SC2.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Michael
Michael Jan 16 2005, 2:02pm says:

Congrats to all.

+1 vote     reply to comment
chis
chis Jan 16 2005, 2:02pm says:

leetcaxe

+1 vote     reply to comment
lillbrorsan
lillbrorsan Jan 16 2005, 2:02pm says:

Good job!

+1 vote     reply to comment
duckedtapedemon
duckedtapedemon Jan 16 2005, 2:03pm says:

Congrats!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Karuto
Karuto Jan 16 2005, 2:08pm says:

Congratulations to all of the winners!

Although, IOS should be #1 Sports Game. It appears people crowded around to vote RO for every award on here ;)

+1 vote     reply to comment
Sajt
Sajt Jan 16 2005, 2:23pm says:

Red Orchestra doesn't look like it has the slightest thing to do with sports...

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 16 2005, 2:26pm says:

As much as I love RO, I don't think there's anything to do with sports.
Unless there's some soccer mini game hidden in there somewhere...

+1 vote     reply to comment
Anubis612
Anubis612 Jan 16 2005, 2:31pm says:

congrats to all the mods featured here and especially to red orchestra the whole mod team and all of the ex devs (polygon merca jeremy) deserve praise for their work on ro and because of them red orchestra has gotten to this point. Once again congratulations to all mods and I myself am wondering why moddb counts ro as a sports mod lol

+1 vote     reply to comment
jacksonj04
jacksonj04 Jan 16 2005, 2:42pm says:

Red Orchestra won the Best Sports Mod award since its profile quite clearly stated it to be a Sports mod. This has since been corrected, but to adjust the votes would badly skew everything else. Sorry guys!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Aquilo
Aquilo Jan 16 2005, 2:47pm says:

Great article/awards :D
Strange that there were no roleplaying-mods though.

+1 vote     reply to comment
wilsonam
wilsonam Jan 16 2005, 4:17pm says:

Well, we're really sorry - RO was logged as a "Sports mod" sometime back in the dim and distant past. Since been corrected, but obviously too late for the comp!

International Online Soccer and Deathball should be read as being in 1st and 2nd places in their category, really...

+1 vote     reply to comment
wilsonam
wilsonam Jan 16 2005, 4:20pm says:

A quick correction from the RO team:

We have won the FPS prize for Phases 2, 3 and 4 of the MSU contest, plus some sound prizes - but not the whole thing! We wish :) But the winners haven't been announced on that one yet and we still have our fingers crossed!

+1 vote     reply to comment
[CC]Nimrod
[CC]Nimrod Jan 16 2005, 4:40pm says:

Congratulations to all of the winners, and Red Orchestra in particular! Like I said in my previous comment, this mod really stands out from other WWII games. I'll be sure to check out some of the other mods in those categories, some of them look really interesting. Once again, congrats to all of the modmakers - your creative products make the 'gaming industry' much more interesting and colorful. GG!

+1 vote     reply to comment
outlive
outlive Jan 16 2005, 4:56pm says:

no RPG's where nominated ?
you gota be kidding me !!!
i voted for a RPG, so the vote counts - and i think, a dozen other people voted for RPG's too
this spanner award thing is so stupid...even a WW2 mod got 1st at Sports (!!!!)

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 16 2005, 5:11pm says:

Galactic conquest didnt even get a mention. How on earth can people not even mention galactic conquest. its a damn travisty.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Ap
Ap Jan 16 2005, 5:17pm says:

On behalf of Game-Panel.com, we would like to congratulate all of the mods, we hope that with these awards and our sponsorship here, will help the mod community in receiving recognition on all the hard work that you do. Congrats to the winners, we will see you here again in 2005!

+1 vote     reply to comment
INtense!
INtense! Jan 16 2005, 6:10pm says:

bring on the riots and arguements i say :D happens every year, only this year i have to say the results reflect the voice of 8,000 gamers and i believe they got it all pretty spot on.

hopefully next year the results will reflect the voice of 16,000 gamers and prove an even more accurate reflection of everyones voice and opinion

+1 vote     reply to comment
ShortCutMan
ShortCutMan Jan 16 2005, 6:28pm says:

And also next year, people will have their profiles correct. :P

Congrates to Sven-Coop 2 and Red Orchestra for winning their respective awards, and also to all the other winners in the categories they were nominated for. Good Job guys!

+1 vote     reply to comment
mystery8
mystery8 Jan 16 2005, 6:57pm says:

Congrats to the winners and good work to the organizers. Didn't even know about UT2004's Utopia Online and that looks pretty cool. Pity Snow War HL didn't get mentioned, but the results leave me no reason to riot. Well, maybe just for the fun of it.... *grabs a crowbar & flame thrower*

+1 vote     reply to comment
Hp-P00nst3r
Hp-P00nst3r Jan 16 2005, 7:29pm says:

whats so great about sven coop for HL? I played it for awhile and it got repetitive really fast

+1 vote     reply to comment
Jimi
Jimi Jan 16 2005, 7:39pm says:

Woah! I'm surprised :D

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 16 2005, 7:50pm says:

Congratulations, but I still can't believe SS2845 lost to a graphics remake of SC! Nooo!!! Congratulations all the same. ^_^

+1 vote     reply to comment
AdrianShephard
AdrianShephard Jan 16 2005, 8:40pm says:

Congrats Guys. :D

+1 vote     reply to comment
ForK
ForK Jan 16 2005, 8:41pm says:

wow, not the results i expected but 'as voted by you!'

+1 vote     reply to comment
TwwIX
TwwIX Jan 16 2005, 9:25pm says:

fuckin lame
you people have no taste whatsoever

+1 vote     reply to comment
MaSaKaRi
MaSaKaRi Jan 16 2005, 11:29pm says:

Well, while the moddb team worked hard, i mean the following as constructive criticism:
1) you guys really should have noticed the Red Orchestra as sports mod thing. I don't agree adjusting anything would skew anything - RO should be disqualified from the sports category, and put in the action category instead, as it should be, not as first, but depending on it's votes.
2) what the hell is Xel'Naga Vengeance doing as the 3rd best RTS mod??? The Mod was closed down by the copyrights holders Blizzard, and never finished. That ALONE would be sufficient to desqualify it from the 2004 Mod Awards. I understand wanting fans to decide this, but one thing is being unbiased, another one is being unreasonable.

As understandable, since this is voted by fans, they tended to only care about the bigger mods, or be a bit weird. The three best websites are not bad, far from it, but they aren't anything special either. There are A LOT of better websites out there, i work at webdesign professionally, i do know what i'm talking about.
And since when does Cold War Crisis (best model textures) have better model textures than Forgotten Hope, Point of Existence, SS2845, or any major FPS mod for that matter??? The only reason they look so good from other Generals mods is because they're using skins with much higher resolutions than the other mods, which really taxes your computer, but of course that isn't taken into account in this vote...
The fan issues i can understand, there are weird choices here, just what people like (every half-assed Starcraft mod would make this list if it were up to the fans). But the two issues i raised above are the responsability of the ModDB crew, and should have been adressed prior to this.
Still, good job ModDB crew, here's to a great 2005 full of great mods! :)

0 votes     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 12:49am says:

I thought screwed up voting was just something that Florida was good at. The sports mod gaffe certainly showed a lack of professionalism but then to brush it off and not make things right?! Really invalidates your contest. Shame on you.

+1 vote     reply to comment
Aircraftkiller
Aircraftkiller Jan 17 2005, 2:41am says:

I didn't expect RA would take second place for level design, considering I did the levels for it, along with the buildings... Many thanks to those who voted for us!

+1 vote     reply to comment
routetwo
routetwo Jan 17 2005, 3:27am says:

It's a disgrace that IOS is put into second place by a WW2 mod to be honest.

+1 vote     reply to comment
ViperUK
ViperUK Jan 17 2005, 4:01am says:

So....2004 awards where the winner is not even in the right category :D

+1 vote     reply to comment
ViperUK
ViperUK Jan 17 2005, 4:04am says:

I think Counter Strike should have won the sports category...

+1 vote     reply to comment
PingKing
PingKing Jan 17 2005, 4:36am says:

This is fucking ridiculous. Where's the problem in just kicking Red Orchestra out of the competition since it's a freaking WW2 Mod. Is it so much work to set IOS as winner?

+1 vote     reply to comment
dfulcrum
dfulcrum Jan 17 2005, 5:17am says:

new HL2/HL mods cleaned up rather nicely.

great job to all the teams featured here.

+1 vote     reply to comment
maShine
maShine Jan 17 2005, 5:52am says:

no comment to the sports category
it is only shaming

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 6:25am says:

RENalert SUX, AIRCRAFTKILLER DOESN'T EVEN SUPPORT THE RENEGADE ENGINE NOW AND DISS's IT WHENEVER HE HAS THE CHANCE.
WHY SHOULD THIS MOD BE RELATED TO RENEGADE WHEN THE TEAM LEADER DOESN'T GIVE A STUFF?>???

DIE IN HELL ACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 6:36am says:

Natural Selection > almost all commercial games and mods.

+1 vote     reply to comment
KleRoi
KleRoi Jan 17 2005, 6:42am says:

This is so stupid.... a worldwar2 mod in a sport competition... can't you just see that it's not a sport game? Is it so hard to understand it and to erase it from the competition? IOS rulez.

+1 vote     reply to comment
INtense!
INtense! Jan 17 2005, 6:50am says:

Ok you guys are right, and we have caved in to the pressure.. its just wrong to have Red Orchestra as best sports mod when it clearly isn't a sports mod at all...

hence the sports mod results have now been corrected and has made the top 3!! Furthermore, has been moved to its rightful category 'Action Mods' and given an equal 1st position with Sven-Coop!

+1 vote     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 8:06am says:

+1 vote     reply to comment
wilsonam
wilsonam Jan 17 2005, 8:21am says:

@ INtense: thanks for clearing that up for everyone, mate, and apologies from the RO crew for the misunderstanding! It was one of those dumb things that happen...

+1 vote     reply to comment
PingKing
PingKing Jan 17 2005, 8:42am says:

Thanks for doing the right thing and declaring ios as winner.

+1 vote     reply to comment
PingKing
PingKing Jan 17 2005, 8:43am says:

meant moddb of course :<

+1 vote     reply to comment
TheRambo
TheRambo Jan 17 2005, 10:15am says:

Congratulations to everyone !! :D Nice Work!!

+1 vote     reply to comment
MaSaKaRi
MaSaKaRi Jan 17 2005, 11:33am says:

Glad to see you guys came around, INtense. Nicely done :)

0 votes     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 1:26pm says:

Kind of nitpicking here but is mixing up mods with total cinversions really recognizing the work and quality thats put into these projects? No one is a bigger HL2 fan than I am but lets face it, voting HL2 Sven over the Starsiege TS as well as the W3 TS just screams popularity contest. The latter two have an enourmous amount of new assets made specifically for the game and implemented in such a way that its impossible to tell that these were done by "amateur" teams.

I think modding is evolving into its own sub-genres and perhaps we need to start recognizing that.

+1 vote     reply to comment
MaSaKaRi
MaSaKaRi Jan 17 2005, 1:58pm says:

You do have a point, but where do we draw the line? That's the issue here.
Furthermore, you have to realize "fan awards" are basically just a popularity contest, otherwise you wouldn't have stuff like Cold War Crisis winning Best Model Textures, or The First Tiberium War and Xel'Nagas Vengeance as the 2nd and 3rd Best RTS Mods. For example, PlanetC&C recently reviewed Tiberium War and they got 55% gameplay, 65% overall, and mine, for example, Capellan Solution, got 95% gameplay, and 85% overall.
People just voted on them because they are a mod of the original C&C (a big classic in gaming), and the other a Starcraft mod, which IMO should have been desqualified because they were closed down, and will never be finished. Like i said in a previous post, every half-assed Starcraft mod will make this list if it's up to the fans. These depend heavily on the base material (known franchises, for example).
It's great to see stuff in there like Ghost Ops, Natural Selection, HL Rally, and ZooW, just to name a few.

Bottom line, in fan awards you will get what's more popular (you see here mods based on Dragonball Z, Starcraft, Star Wars, WWII, Matrix). I don't consider these awards to feature the best modding has to offer, just the most popular. And as you know, sometimes what's popular is the best, sometimes it's just hype.
I don't want anyone to think this is a rant at any particular mod, i am just stating my point of view - the winners are to be congratulated, and winning this is great. Just don't read this thinking they are modding's "best of the best", because several of them aren't.

0 votes     reply to comment
Guest
Guest Jan 17 2005, 2:19pm says:

I probably shouldve read more closely. Wasn't aware that it was reader driven numbers. Given that, I'm surprised SS showed up.

+1 vote     reply to comment
INtense!
INtense! Jan 17 2005, 4:12pm says:
Quote:Kind of nitpicking here but is mixing up mods with total cinversions really recognizing the work and quality thats put into these projects? No one is a bigger HL2 fan than I am but lets face it, voting HL2 Sven over the Starsiege TS as well as the W3 TS just screams popularity contest. The latter two have an enourmous amount of new assets made specifically for the game and implemented in such a way that its impossible to tell that these were done by "amateur" teams.

I think modding is evolving into its own sub-genres and perhaps we need to start recognizing that.


This is a very real problem we faced / considered and as stated perfectly, a line needs to be drawn somewhere. In the end we decided to go with the feature you see here whereby people vote for mod of the year and also for different design elements (best models, maps etc..). This does mean that the competition largely ends up as a popularity contest, however to have sub-categories and break it down further would just result in an even more confusing system with 300 winners.

The aim of this comp was to recognise the best mods irrelevant of game, and i believe we have done that quite well.

+1 vote     reply to comment
BlueWolf72
BlueWolf72 Jan 17 2005, 4:13pm says:

We allowed you to suggest mods to us and we would select what we thought was good and bad and didnt have you the user vote. This was our first year doing that.

mods of 2003

Moddb.com

mods of 2002

Moddb.com

+1 vote     reply to comment
Post a Comment

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free) and do things you never thought possible.

Feature
Browse
Features
Report Abuse
Report article
Bookmark
Digg Super bookmark
Related Mods
Sven Co-op (Half-Life)
Sven Co-op
Half-Life - Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
HL Rally (Half-Life)
HL Rally
Half-Life - Multiplayer Racing
Natural Selection (Half-Life)
Natural Selection
Half-Life - Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Earth's Special Forces (Half-Life)
Earth's Special Forces
Half-Life - Single & Multiplayer Third Person Shooter
The Specialists (Half-Life)
The Specialists
Half-Life - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
G.H.O.S.T. Ops: The Avalon Project (Half-Life)
G.H.O.S.T. Ops: The Avalon Project
Half-Life - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Half-Life: Nightwatch (Half-Life)
Half-Life: Nightwatch
Half-Life - Single Player First Person Shooter
The Trenches (Half-Life)
The Trenches
Half-Life - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
International Online Soccer (Half-Life)
International Online Soccer
Half-Life - Multiplayer Alternative Sport
Red Orchestra (Unreal Tournament 2004)
Red Orchestra
Unreal Tournament 2004 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Duffers Golf (Unreal Tournament 2004)
Duffers Golf
Unreal Tournament 2004 - Single & Multiplayer Alternative Sport
UnWheel (Unreal Tournament 2004)
UnWheel
Unreal Tournament 2004 - Single & Multiplayer Racing
UnrealSpeed (Unreal Tournament 2003)
UnrealSpeed
Unreal Tournament 2003 - Single & Multiplayer Racing
StarKiller (C&C Generals: Zero Hour)
StarKiller
C&C Generals: Zero Hour - Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Sven Co-op II (Half-Life 2)
Sven Co-op II
Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
MechMod (Half-Life)
MechMod
Half-Life - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Jedi: Timeline (Half-Life 2)
Jedi: Timeline
Half-Life 2 - Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Utopian Realms (Unreal Tournament 3)
Utopian Realms
Unreal Tournament 3 - Single & Multiplayer Virtual Life
Cold War Crisis (C&C Generals: Zero Hour)
Cold War Crisis
C&C Generals: Zero Hour - Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Bloodthirst (Half-Life 2)
Bloodthirst
Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Point Defense Systems (V13) (Homeworld 2)
Point Defense Systems (V13)
Homeworld 2 - Single & Multiplayer Realistic Sim
Shattered Horizons (Half-Life 2)
Shattered Horizons
Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Deathball (Unreal Tournament 2004)
Deathball
Unreal Tournament 2004 - Single & Multiplayer Alternative Sport
Insurgency (Half-Life 2)
Insurgency
Half-Life 2 - Multiplayer First Person Shooter
The First Tiberian War (C&C Generals: Zero Hour)
The First Tiberian War
C&C Generals: Zero Hour - Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Project Revolution (Warcraft III)
Project Revolution
Warcraft III - Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Pathways Redux (Doom III)
Pathways Redux
Doom III - Single Player Adventure
Black Mesa (Half-Life 2)
Black Mesa
Half-Life 2 - Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Forgotten Hope (BattleField 1942)
Forgotten Hope
BattleField 1942 - Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Related Games
Half-Life
Half-Life
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Doom III
Doom III
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Unreal Tournament 2003
Unreal Tournament 2003
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
BattleField 1942
BattleField 1942
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Warcraft III
Warcraft III
Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Homeworld 2
Homeworld 2
Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Half-Life 2
Half-Life 2
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
Unreal Tournament 2004
Unreal Tournament 2004
Single & Multiplayer First Person Shooter
C&C Generals: Zero Hour
C&C Generals: Zero Hour
Single & Multiplayer Real Time Strategy
Red Alert: A Path Beyond
Red Alert: A Path Beyond Indie
Multiplayer First Person Shooter
SS:2845
SS:2845 Indie
Single & Multiplayer Realistic Sim
Related Groups
Bluehell Productions
Bluehell Productions
Developer & Publisher with 35 members
Unknown Worlds
Unknown Worlds
Developer & Publisher with 5 members
Cold War Crisis Mod-Team
Cold War Crisis Mod-Team
Developer & Publisher with 4 members
2004 Mod of the Year Awards
2004 Mod of the Year Awards
Official event with 16 members
Black Mesa Dev Team
Black Mesa Dev Team
Developer & Publisher with 22 members
Forgotten Hope Devs
Forgotten Hope Devs
Developer & Publisher with 19 members
Snowflake Entertainment
Snowflake Entertainment
Developer & Publisher with 4 members
Insurgency Team
Insurgency Team
Developer & Publisher with 2 members
ESF developers
ESF developers
Developer & Publisher with 10 members
SC Team
SC Team
Developer & Publisher with 2 members